I'm Watching The Edited Version Of The War Games (it's On BBC4 Right Now And My Parents Wanted To See

I'm watching the edited version of the War Games (it's on BBC4 right now and my parents wanted to see it), so, have some thoughts.

I'm normally a bit iffy on colourisation but this is genuinely very well done. The titles are gorgeous.

Squishing it into 90 mins makes the opening very zippy. The pace feels a shade too quick if anything.

It also gets a bit weird when the cliffhanger is turned into continuous action.

This is despite the fact that they only cut about 10 mins of episode one.

They drink a lot of tea in the War Games but it comes across as even more when you cut out of the non-tea-drinking bits.

OK, there's some very fun editing around the redcoat and Buckingham remembering the mist coming down. (Dare I say possibly an improvement on the original?)

But then it goes back to feeling too zippy, but least because episode 3 is brutally cut. Very little of it left.

Gah, I'm trying to like this, because it's clearly been lovingly made and the colourisation is genuinely superb, but the grinding relentlessness of the War Games has been replaced by rattling through the plot at a frenzied pace and it's not really working for me.

Ooh, Murray Gold's Master theme has been added over the War Chief's appearance. Not sure how I feel about that, but it's certainly an interesting choice.

They've dealt with the cliffhanger issue at the end of episode 4 by taking it out entirely.

The little added CGI bits are not hugely successful - they look oddly plasticky. Which is a bit disappointing, because have I mentioned how good the colourisation is?

It's taken my dad until the episode six cliffhanger to note the place where the original cliffhanger was.

(My mum has given up because she doesn't like how much fighting there is. Not sure if the original edit would have been any better on that score.)

Episodes 6 and 7 are so thoroughly chopped up that it's tricky to trace the original storyline. It's neatly done but it's not really the War Games any more.

More of the Master's theme when the War Chief admits to knowing the Doctor.

My dad comments that this bit seems like it was inspired by the Prisoner (which he also watched when it first aired).

It feels a bit weird when it switches from Murray Gold to 1960s incidental music.

This really centres the War Chief et al over the rest of the storyline.

"Complete loyalty and devotion" - oh, Jamie. This loses a lot of character beats in favour of the Time Lord-centric storyline, but not all of them.

Oof, their last desperate attempt to escape is still just as grim and desperate in the edit. Like there's still part of me wondering if they might somehow get away this time.

There are new Who-style images of Gallifrey on the view screen.

"Is the next episode The Trial of a Time Lord?" asks my dad, who has seen all of Doctor Who, but mostly not very recently.

The middle bit of episode 10 is cut, which means that I can watch the ending without crying for once.

Lots of establishing shots of Gallifrey.

The too old/too young/too thin shows a series of New Who Doctors. Not entirely sure how I feel about that choice either.

And it ends with the Doctor regenerating in the TARDIS - again, New Who style - before the date ticks back and forth erratically between 1970 and 1980, a joke that will appeal to a small number of people that includes me, and finally the very opening scene of Spearhead from Space.

I think if you accept the premise that a 90-min version of the War Games could be done, it's about as good as it could be. A few of the choices make it pretty clear that this is primarily for a New Who audience - particularly that it becomes a very Time Lord-centric story - not really for existing fans of the War Games.

Still, I wasn't expecting to love the colourisation as much as I did, and it made me wish I could watch a colourised version of all 10 episodes.

More Posts from Thesquiddian and Others

1 year ago

Love it when the kinda half-formed observations you make about an episode finally come to the forefront.

Watching the start of "Dot and Bubble": Hmm, everyone in this episode is very... white.

Halfway through: The Doctor certainly continues to stand out, especially in that bright red sweater amongst all the pastels

Lindy freaking out about the Doctor and Ruby being in the same room together: I suppose that could be due to some cultural taboo about interacting in-person when everyone is supposed to communicate via bubble, but that doesn't track with what we've seen of her work day...

The "twist" that the chronically online, all white, super rich, entitled to the point of satire, willing to sacrifice others without hesitation, oh so eager to colonize people living in a literal bubble (TWO bubbles) are *gasp!* actually, devastatingly racist...

Yeah, that's not a twist. That's all deliberately interconnected. The episode didn't suddenly move from an argument about social media use to an argument about racism; the two historically go hand-in-hand.

8 months ago

Whenever I mention that Romanadvoratrelundar is from House Dvora, someone inevitably mentions the House of Heartshaven, and up until now I’ve explained the relationship between Heartshaven and Dvora as being analogous to that between Lungbarrow and Prydon or Meddhoran and Xianthellipse: in other words, Heartshaven is a sub-bloodline of Dvora. I’ve recently come up with an alternate solution, though, and I think it’s far more satisfying.

I am Romanadvoratrelundar, mortal heir to the House of Heartshaven, inheritor of the House of Dvora, and custodian of the House of Everston.

— Romana, Panacea

I was an only child. I didn’t have many friends.

— Romana, Neverland

When Romana visits the House of Heartshaven at the beginning of Panacea, she finds it completely deserted, laying in ruins and infested with pig-rats. Nothing could be more dissimilar to the House of Lungbarrow from Lungbarrow, which belongs to an active bloodline with many living members. Heartshaven isn’t some modern experiment with new biodata; it’s a fallen House, like Catherion or Ixion from The Book of the War.

And Romana acknowledges that Heartshaven is dead: there were no other children in the House; she’s not just a member, she’s the bloodline’s “mortal heir”. The last person with any claim to Heartshaven’s property and legacy.

[Eighth Man Bound] is never played by Time Lords of those ‘newblood’ Houses for whom a change of body is as trivial as a change of fashion, and who come straight from the loom with a secondary heart.

— Christmas on a Rational Planet

The Imperator crisis was the moment of catastrophe for the Houses. … From that point on Dvora was known as a Newblood House, the first House to have bred such an obvious mutation despite its reasonably long lineage.

— The Book of the War

When Christmas on a Rational Planet introduced the idea of a Newblood House, it specifically did so by contrasting Romana and the Doctor: the First Doctor had only one heart, per The Edge of Destruction and The Man in the Velvet Mask, whereas Romana I had two hearts and also seemed to casually regenerate in Destiny of the Daleks. (The novelisation of City of Death goes so far as to suggest that she regenerated “for the fun of it”.)

The Book of the War then introduced Dvora as the first and oldest Newblood House, being deemed as such after the Morbius crisis. Assuming that Romana is a member of Dvora, this means that Romana was from the generation right after Morbius’ rise to power, which does match the timeline: she’s about one generation younger than the Doctor, who himself was loomed around the same as Morbius.

The Faction Paradox series actually introduces us to one of Romana’s cousins, another child of Dvora from the generation after the Imperator: Larissa. Larissa graduated from the Academy and was recruited into the Order of the Weal when the “worldquake” and the “goblin infestation” were still recent events, which matches perfectly with the freshly-graduated Romana we see in The Ribos Operation. Their timelines are perfectly aligned, and by peeking into Larissa’s childhood, we can get a hint of Romana’s.

They had separated her from her playmates and marched her over the mountains. This was punishment, but not for her. There was madness in the family, a taint in the blood, so the children were scattered to the nine corners of the world for their own protection. She was still too young to understand the reasons, the scandal and disgrace her elders had left behind. She had been carried everywhere all her life, and hated walking. Her new and temporary home was a small house in the mountains, so tiny it was forgotten and flew no sovereign banner.

— Larissa’s childhood, Newtons Sleep

The bloodline of Ixion had already vanished in the Diaspora, leaving only a line of caretakers to manage the affairs of the House. … Following the death of Thessalia and the decline of the Order of the Weal, Ixion became an empty, desolate House.

— The Book of the War

After the Imperator crisis, the children of House Dvora were scattered around Gallifrey, and just as Larissa went to live in the long-empty House of Ixion, Romana was sent to the House of Heartshaven. Just like with Ixion, the death of the caretaker would later prompt the chapterhouse’s collapse, as we hear in Panacea; but, just as Larissa returned to the House of Ixion as an agent for the Order of the Weal, Romana gained a sense of belonging with Heartshaven during her time there that lasted long after she left for the Academy.

5 months ago
I’m Just Going To Leave This Here

I’m just going to leave this here

7 months ago

i suspect certain elements of doctor who are definitely a different (read: baffling) experience if you're not british

1 year ago

Not the Fifteenth Doctor info-dumping like crazy, calling Gallifrey “posh,” listing the Rani and the Bishop but not the Master, and then immediately asking Ruby to fly with them

The Master listening from their golden tooth:

Not The Fifteenth Doctor Info-dumping Like Crazy, Calling Gallifrey “posh,” Listing The Rani And
2 months ago

The dw fandom is so vast and thr vibes are so different that modern who fans are like "top 10 theories about how the TIME WAR made Satan bible afraid" and wilderness years fans are sweating in a corner frantically trying to connect uncle winky's wonderland to faction paradox with red string on a giant conspiracy board

3 months ago
Okay Cap, Who Tf Did This😭

okay cap, who tf did this😭

7 months ago

the time lords actually invented looms because they had a serious macbeth infestation. don't listen to that nonsense about the pythia they just really needed some people who weren't of woman born to kill all those bloody macbeths

1 year ago

God season one of nuwho is so. Your budget is a half-eaten cheese sandwich. Your props department is the rubbish tip behind the BBC studio offices. You may use one (1) cgi, and also photoshop that is exceedingly bad even for 2005. And its one of the best seasons of television ever made

1 year ago

Anyways. I'm glad we've moved past the "heavy handed allegory for racism between two different sentient species where they are all best friends in the end" episodes and into the "racism is so deeply engrained into society that in the absence of active anti-racist deconstruction people would go to any length to avoid confronting their biases and changing their worldview"

  • eryaforsthye
    eryaforsthye liked this · 3 months ago
  • finndiseicla
    finndiseicla liked this · 5 months ago
  • fatiguedrodent
    fatiguedrodent liked this · 5 months ago
  • gonk2020
    gonk2020 liked this · 5 months ago
  • onlyacisdealsinabsolutes
    onlyacisdealsinabsolutes liked this · 5 months ago
  • disbeautifulboy
    disbeautifulboy liked this · 5 months ago
  • bobbiethepunkkid
    bobbiethepunkkid liked this · 5 months ago
  • underpressure08
    underpressure08 liked this · 5 months ago
  • thecryptidqueen28
    thecryptidqueen28 reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • thecryptidqueen28
    thecryptidqueen28 liked this · 5 months ago
  • shiftofgallifrey
    shiftofgallifrey liked this · 5 months ago
  • kingragnarok25
    kingragnarok25 liked this · 5 months ago
  • braigen
    braigen liked this · 5 months ago
  • skalja
    skalja liked this · 5 months ago
  • kvschxi
    kvschxi liked this · 5 months ago
  • claudiescreations
    claudiescreations liked this · 5 months ago
  • reviss-dragonlord
    reviss-dragonlord liked this · 5 months ago
  • dropletr
    dropletr liked this · 5 months ago
  • nekob99
    nekob99 liked this · 5 months ago
  • noticiasarquelogicasjaponesas
    noticiasarquelogicasjaponesas liked this · 5 months ago
  • lollyase
    lollyase reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • thiefoffivefates
    thiefoffivefates liked this · 5 months ago
  • bookpersonmaryjon
    bookpersonmaryjon liked this · 5 months ago
  • mertensia
    mertensia liked this · 5 months ago
  • numericalvalue
    numericalvalue liked this · 5 months ago
  • una10bananas
    una10bananas liked this · 5 months ago
  • thesquiddian
    thesquiddian reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • thesquiddian
    thesquiddian liked this · 5 months ago
  • sylphre-bard
    sylphre-bard liked this · 5 months ago
  • goingdowntocowtown
    goingdowntocowtown reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • goingdowntocowtown
    goingdowntocowtown liked this · 5 months ago
  • locutus-sum
    locutus-sum liked this · 5 months ago
  • theimprobableone42
    theimprobableone42 liked this · 5 months ago
  • flora-is-just-here-ig
    flora-is-just-here-ig liked this · 5 months ago
  • fredtheeternalsnail
    fredtheeternalsnail liked this · 5 months ago
  • incomingalbatross
    incomingalbatross liked this · 5 months ago
  • ilovemedia
    ilovemedia liked this · 5 months ago
  • cosmic-castor-canadensis
    cosmic-castor-canadensis liked this · 5 months ago
  • the-worms-in-your-bones
    the-worms-in-your-bones liked this · 5 months ago
  • daelenn
    daelenn liked this · 5 months ago
  • finn-shitposts
    finn-shitposts reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • finn-shitposts
    finn-shitposts liked this · 5 months ago
  • toxicviolet16
    toxicviolet16 reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • toxicviolet16
    toxicviolet16 liked this · 5 months ago
  • takeasneeded
    takeasneeded liked this · 5 months ago
  • the-gamling-dog
    the-gamling-dog liked this · 5 months ago
  • nitr09-productions
    nitr09-productions liked this · 5 months ago
  • magiefish
    magiefish liked this · 5 months ago
thesquiddian - The Squiddian
The Squiddian

I’ve been trying to change this to a secondary blog please help. (Any pronouns)

126 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags