I Want To Get This Off My Chest Regarding The Star Wars Fandom, Especially The Clone Wars And Bad Batch

I want to get this off my chest regarding the Star Wars fandom, especially the Clone Wars and Bad Batch fans, because it's something that's been bothering me for a bit. This may come across as controversial to some and fall upon deaf ears, but I want to address this in the nicest, most encouraging, smartest way possible. This also isn't a callout to anyone, it's just something I've observed!

Everyone in the fandom (specifically TCW and TBB people) is all for clone individuality and advocacy until they aren't. When it comes to a particular clone they don't like, it's no longer convenient for them to love all clones, and then all bets are off.

Take the fandom's treatment of Cody and Bly, for example.

Cody and Bly's worths and personalities have been reduced to solely their Jedi Generals to a disgusting degree. Whenever I look for Cody content specifically (and I've checked the "commander bly" tag too for confirmation), it's just oversaturated with Codywan content. Even in the non-Codywan-specific posts, you can't find a sentence with Commander Cody that doesn't also mention Obi-Wan Kenobi. Not to mention male characters (especially) portrayed platonically in media can't *just* be friends anymore, but that's a whole other issue for another day 😅 Bly is the same way; whenever there's a sentence with Commander Bly in it, Aayla Secura just happens to *magically* appear. That's so unfair to Cody and Bly.

Then take Fox, for example. Fox has less screen time than Cody, but he is still given an entire multifaceted personality, and even a fan-created face to a name. It makes no sense that Cody and Bly aren't given the same kind of care and attention. Obviously you can make fanon personalities (because that's part of the fun of participating in fandoms!), but they shouldn't be reductive, insult the character, and not do the character justice. Thanks to TBB S2, more light is shed on Cody's personality (and hopefully, fingers crossed, we see more Cody and Bly in another season of TBB, so Bly's definitive personality is addressed and developed more. It's what he deserves 😌). Cody is so much more than just Obi-Wan's sidekick: he's stern and by-the-book (however, his orthodoxy has its limits, and he uses his own judgment in various situations), but he's very caring, loyal, kind, intelligent, and courageous!

Clones fought tirelessly in both the Republic and Empire eras (albeit the beginning of the Empire era when the clones were still serving in the military) to distinguish themselves from their fellow brothers in order to make themselves more human. Personal selections and preferences for their hairstyles, armor paint, tattoos, names, and even scars obtained in battle tried to convey to the general public that they were more than mere copies of Jango Fett. They were always human, but because they all share the same face, the GAR was then made faceless. To natborns, a faceless army wasn't as tragic to see refused basic human rights, be victims of bigotry, and then physically suffer and die in combat, because with facelessness comes a lack of identity, and with a lack of identity comes neglect.

Support all the clones, not just your favorites! They are some of the most tragic characters, if not the most tragic characters, in all of Star Wars. If the writers won't give them the love they deserve from the natborn characters (because seeing a named clone we just met die within the same episode is so upsetting đŸ˜©...ahem, I'm talking to you Dave and Jen lol!), the least we can do is give them that much-needed love from a fan's standpoint! đŸ„°

More Posts from Screamingandcrying22 and Others

2 years ago
Rampart's Answer Did Not, Repeating, Did NOT Please Me

rampart's answer did not, repeating, did NOT please me

like what is he so smug about, i honestly feel like he was lying. they didn't just- you know- execute him for disobeying orders, right?

2 years ago

tumblr writers try not to woobify the white man in a ship challenge level impossible

2 years ago

The thing I really love about Cody’s story in “The Solitary Clone” is that he reflected on what happened and his reality on his own, that his realizations were his own, nobody beat it into his head, nobody had to shake him away, Cody did that on all his own.  Cody’s ability to think for himself, to navigate his way through his own mind, was what brought him through the conditioning in his head.  That doesn’t have to negate that the Jedi’s effect on the clones was foundational and tremendous, that they helped give the clones the chance to grow into these people.  But it also is still Cody’s own damn work on his own damn mind that brought him to where he was. The thing I really don’t love about Cody’s story in “The Solitary Clone” is that he could have been replaced with just about any other character and it would have had nearly as much impact, because this was a story about Crosshair, not about Cody.  We never even see Cody’s realization or the moment he leaves, Cody was set dressing for Crosshair’s story, and wound up being a cameo more than actually getting a story. I’m not opposed to every single episode of the show having a cameo–even if I think they’re relying too heavily on them to draw in viewers and thus undercutting the idea that these characters might actually get a hefty story being told about them, instead of having it done in tiny snippets here and there.  But that’s my frustration with Cody’s story, that what’s there isn’t bad, but because he’s a cameo in someone else’s story, his story is told in the background and we only see half of it.  Cody deserves better than to have his story told that way.

3 years ago

“slow-burn” “friends to lovers” “childhood friends” like just say youre demiromantic and move on

2 years ago

my toxic trait is becoming more obsessed with something than the person who recommended it to me

2 years ago

-tbb s2 spoilers-

okay listen,

-tbb S2 Spoilers-
-tbb S2 Spoilers-

i know that they're literally clones and that's like the default haircut (except wilco's hair is slightly longer and cody is obviously hotter im sorry)

but doesn't wilco look a lot like cody? he almost feels like cody!

i hope they were not foreshadowing cody's death with the ending scene of ep 2, you get what i mean.

3 years ago

Doctor Who is literally about time travel, it’s about exploring the past as well as the future.

It is thematically on point for it to dwell in nostalgia now and then! It’s what the characters do.

You’ve got something good, why not revisit it once in a while? That’s the point of having a spaceship. 

2 years ago

I DONT WANT ANYMORE ORDER 66 RETROSPECTS

WHAT I WANT IS TO SEE OBIWAN AND CODY DRINKING TEA, WHILE BEHIND THEM ANAKIN IS CHASING AHSOKA WHO STOLE HIS ARM, WITH REX SCREAMING INTO A PILLOW AS A BONUS

2 years ago

-tbb s2 spoilers-

"Well, you know what makes us different from battle droids? We make our own decisions. Our own choices. And... we have to live with them too."

as the effects of the inhibitor chips start wearing off, clones (some of em at least) begin to realise what they've done and what they're doing now.

-tbb S2 Spoilers-
-tbb S2 Spoilers-

he remembers.

i absolutely loved this episode, crosshair really needs a mentor and that could've been cody, although he did the right thing by leaving AND HE'S OFF TO FIND KENOBI YOU CANNOT CONVINCE ME OTHERWISE unless they actually executed him silently which would be HORRIBLE.

and 32 rotations? what the FUCK crosshair how did you even manage to survive in there

  • phk-anime
    phk-anime reblogged this · 4 months ago
  • phk-anime
    phk-anime reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • phk-anime
    phk-anime reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • horror-princess123
    horror-princess123 liked this · 1 year ago
  • wxlfae
    wxlfae liked this · 1 year ago
  • iwantsilmarils
    iwantsilmarils liked this · 1 year ago
  • thecatitbittingmeee
    thecatitbittingmeee liked this · 1 year ago
  • aouralune
    aouralune liked this · 2 years ago
  • lepetitfruit
    lepetitfruit liked this · 2 years ago
  • roxalind
    roxalind liked this · 2 years ago
  • im-here-and-im-confused
    im-here-and-im-confused liked this · 2 years ago
  • flyiingsly
    flyiingsly liked this · 2 years ago
  • indecisivebigal
    indecisivebigal liked this · 2 years ago
  • quietgingerfangirl
    quietgingerfangirl liked this · 2 years ago
  • shadowsoundeffects13
    shadowsoundeffects13 liked this · 2 years ago
  • therathen
    therathen liked this · 2 years ago
  • stormneko25
    stormneko25 liked this · 2 years ago
  • orangeoctopusart
    orangeoctopusart liked this · 2 years ago
  • mybrainnevershutsup
    mybrainnevershutsup reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • mybrainnevershutsup
    mybrainnevershutsup liked this · 2 years ago
  • cookielessthan3
    cookielessthan3 liked this · 2 years ago
  • ithazbinanhonour
    ithazbinanhonour liked this · 2 years ago
  • alverdekote
    alverdekote reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • alverdekote
    alverdekote liked this · 2 years ago
  • screamingandcrying22
    screamingandcrying22 reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • screamingandcrying22
    screamingandcrying22 liked this · 2 years ago
  • aysha2956
    aysha2956 liked this · 2 years ago
  • littlepinkfrogs
    littlepinkfrogs liked this · 2 years ago
  • thecottagewitch96
    thecottagewitch96 liked this · 2 years ago
  • greeneyes1
    greeneyes1 liked this · 2 years ago
  • boxhv
    boxhv liked this · 2 years ago
  • starsandmyrhs
    starsandmyrhs liked this · 2 years ago
  • darkangeloftartaraus
    darkangeloftartaraus liked this · 2 years ago
  • theladsaregoingmental
    theladsaregoingmental liked this · 2 years ago
  • astrologically-indecent
    astrologically-indecent liked this · 2 years ago
  • kayrielwrites
    kayrielwrites liked this · 2 years ago
  • theartgremlin
    theartgremlin liked this · 2 years ago
  • black-mambaaaa
    black-mambaaaa liked this · 2 years ago
  • rowanshadow26
    rowanshadow26 liked this · 2 years ago
  • timberwood-101
    timberwood-101 reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • timberwood-101
    timberwood-101 liked this · 2 years ago
  • loverofclones
    loverofclones liked this · 2 years ago
  • briefexpertdeer
    briefexpertdeer liked this · 2 years ago
  • ew-wtaf
    ew-wtaf reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • roseiswrite
    roseiswrite reblogged this · 2 years ago
screamingandcrying22 - State of Grace
State of Grace

she/her | lover of shedding tears over black lines on paper/phone screens | swiftie | whovian | don’t have a personality beyond loving to read and listening to taylor swift | psychology major that doesn’t understand her own actions |

253 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags