This Isn't Something That Exclusively Affects Nonbinary People, But For Reasons I'm Gonna Get Into, We're

this isn't something that exclusively affects nonbinary people, but for reasons i'm gonna get into, we're disproportionately and the most obviously affected by this.

whether we'd like to admit it or not: the trans community has a problem with bioessentialism and is at times just as obsessed over genitals at birth as cis people are.

it becomes really obvious when you look at how nonbinary people are grouped into amab and afab, transmasc or transfem. for trans men, everyone assumes they were born with a vagina, for trans women, everyone assumes they were born with a penis. with those terms, it's easy for people to make assumptions about "where they came from", i.e. what genitals they were born with. of course in these ideas, there is no room for intersex experiences.

nonbinary is more vague and doesn't have "built-in" assumptions about AGAB or genitals at birth. and people hate that. i believe it's one of the main reasons why people are obsessed with dividing us into amab and afab.

but many people have realised that this isn't a good look, so instead they divide us into transmasc and transfem. if trans men are assumed to all be afab and have vaginas at birth, then so are all transmascs. of transfems are assumed to all be amab and have penises at birth, then so are all transfems. (note: this is not at all about people self-identifying as transmasc or transfem, but rather about people using them as collective descriptors.) nonbinary people are constantly confronted with questions like "are you transmasc or transfem?" by other trans people, trying to figure out "where we came from". nonbinary people confuse most people, and most people can't sit with that at all. transmasc and transfem as collective terms like this are considered less bad than amab and afab, because at least they don't refer to agab anymore, so we're not allowed to say anything. ignore the fact that these terms are misgendering many of us and painting a linear picture of the gender spectrum.

i'm very sure that this is also why people hate afab transfems and amab transmascs so much. if transmasc no longer automatically means afab, and transfem no longer automatically means amab, then these terms have supposedly "lost all meaning", because whatever will i do if i don't know what genitals someone was born with.

because let's be real, that's what the obsession with AGAB comes down to. you were born with either a vagina or a penis and that will shape all of your trans experiences. once again ignoring intersex people or any sort of diversity in people's upbringing. it's bioessentialism.

and because nonbinary as a label is free from agab assumptions, we're called by these extra terms that we may or may not identify with way more often. not only are we reduced to our bodies, we're also misgendered and/or consistently related back to our agab in the process.

More Posts from Fuckifellagain and Others

3 weeks ago

art idea i've had since last night

digital drawing of Sanrio character Dear Daniel holding a vial of testosterone cypionate out to the viewer, while clutching a bandage in teh other hand. the caption "let's take testosterone together" appears at the top of the image
2 months ago

So like, is a trans woman who likes the smell of gasoline simply not a real trans woman now? Because only male-brained people like the smell of gasoline because Man Like Car Vroom Vroom Car Manly

The idea that gender is biological or linked to anything biological is bioessentialism. Aside from being intersexist, this idea is ALSO transphobic.

This is just "gender is what's in your pants" but with neurobiology most of you don't know jack shit about.

So Like, Is A Trans Woman Who Likes The Smell Of Gasoline Simply Not A Real Trans Woman Now? Because

The brain is not sexually dimorphic to the point you could call ANY brain 'sexed', in any capacity. The structures within the brain that vary in size in relation to sex traits (insula, left amygdala, hippocampus, claustrum, pallidum, and a few others) are slight, and only loosely connected. These traits are sexually dimorphic only in a non-rigid way, such as height or facial proportions. Being tall is not seen as a strictly 'male' trait the way having a beard or testicles is. Being short is not seen as a strictly 'female' trait the same way having a uterus or breasts is.

We don't call tall cis women or short cis men intersex, why the hell would we call people with slightly uncommon neurological structures vaguely associated with sex intersex? Not to mention, we have literally no idea if these neurobiological variances are even what causes gender dysphoria.

By nature of these things being averages; There are cis people with these brain differences who are literally perfectly fine being cis and have no dysphoria. There are trans people without them with dysphoria so debilitating they don't go outside and prefer showering with the light off.

Further on dysphoria, I dislike the way it is all called "gender dysphoria", as if social dysphoria and physical dysphoria are the same thing. You can wish to change your sex traits REGARDLESS of your gender identity. Yes. Cis people can have dysphoria and can go on HRT and get surgeries because they have gender dysphoria, without ever changing their pronouns, going by a different name, or identifying as a different gender. Trans people can be comfortable with their bodies despite fully identifying as a different gender, getting a new name, pronouns, etc.

Gender is social. Not biological. The idea of "biological gender" is inherently transmedicalist.

Aside from this, co-opting intersexuality and making it about perisex people because your dad has weird double standards regarding intersex & perisex trans people is absolutely unacceptable. Fighting intersexism with more intersexism just makes you (shocker), an intersexist.

Your parents said "Only intersex people can be trans", and instead of responding with "no, that's wrong, here's why-", you went "You're right! All trans people are intersex", how on earth does agreeing with your parents' bigotry help intersex or trans people?

1 year ago
Happy Silly Day Trafficblr
Happy Silly Day Trafficblr
Happy Silly Day Trafficblr
Happy Silly Day Trafficblr
Happy Silly Day Trafficblr
Happy Silly Day Trafficblr
Happy Silly Day Trafficblr
Happy Silly Day Trafficblr
Happy Silly Day Trafficblr
Happy Silly Day Trafficblr

happy silly day trafficblr


Tags
5 months ago

Reblog with the highest mountain in your state or country and whether or not you’ve at least attempted to climb it.


Tags
1 year ago
My Fucked Up Alien Rodent Brother

my fucked up alien rodent brother


Tags
4 months ago
tumblr reply reading "it actually does matter because when the emts need to adminster drugs to you, your genetic sex definitely matters a fuckin lot"

the euphemistic nonsensical phrasing of transphobia constantly gets me. like I know it's just bad faith bullshit, but just the implication of an EMT needing to do karyotype testing before treating someone is so absurd it feels like the premise of an over the top satirical comedy sketch about transphobia

1 year ago

Imagine a world where homosexuality was still in the DSM but society had moved gradually toward some moderate acceptance of queer people, but only with the understanding that we are sick and that leading out our queer lives is medically necessary for us. in this paradigm, a person would have to get diagnosed with homosexuality by a psychiatrist in order to be permitted to have gay sex

this is basically the reality that trans people are living in right now. and that's for those of us that are lucky enough to live in a place where we *are* allowed to lead out trans lives once we get gender dysphoria written down in our medical charts

1 month ago

idk where all of this weed-smoke discourse erupted from, but “weed is fine and you shouldn’t be a snitch about it” and “don’t burn plant matter in public spaces where someone you don’t know might have, like, a lung condition” are two sentiments that can and do coexist. i have asthma and i hang out with stoners pretty much constantly. i’ve never felt the urge to snitch and no one has ever blatantly disrespected my avoidance of smoke. they’re always eager to help keep it away from me when needed, which isn’t difficult to do. i hate to say this, but my only takeaway from a hypothetical scenario in which a stoner is blasting weed smoke in public like a dragon and an asthmatic feels the need to involve the cops is that both individuals are unpleasant and i don’t want to be around either of them lmao

1 year ago
Frends Is When U Have A Bud (who Makes Ur Awful Job Slightly Less Awful)
Frends Is When U Have A Bud (who Makes Ur Awful Job Slightly Less Awful)

frends is when u have a bud (who makes ur awful job slightly less awful)

(dont tag as ship pleas ^_^;)


Tags
  • eowyn-igneelcheshire
    eowyn-igneelcheshire reblogged this · 3 weeks ago
  • stormandsparks
    stormandsparks liked this · 3 weeks ago
  • invisiblesketches
    invisiblesketches liked this · 4 weeks ago
  • autisticbee
    autisticbee liked this · 4 weeks ago
  • steampunk-llama
    steampunk-llama liked this · 4 weeks ago
  • outreescapist
    outreescapist liked this · 1 month ago
  • a-very-funny-username
    a-very-funny-username liked this · 1 month ago
  • automaticstarfishparadise
    automaticstarfishparadise liked this · 1 month ago
  • divinecircuits
    divinecircuits reblogged this · 1 month ago
  • cassachino
    cassachino liked this · 1 month ago
  • aroacemagicstar
    aroacemagicstar liked this · 1 month ago
  • smoke-glass
    smoke-glass reblogged this · 1 month ago
  • smoke-glass
    smoke-glass liked this · 1 month ago
  • http-501
    http-501 liked this · 1 month ago
  • altamira-a
    altamira-a liked this · 1 month ago
  • eowyn-igneelcheshire
    eowyn-igneelcheshire reblogged this · 1 month ago
  • phantom-phreakazoid
    phantom-phreakazoid reblogged this · 1 month ago
  • phantom-phreakazoid
    phantom-phreakazoid liked this · 1 month ago
  • wings-and-cherry-blossoms
    wings-and-cherry-blossoms liked this · 1 month ago
  • allegedlyiwrite
    allegedlyiwrite liked this · 1 month ago
  • insertkaomojihere
    insertkaomojihere liked this · 1 month ago
  • plum-petunia
    plum-petunia liked this · 1 month ago
  • tiorx
    tiorx reblogged this · 1 month ago
  • jax-the-destroyer-of-lgbtphobes
    jax-the-destroyer-of-lgbtphobes liked this · 1 month ago
  • spiritcaesar
    spiritcaesar liked this · 1 month ago
  • enderlaith01
    enderlaith01 liked this · 1 month ago
  • orgasmic-cereal
    orgasmic-cereal liked this · 1 month ago
  • lordmothula
    lordmothula liked this · 1 month ago
  • justanotherchangeling
    justanotherchangeling reblogged this · 1 month ago
  • justanotherchangeling
    justanotherchangeling liked this · 1 month ago
  • viviaaan
    viviaaan liked this · 1 month ago
  • anarchy-flagz
    anarchy-flagz liked this · 1 month ago
  • theproxy066
    theproxy066 reblogged this · 1 month ago
  • thebendiestenby
    thebendiestenby liked this · 1 month ago
  • theproxy066
    theproxy066 reblogged this · 1 month ago
  • theproxy066
    theproxy066 liked this · 1 month ago
  • leotheloaf
    leotheloaf liked this · 1 month ago
  • fireboaserpent
    fireboaserpent liked this · 1 month ago
  • ditheringtouhoufan
    ditheringtouhoufan liked this · 1 month ago
  • benvoliobird
    benvoliobird liked this · 1 month ago
  • sideflorfauna
    sideflorfauna liked this · 1 month ago
  • a-normal-panda-bitch
    a-normal-panda-bitch liked this · 1 month ago
  • astersselves
    astersselves liked this · 1 month ago
  • funky-lill-communist
    funky-lill-communist reblogged this · 1 month ago
  • funky-lill-communist
    funky-lill-communist liked this · 1 month ago
  • scp3199
    scp3199 reblogged this · 1 month ago
  • scp3199
    scp3199 liked this · 1 month ago
  • alphazed
    alphazed liked this · 1 month ago

He/him 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿🏳️‍⚧️

481 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags