Dano!Riddler, snuggling beside (y/n): Youâre the best thing that has ever happened to me. Youâre my star, the light in my darkest days.
You, jumping awake into a corner: You fucking bitch- I thought I locked the door?!
Dano!Riddler: The window was open.
That was so lovely and now I'm depressed
Dreaming of You
Summary: Plagued by graphic dreams about the Munson boy, you decided to see if he can make them come true.
Word count: 10.3k
What to expect: Virgin!Eddie Munson. Smut/Lemon. (-18 kindly dni)
A/N: This was supposed to be something short, hot, and fun, but somehow turned into a therapy session. So this is for all my girlies who have suffered bad sex, been robbed of their O's, and made to feel like pleasing them was too much work. Iâm very much a long fic kind of gal, so this is a bit of a different speed for me. Let me know if you enjoyed it!
Yes, that is a Selena song title.
It started with a dream where Eddie The Freak Munson made an appearance. You knew who he was. Everyone did. But you never paid him more than a glance or two until your unconscious mind conjured up a peculiar image of his face buried between your legs on top of OâDonellâs desk. At first you couldnât quite place who it was until he withdrew from you. Even in sleep, you were lucid enough to be shocked that the freak was the one to turn your legs to jelly. He interrupted your thoughts by commanding you to roll on your belly and stick your ass in the air so he could fuck you full right in the middle of the empty math classroom.
After waking up with a sticky situation to remedy, you started to pay more attention to him. Eddie Munson was no longer a loud extra in the backdrop of your day to day life.
Now that he was on your radar, you could spot him anywhere. He towered over almost everyone. Was he always so tall? And kind of built in a scrappy sort of way? You saw him without his jacket once and had the sudden urge to just run your hands up his shirt and feel his lithe abdomen. Maybe even lightly scrape your nails down it just to see the red marks left behind.
Your ogling led to the discovery that he had really nice hands. Even if they were covered with an excessive amount of silver rings that directed the reflection of sunlight from the window into your eyes if you looked his way too long. You wondered if the cheap faux silver turned his thick fingers green, but then forgot to care once you started to wonder what else those fingers could do--if the stretch of them would feel just as good as you dreamt.
You also noticed that he stuck his tongue out a lot. It was like he knew what you dreamt about and was intentionally tormenting you. When he was antagonizing Jason in the cafeteria, you nearly fainted at the sightâtongue so long it nearly reached the bottom of his chin. It didnât take long for you to imagine yourself sitting on his face, writhing on the wet, flat muscle and thinking about how his nose would probably bump in just the right spot. How youâd love to thread your fingers through the hair at the crown of his head and--
A curiosity soon turned into an obsession. Morning, noon, and night your thoughts were flooded with the boy in the leather jacket. You couldnât escape him even in your dreams.
You had to have him.
Many hours of the school day were dedicated to coming up with a plan on how to get his attention, but it was more difficult than you hoped. He was always surrounded by people and looked as if he were in the middle of a tirade, which judging by his outburst in the cafeteriaâhe probably was. Waiting for him to be isolated wasnât yielding any results, but the thought of going up to him when he was in a group of boys who looked less than welcoming wasnât what you wanted either.
There was a possibility that Eddie would laugh at you. Turn you into a spectacle and belittle you for asking him out. He was loud, opinionated, boisterous, and quite abrasive if the wrong person approached him. You hoped he wouldnât do that to you, but you didnât know him well enough to say for sure.
But then he appeared in another dream that caused a yearning so severe that you decided to risk it all.
He was easy to find in the parking lot after school. As usual, he had some of his friends orbiting around him, though it only seemed to be a few of the younger ones that looked less intimidating than his normal posse. Taking a deep breath to gather your wits, you approached Eddie Munson.
Or at least tried to. The Super senior paid you no mind as you stood beside him. He continued to address the small ring in front of him, not noticing that they were staring at you with open mouths and wide eyes instead of listening to him.
â--You can beg all you like, Wheeler, but the answer is no. Why donât you ask your buddy ol pal Harrington to get it--what are you all looking at?â Eddie turned to follow their gaze. His face shifted from mild annoyance to confusion as he stared at you.
Losing a bit of your nerve at the way his brown eyes bore into you, you faltered. âH-hey, Eddie.â
His brow furrowed in further uncertainty. âHi?â
You couldnât blame him for being uneasy at your sudden attempt at contact, having ignored him for the years youâd been in school together. But it made you second guess yourself all the same. Perhaps the Eddie in your dreams should be the one you focused on.
The thought of Dream Eddie brought on a searing heat that warned your neck and face. If there was even a chance that Eddie in the real world could have the same effect on you that Dream Eddie did, you had to go for it.
Regaining your confidence, you put on a sly smile. âAre you busy tonight?â
Eddie narrowed his eyes at you and tilted his head. âWhy?â
Feigning innocence, you shrugged meekly. âWhy donât you invite me over and find out.â
After a few more beats of confusion, something seemed to click in Eddieâs brain as you visibly watched his suspicion turn to understanding. He nodded and snapped his fingers before pointing it at you like a gun. âRight. Forest Hills at nine oâclock?â
All the tension you were carrying in your shoulders melted away. Smiling brightly, you agreed.
ââ
Nine oâclock seemed to take forever. You spent the time at home pulling out all the stops to make sure that you were ready and presentable. Using the best smelling shampoo and body wash, taking the time to contort in the tub for optimal body hair removalâno matter how much you hated shavingâteeth and tongue scraped to gleam, perfumed body lotion, the only lacy set of bra and panties you owned, and just a small amount of makeup to keep everything smooth.
It had been a while since you had sex, giving up on high school boys completely. The few experiences you had were less than satisfactory, so you decided that getting yourself off was much less of a hassle than dealing with the idiots at school.
Like many of the girls at Hawkins high, you had given your virginity to Steve Harrington. He was sweet, gentle, and took his time opening you up with his fingers before pushing in to you. It was arguably the best night of your life. An orgasm that was provided by someone other than yourself, the giggling, nose kisses, and night full of whispers made you think you were right to choose Steve for your first time. However, as soon as the sun came up, he forgot all about you and moved on to his next conquest.
Things only went downhill from there.
You could feel bile rising in your throat from remembering the way Tommy H flopped around on top of you like he was having a seizure. With all his talk about how great he was in the sack, you were severely disappointed. You couldnât wait for it to be over with so you could go home and take care of yourself properly. Thankfully, in less than three minutes your prayer was answered.
Then there was Billy Hargrove. He knew how to use his cock, but he was a selfish lover. He didnât take the time to make sure you were satisfied, and once he was done, that was it. You were to shut up and leave. He made you cum on occasion, but it turned into a bizarre fight because you didnât ask his permission to do so. You werenât desperate enough to beg for anything, and for Billy to expect you to beg him to cum when you could achieve it without himâŚwell. Letâs just say you didnât go back when he brought it up again.
Steve was great but used you. Tommy was terrible and had bad breath. Billy was capable of satisfying you but chose not to. You hoped Eddie would be different.
In your dreams, his attitude varied. Sometimes it was hot and rough, other times it was slow and sensual, and sometimes it was just him worshiping you with words.
As much as you wanted that to be the truth, you were afraid that Eddie in the flesh would disappoint you. Just like the others.
But you tried not to think about it. Instead, you focused on recreating the images your imagination conjured up both in sleep and waking hours. Recalling the way his lips felt on yours. The sting of your scalp when he pulled your hair. The sweet words heâd coo after he made you see stars.
The permanent ache in your belly only intensified the longer you dwelled on your past visions. Before you were even at his place your body was scorching from the inside out, cunt drenched and throbbing, and breathing erratic.
Arousal quickly faded into nervousness as you parked your car next to the familiar van, but you tried to bully it back by taking a few calming breaths before going for gold and knocking on the door.
All that could be heard from the other side was various banging and swearing before the door launched open to reveal Eddie looking quite frazzled.
He held up a few crushed beer cans in his hand and gave a weak smile. âSorry. Was trying to clean up a bit. Maid took the week off.â
You gave him a small smile. âThatâs okay. Can I come in?â
Eddie moved out of the way and bowed low at the waist. âOf course. Castle Munson is yours.â
You couldnât help but laugh at that display as you walked past him. Youâd seen him bow his head to girls at school who either ignored his existence completely or scowled at him, but to be on the receiving end of his chivalry was cute.
His castle was anything but. The trailer was small, very cluttered, and was certainly the home to chain smokers as every countertop had a full ashtray on it. Still, it was oddly comforting with the soft glow of the living room lamp, the rows and rows of mugs lining the walls and the collection of baseball caps to compliment them.
You followed him into the tiny kitchen area. âDo you live here alone?â you asked curiously, taking a closer look at the Garfield mug on the counter.
âUh--no,â Eddie answered, stuffing his hand in the full trash can to stop the pile from overflowing. âMy uncle lives here too but he works overnight at the plant.â
Your heart soared at the idea of having the place to yourself for the evening. âSo no one will be home tonight?â
âNope,â he answered, turning his attention to the fridge. âCan I get you a water? Or beer? I think I have some Kool-aid in here if you want that.â
You shook your head, forgetting he couldnât see you with his face in the depths of the fridge. Perhaps beer would be a good idea to calm your nerves a bit, but then again, you didnât want to have horrid breath for this.
âNo. Iâm okay, thanks.â
âRight,â Eddie mumbled. He withdrew from the fridge and clapped his hands together. âSo. What can I get you? Iâm out of shrooms, but I have a couple of tabs and some weed.â
âHuh?â you questioned, staring at him with confusion.
Eddie looked equally unsure. âThatâs what youâre here for, right? Weed?â
You clenched your eyes shut when you realized what he meant. He didnât exactly pick up what you were putting down earlier.
Maybe it would be better to accept a beer and a joint. Perhaps get to know him better before pouncing on him like a lioness in heat. But the yearning in the core of your belly wasnât willing to wait.
âUm, no,â you answered awkwardly. You let out a sharp exhale before looking at him again. âIâm here for you.â
He raised his brows. âMe?â
Was there a way to convey this without sounding like a whore? How were you supposed to tell him you wanted to fuck when clearly the thought never crossed his mind?
You supposed you could show him. You took a few steps to close the distance between you, inhaling the scent of him. True, the smell of cigarettes and weed clung to him, but so did the aroma of Old Spice, cologne, and something you could only describe as man. And boy was it intoxicating in the most alluring way to breathe in.
You placed your hands on his leather clad biceps--which were almost heaven to finally touch after weeks of staring--and stood atop the tips of your toes to whisper in his ear. âIâve been thinking about you.â
Grabbing you by the elbows, he gently pushed you back far enough to be able to look at you.
âHey, if you donât have any money, itâs fine. I can just smoke you out,â he frowned. âYou donât have to do any of that.â
No wonder it took him three tries to pass senior year. The guy was really dense. What was it going to take for him to realize you were here to get your back blown out?
Huffing with mild irritation, you leaned away from him and seized the hem of your shirt, pulling it over your head and tossing it carelessly elsewhere.
Eddieâs brown eyes nearly bulged out of his skull as they stared at your lace covered tits. If you werenât so turned on, you would have laughed at the way his mouth hung open--face frozen in shock. It didnât even look like he was blinking. Or even breathing for that matter.
âI told you. I came here for you.â
Taking his stunned silence as an opportunity, you crowded his space once again and finally got to live out one of your fantasies: pushing your hands beneath his shirt and feeling the muscles of his abdomen. There were some there, but there was also a little bit of pudge too right at his navel. Lightly gliding your hands upward towards his chest, you leaned to place a small kiss on the side of his throat.
âIâve had dreams about you,â you said in the best seductive tone you could muster, placing another kiss just a few inches higher on his neck.
His Adam's apple bobbed beneath your lips. âHua-uhh,â Eddie stammered. âWhat kind of dreams?â
You smiled to yourself at the crack in his voice. âOh, I think you know what kind.â You pressed your body flush against his, relishing in the warmth of him and internally cheering at the stiff bulge pressed against your stomach.
Eddie chuckled nervously, his voice much higher than before. âY-yeah I think I have an idea. Wha--â he cleared his throat in an effort to return his tone to a normal octave. âWhat happens in them?â
You slid your hands towards his belt loops, hooking your fingers in them and steering him the short way to the couch as you answered. âWhich one do you wanna know about? Thereâs been quite a few. I could tell you about them orââ you gently pushed off Eddieâs leather jacket from his shoulders, letting it fall before nudging him down onto the lumpy couch. ââI could show you.â
All the air in Eddieâs lungs came out in a huff when he collapsed onto the sofa. Wide eyed he asked, âIs thisâis this really happening?â
Taking your time to settle on your knees between his legs, you outlined the tattoo on his forearm, having never noticed it there before. Eddie Munson just became ten times hotter.
âReally happening,â you smirked.
Eddie was nearly panting through his wide open mouth as he watched you undo his belt, button and zipper. The quiet gasps of âh-oh shitâ that escaped him only made your confidence grow.
âCute,â you teased, snapping the elastic waistband of his navy bullfrog boxers.
He may have said something about how they were his lucky pair, but you werenât listening. The anatomy beneath them was what you were here for, and you couldnât wait to see it. Wasting not another second, you instructed Eddie to lift his hips and yanked the heavy black denim and boxers to his knees.
Cock slapping against his belly, sticky drops dribbled from the head. Your mouth watered at the sight of it twitching against him in anticipation. It was all you could have hoped for. Thick, long, curved just a little to the right, and with a glistening pink tipâEddieâs cock was gorgeous.
âGood for you, Munson,â you praised mischievously. It took no time wrapping your hand around the length of him. Heavy, silky smooth, and hot, you gave into the urge and licked a pressured stripe on the underside of his shaft, tracing the protruding vein.
The strangled chortle that emitted from the back of Eddieâs throat only fueled your desire. You could feel your own arousal pooling, more than likely already seeping through the thin fabric of your underwear with how worked up you made yourself earlier. Lifting yourself higher on your knees, you licked the slick slit and relished the salty taste of him before enveloping the entirety of the head with your lips.
Maybe it was weird to be so turned on when giving a blowjobâother girls talked about it like it was a chore and you hated having to do it to Billy. But feeling Eddieâs hairy thighs tremble under your palms, seeing his chest heave as breathy whimpers escaped him, watching his mouth hang open in disbelief with his cheeks sporting a ruddy complexion was enough to make your cunt throb.
Hollowing your cheeks, you lowered your mouth as far as you could without gagging, and pulled back up again to swirl your tongue around the mushroom tip with your fist following close behind.
Eddie huffed and puffed, trying to stutter out half syllables as he writhed in your grasp. Unsure of what to do with his hands, his fingers flexed against the cushions beneath them. He struggled to keep his eyes openâdark lashes fluttering against his pink cheeks with every stroke.
God he was beautiful like this. Why you never thought of him before was a true mystery. Lips pink and plump, strong nose, and eyelashes so long youâd kill for them. Now that youâd seen him blissed out from something you were doing for himâto himâyou couldnât imagine ever going back to ignoring him.
Drunk from the power you clearly had over him and determined to make a lasting impression so this could happen again, you bobbed your head lower and lower, relishing in the smooth glide of his cock against your tongue, opening the back of your throat to accommodate him until you were close enough to bury your nose against the thick dark curls at the base of him.
But Eddie was finally able to gasp out a single word. âS-Stop!â
All the confidence drained from you when you peered at him through your lashes. Eddie panted heavily with his brown eyes wide and glossy, looking as if her were about to cry.
Pulling off of him with a wet pop, you frowned with his dick twitching against your chin. âIs it not goodâ?â
He quickly shook his head. âToo good. So good Iâm gonna bust in two seconds if you donât slow down,â he answered breathlessly. âOr if you keep looking at me like that. Jesus Christ.â
Your frown deepened at his words. Too busy worrying about your pleasure from devouring him, you didnât give much thought about what he wanted from this, thinking getting blown was reward enough in itself.
Embarrassed by your selfishness, you decided to make it right.
Ignoring the popping in your knees, you lifted yourself from the carpet to straddle Eddieâs lap, taking extra care to press your clothed core right against his aching cock.
Up close like this you were able to admire his features. Trace his bottom lip with your thumb, the curve of his scratchy jaw. Memorize the pattern of light freckles dusting the bridge of his nose. You outlined that too with the pass of your fingertips, along with the ridge of his deep set Cupidâs bow.
âSorry,â you said softly, gently swiping the curtain of black bangs to expose his pale forehead.
Eddie blinked. âHuh?â
âFor being greedy,â you answered simply.
He chuckled weakly. The corner of his lip ticked in a sideways grin, allowing for a dimple to dent his cheek as you caressed it. âPromise itâs alright, Sweetheart. Just want it to last longer than ten seconds.â
You slowly rocked your hips, letting the sopping cotton of your underwear drag against the hard length pressing so deliciously against you. A sigh rushed out of his parted lips when you moved his hands from the couch cushions and slid them up your body until they rested against the curve of your lace covered breasts.
The audible gulp emitting from his throat made you giggle, but it quickly faded into silence when he kept his hands still. No kneading, squeezing, or massaging. You ceased the roll of your hips.
âYou can touch me if you want,â you offered.
Eddie stared at his unmoving hands and licked his lips before his eyes flickered up to yours. âCan I kiss you?â
It was your turn to gape at him. It hadnât occurred to you that you hadnât even kissed him during your lust fueled frenzy. Granting permission with a wordless nod of your head, letting him initiate just as he asked.
From your observations of Eddie over the last few weeks, timid is not the word you would use to describe him. However, as his lips gently pressed against yours, thatâs all you could think of.
The kiss wasnât bad, it was justâŚslow. Gentle. Timid. He made no effort to deepen it--deciding that a few chicken pecks were satisfactory. Eddie also kept his hands frozen on your chest, much to your displeasure.
Trying to relay the urgency of your desire, you took over. Crashing your lips against his, you tried to set the pace. But Eddie couldnât keep up. He was clumsy, had a little too much spit, and nearly jumped out of his skin when you slid the tip of your tongue against his.
Frustrated, you pulled away from him.
âAre you okay?â you snapped.
Eddie nodded vigorously. âYeah, Iâm fine. Are you okay?â
You didnât want to crush his spirit and say it was disappointing, but you also wanted more. âYouâre just--youâre acting like youâve never done this before.â
His cheeks deepened into a harsh maroon. âI havenât.â
Your hands dropped from his face as you stared at him incredulously. âHavenât what?â
âThis!â Eddie shrieked with frustration. He removed his hands from your tits to pull his boxers over his exposed dick. âI havenât had a chick dream about me! Or storm into my house with her tits out! Or blow me! Or even--â
The realization hit you like a bag of bricks. Shocked, you blurted, âOh, my god. Youâre a virgin.â
Eddie seized his speech mid rant--mouth snapping shut like a gatorâs.
This couldnât be. Eddie? Eddie Munson? Heâd been in high school forever and he never had a girlfriend? Not once? The guy who was like nineteen or twenty? Old enough to go to bars and clubs and--didnât he play in a band? No girls hung around after the show to try and sleep with the band? Especially now that youâve seen what he was hiding in those tight black jeans of his.
âHow?â you gasped, completely by accident.
Frustrated and embarrassed, Eddie snapped. âIt just never happened, okay? No one wants to fuck the freak! Except you, I guess,â he added hastily. âBut I think I just ruined that.â
True, you never saw a girl hanging around Eddie at school, but you thought it was just because he was into girls outside of the high school scope. His own age, from bars, from people he knew from earlier years at Hawkins High. With how Eddie carried himself--so sure and in your face--the thought didnât occur to you that heâd never done anything before.
Your shoulders sagged as the full weight of disappointment sank in. If Eddie was a virgin, he wouldnât have any idea on how to give you what you wanted. Weeks of dreaming about him were just that--The opposite of reality. Fantasies. Falsehood. The type of rush and satisfaction you got from your dreams would not be received here today, and that was almost devastating. Despite his ignorance of the female body, he probably didnât want you--someone who barely spoke to him before today--to be the one to champion his first time.
You also felt stupid. So fucking stupid for having built up this guy in your head, only to be so very wrong about him. For as big and bad as Eddie Munson tried to make himself, he was currently the epitome of one of Madonnaâs greatest hits.
âIâm sorry,â Eddie grumbled bitterly. âTrust me, no one is more disappointed than I am about it.â
Swallowing harshly, you nodded and tried to smile the ache away. âItâs okay. Iâm just surprised. But um--I should probably get going--â
Eddieâs face fell into panic. âNo!â he shouted loudly, making you jump at the volume. âI mean--you donât have to go. We can still do whatever you want. If you want.â
Did you still want to? There was the matter of the soreness in your belly that would only get worse the longer you were left unsatisfied, but you didnât really have the patience for Eddie to try and figure out how to touch you.
You tried to play it off politely. âDonât you want your first time to be with someone you care about? I wouldnât want to take that from--â
âTake it!â Eddie interrupted. âSwear, youâll be making both of our dreams come true.â
It was difficult to argue with that. You were already here with nothing else to do. And after the hell you went through to make yourself presentable for him? You deserved at least something. The image you curated of him was already shattered to bits. Could any further harm be done at this point?
Eddie took the silence of your deliberation as an opportunity to plead his case. Sliding his large hands up your back, he leaned forward to plant a kiss on your collarbone.
âYou could teach me,â he said softly before moving his mouth to attend to the curve of your breast. âShow me what you like.â
Now there was an idea. None of the guys you had been with before were virgins, but they also werenât very knowledgeable on what it took to please you. With Eddie not having any prior experience, it would be easier to get him to do what you needed so you could both enjoy it, instead of him getting off and you having to take care of yourself after anyway.
Twisting your arm behind your back, you unhooked your bra, letting the straps slide down your shoulders. âOnly if you promise not to use what I show you on anyone else.â
Eddie licked his lips as he watched the lace drop to fully reveal your breasts. âWouldnât dare.â Tentatively, as if he was scared to move too fast, Eddie cupped the soft flesh and lifted.
âTheyâre heavy,â he said with surprise.
You chuckled. âThey can be.â Placing your hands over his, you guided him where you wanted him, and told him to squeeze.
âThat doesnât hurt?â he asked curiously.
You shook your head. âYouâre not gonna hurt me, Eddie. JustâŚdo what you want, and Iâll let you know if I donât like it.â
âWhat if you do like it?â
Your patience was already thinning. âYouâll know.â
There it was again. That tantalizing tongue of his poking out of the side of his mouth as he finally gave in.
Gripping his shoulders for stability, your eyes fluttered closed at the sensation of him kneading your chest. Experimenting with pressure, noting that your breath hitched when he held you a little firmerâthe way your head tilted back when he brushed his palms over the pebbled flesh of your nipples. His hands felt just as good as you hoped they would. Maybe even better, as they were rougher than you imagined. The harsh texture in contrast to your smooth skin fueled the fire brewing between your legs. The contented sigh that fell from your parted lips when he rolled them between his fingers. Pinching, tugging, sometimes too hard but he paid attention to your direction, never making the same mistake twice.
When his mouth enveloped the hardened nub, you felt all the breath leave your lungs in a rapid huff as you lurched forward involuntarily from the pulse of pleasure coursing through you.
No one had done that to you before. The most attention your boobs ever got was clumsy groping and a sloppy wet kiss to the tops. Never had anyone swirled their tongue over your nipples, and suddenly you felt very cheated.
âKeep doing that,â you breathed, finally living out another fantasy of threading your finger through his hair at the base of his neck to hold him close. It was softer than it looked--thicker and lush. You wondered what it would feel like tickling the inside of your thighs.
Eddie changed course, going from languid swirls to quick flicks that sent jolts of need through your body. Your hips started to rock on their own accord, gliding your sopping cunt over his cock.
Eddie groaned loudlyâthe vibrations making you whimper. He dropped his hands from your breasts, ignoring the meek whine of protest from you at the loss of contact, and instead focused on gripping the bare fat of your ass beneath your skirt to move you how he wantedâpulled down flush against him and faster. Your hips sped up to meet his pace, relishing in the way the head of his cock bumped your clit with each pass.
He pulled off of your breast with your nipple gently clenched between his teeth, releasing it with a primal growl. You hoped he would show the same attention to the other side, but instead he directed his mouth to the column of your throat--sucking lightly, nipping and licking his way around.
âFuck, thatâs it,â he groaned. âMakin such pretty noises for me.â
âY-you can only leave marks--â you began breathlessly, interrupted by a mouth escaping your lips at the feel of him finding that sweet spot at the juncture of your neck. â--if I can mark you.â
Eddieâs response was indecipherable between the grunt that emitted from him, the way his lips latched onto the soft skin of your neck, and whatever he was trying to mumble. The sting of the suction on your throat paired with the vibrations of his failed attempt at speech was becoming too much.
âYouâre soaking me, baby,â he moaned. âFeels so fucking good.â
Grip tightening on your ass, his hips bucked into you, causing shockwaves to roll through the tendrils of your nerves. Finally, the ache youâd been suffering from for weeks was going to be cured. You could feel yourself getting closer and closer to subsiding the dull burn in the pit of your stomach with each rhythmic roll of your hips against his. Abdominal muscles fluttering, hole clenching around nothing, blood like molten lava through your veins, moaning and panting with abandon--If he felt this good without even being inside you, you couldnât wait to find out what like it felt like to be filled with him.
You could just reach down, yank your ruined underwear to the side and slide down the length of him, but you couldnât stop your movements long enough to do so. You were climbing to your peak and fast.
But Eddie beat you to it. As soon as you opened your mouth to tell him you were on the precipice of seeing stars, Eddie gave one--two more rough thrusts as he let out an animalistic growl in the crook of your neck.
Panic set in. âNo. No!â you whined to yourself, trying not to lose impending orgasm by continuing to ride him relentlessly, but it was too late. The tingle had already faded too far to get back without having to start all over.
Disappointed, you closed your eyes to prevent tears of frustration from falling and laid your head atop his in defeat.
Eddie didnât move from your neck. âGoddamn it! Iâm sorry,â he panted. âIâm so fucking sorry. You just--it felt so good and I--fuck!â
âItâs okay,â you replied flatly. If you werenât mere seconds from cumming your brains out, it would have been hot. Getting him so worked up that he couldnât control himself? Cumming in his frog underwear while he clutched onto for dear life? Literally the subject of your dreams. But with how sore your gut was getting, it was almost cruel to have lost your well earned orgasm so close to the finish line.
Eddie pulled away from you, looking quite dejected with bits of your hair stuck to his wet lips. âItâs not,â he said breathlessly. âLet me make it up to you. Please? I can still make you feel good. Just give me a few minutes and Iâll be good to go.â
He looked so pitiful. Big brown eyes shining at you. Lips pouty. Chest heaving as he pleaded for another chance.
How could you say no to that face? To the offer, really. None of the others would have ever cared that you didnât get yours, if they even noticed at all.
âOkay,â you answered with a nod. âBut, can we go to your room?â
âYes!â Eddie exclaimed with relief. âYeah. Uh, let me just--give me a few minutes to clean it up a little.â
You untangled yourself from him and stood to your feet, embarrassed by the stickiness of your thighs. Youâd never gotten that wet before, not even by yourself.
âHoly shit!â Eddie laughed, staring at his lap.
You were instantly mortified by the sight. Eddie wasnât joking--you did soak him. Between your fluids and his, the navy blue boxers were saturated.
Panic fluttered in your chest. He probably thought it was gross. âSorry, I didnât mean--â
âSorry?â Eddie repeated. âSorry for what? This is--this is fucking hot. I mean, not mine so much, but holy shit.â
You stared at him in disbelief. Eddie was downrightâŚbeaming. Eyes kissing in the corners from how large his toothy grin was as he admired your joint handiwork. âYou donât think itâs gross?â
Eddie wiggled his brows. âLucky boxers just got luckier.â
Huh. That was new too. Mostly that aspect of your body was treated as something to be ashamed of.
âYour room?â you prodded gently.
âOh! Right.â Eddie pulled his jeans up from his thighs before standing, holding them up to his hips in lieu of buckling them. âDonât leave!â he shouted as he sprinted down the short hallway.
You chuckled to yourself as he disappeared from sight. Who would have thought Eddie Munson was soâŚdorky? The image he projected at school and the one you conjured in your head werenât him at all--Brash, tough, something to be feared or avoided, possibly demented. What a crock. He was goofy. Maybe even sweet. And certainly easier on the eyes than you gave him credit for.
You took the opportunity to find your shirt from the living room floor and try to locate your bra that you threw from the kitchen while Eddie didâŚwhatever he was doing in there. More various banging and swearing emitted from the depths of the hallway that made it sound like he was trying to tear the place down instead of clean it up.
At a closer look of the walls within the Munson home, more than hats and mugs stood out to you. A couple of photos bleached by the sun were tacked to the sheet rock. One showed a large older woman with glasses the size of the moon atop her nose sitting at a wooden table with a handful of cards, a cigarette burning between her fingers, and an expression that youâd bet your life was caused by a winning hand at whatever game she was playing. Another with two little boys in matching coveralls outside a wired fence, both grimacing and squinting to protect themselves from the bright light of the sun. The one next to it was of a girlâwho couldn't be older than seventeenâholding a baby with a head full of wild curls, bright wide eyes, grinning proudly to show the two tiny teeth cutting above his gums.
âI know that face,â you grinned, flattening the curled photo against the wall for a better look.
Eddie poked his head through the doorframe. âDid you say something?â
You tapped the picture and took great joy in watching his cheeks pinken at the realization of what you were looking at.
âSo you were always cute,â you replied happily.
The color of Eddieâs face rivaled that of a tomato. Watching him become flustered was probably your new favorite thing to do to him. Mean and scary Munson blushing and curling inwards at a compliment? Interesting, indeed.
He cleared his throat and pointed his thumb towards his room. âDo you wannaâ?â
Absolutely you did. You followed him with a nod into the small bedroom and took it all in. This was certainly what you expected his room to look like, though if this was the clean version you wondered what it looked like a few minutes ago. He did make the bed at least. Posters and drawings that looked like they were cataloged straight from hell lined the walls. Monsters, demons, skeletons, witchesâsome printed, painted, and hand drawn. The dresser and desk were covered with stuff. Tools, magazines, ashtrays, were those bullet shells? And a light blue box of condoms topped with a thin layer of dust.
You inspected the obviously unopened box and held back giggles. âDonât Think we should use these. They expired in September of 1982.â
Horrified, Eddie snatched the package from your hand and stammered, âMy uncleâwhen I started high school.â He gulped, comically tossing the offending material over his shoulder into the abyss. âHe thinks heâs funny.â
His attention immediately went to your still bare chest, eyes boring into it like he could see the future through your tits. Suddenly feeling quite awkward and self conscious, you crossed your arms to hide yourself from him, unsure of what to do next.
âYouâre pretty overdressed,â you pointed out. While you were only down to stringy lace underwear and a black skirt, Eddie wasnât missing any clothing.
Breaking from his trance, Eddie scrambled fast as lightning to pull his shirt over his head, accidentally snagging a fistful of his hair along with it causing him to hiss. It was so difficult not to laugh, watching him scamper to free himself of his jeans, but when he stood to his full height in nothing but his ruined boxer shorts, you took a step closer to admire his body.
He was certainly taller than youâyour eyes only meeting the middle of his tattooed chest. There was more ink there too. A horrible looking skull. A spider. A dagger with some sort of weird writing on it. But it was all so fitting of him. The black dye complimented his alabaster skin nicely.
As did the shadow of muscles on his abdomen. He was a lot more built than you thought he was under those layers of leather and denim. He wasnât big enough for the football team, but he would probably do well in soccer with those long legs of his.
Toying with the guitar pick that dangled from his necklace, you looked up at him from your lashes. âYou should probably kiss me.â
Eddie swallowed hard at the suggestion, making you grin a little at how nervous he still seemed to be despite being in nothing but his underwear.
But he didnât kiss you. Not yet. The way his big brown eyes were raking over you, like he could see through your very soul, made you shrink a little under the strength of his gaze. But he had a sweet smile stretched across his lips--the kind that let his dimples dent his cheeks.
âYou really are good lookinâ,â you blurted.
Eddie chuckled softly, gently moving the loose strands of hair out of your face with his thumb. âYouâre gorgeous.â He moved his hand to caress your cheek, the other delicately tracing up the back of your arms with only the pads of your fingertips, sending shivers down your spine at the featherlight touch.
This kind of attention was something new. Something you hadnât experienced before except for maybe with Steve, but the betrayal you felt after he ignored you once he got what he wanted left you bitter. Other experiences werenât asâŚintimate. Gentle. Soothing, even. And you felt a tad bit guilty for coming on to Eddie so strongly, knowing full well what it was like to only be used for your body.
This was his first time doing anything ever with a girl. And while yes, you were desperate to get some sort of relief from the horrible tension in your stomach, you were enjoying Eddieâs sincerity. Thatâs what it had to be, right? He wasnât like Steve with an ulterior motive--Eddie knew he was going to have you. And he decided to be sweet anyway.
You took the opportunity to wrap your arms around his slim waist, holding him close in a tight hug. He was so warm. Radiating heat that you gladly absorbed, taking in a breath as you pressed your cheek against his sternum. âYouâre not what I thought youâd be like,â you admitted shamelessly.
Eddie returned the gesture, pressing your bare chest into his as close as he could--scratchy palms sliding up and down your back--occasionally clutching the soft curves. âAnd whatâs that? Mean and scary?â
âYeah,â you chuckled, trying to calm the butterflies in your stomach that came to life when he kissed the crown of your head. âIâd thought youâd beâŚrough. Maybe a little mean. Domineering.â
With your face buried in his torso, you didnât see Eddie frown or furrow his brows. âIs that what you like?â
You took some time to think before answering. âI donât know what I like, Eddie. No oneâs ever asked,â you sighed. And it was true. With your limited encounters, you didnât have good concrete data on what did it for you. Billy was what you accused Eddie of being, and you could count on one hand the amount of times you actually enjoyed yourself, only to be reprimanded for it later.
Eddieâs grip tightened, and he peppered a few more kisses atop your head, temples, and the edge of your hairline. Each one making your heart flutter faster and the heat in your cheeks rise. âIâm sorry.â
âNothing to be sorry about. I know what I liked in my dreams,â you added thoughtfully. âWe could always give it a shot. If you want to, I mean.â
Eddie pulled away just enough to lock eyes with you--tilting your head up further with the knuckle of his index finger. âIâd sure as shit love to, but you gotta know, Iâm not him. Whoever youâve been dreaming about. I mean, I already disappointed you with being--you know.â Eddie gulped, lightly nibbling at the edge of his bottom lip.
You placed a quick peck onto the corner of his mouth, and another on the other side. âI know. You donât have to be anyone or anything. Just you. Iâm sorry if Iâve made you think otherwise.â
Eddie nodded, the edge of his lip ticking up into a fragment of a smile. âStill want me then? Iâll still die a very happy man if you change your mind.â
âOh, I still want you, Eddie Munson,â you chuckled heartily.
âWell then,â Eddie grinned, removing your hands from behind his back and bringing your knuckles to his lips for a quick kiss. âYou shall have me.â
You couldnât stop giggling. Giggling for godâs sake. It was so cheesy. Such a bad line. If anyone else had said it, you probably would have snorted and rolled your eyes. But Eddie? Something about him made it work--the way his eyes practically sparkled or the fact that he just kissed the tops of your hands like some Victorian Royal. Why hadnât you paid any attention to him before? You could almost kick yourself for believing what everyone else said about him instead of finding out for yourself. But you were here now, and didnât want to waste anymore time. You wrapped your hands around his neck, bringing his face down to be able to catch him in a kiss.
This time was better. Instead of rushing him, you let him set the pace--take the lead--let him be the one to decide if and when he wanted to deepen the kiss. You followed his movements, moving with him and trying to give pointers with your own body language when things got a littleâŚlost. The longer it went, the more his confidence grew. Languid licks into your mouth turned into more adventurous tugging at your bottom lip. And before long, you were on the bed with Eddie hovering over you--skirt and underwear cast aside somewhere in the chaos of his room.
Body practically searing, you held your breath as Eddie traced his fingertips over the soft expanse of your belly. Normally self consciousness of how you looked would cloud your mind with doubtâstretch marks, the size and shape of your abdomenâbut with how Eddie gazed at you with a slack jaw and brown eyes almost pleading, you forgot to think too much about it.
âCan I touch you?â he asked carefully, rubbing his large palm against your stomach.
Though you were glad Eddie cared enough to ask permission, you were becoming increasingly impatient as lust clouded your mind. âI might kill you if you donât,â you answered with a huff.
Eddie licked his lips and spared a glance between your legs. You let your knee drop further, inviting him to explore. He slid his palm down to slide his fingers along your sticky slit. A sigh of relief rushed from your lips at the contact, and your hips instinctively followed his fingers for more.
His eyes clenched shut as he groaned through parted lips. âOh, fuck. Youâre so wet.â
âItâs cause of you,â you praised, threading your fingers in his hair and holding his forehead to yours once again. âYou did this to me.â
Eddie audibly gulped, unable to both carry on a conversation and focus on his fingers at the same time. He was being too delicate for your liking, barely able to feel the brush of his fingertips. Desperate to help, you put your hand over his, showing him how you wanted to be touched.
âLike this,â you said, adding more pressure against his middle finger as he traced the path from your entrance to your clit, breath hitching at the tingling sensation when he reached it.
âAnd just--â your pressed his fingers harder against you, showing him just how you liked to be rubbed. You tried to tell him he could switch it up between small circles or figure eights, but the only thing that came out of you were little squeaks of appreciation. The callus of his fingertips against the delicate flesh there was hypnotizing to say the least.
âThatâs good?â he questioned with a furrowed brow.
The circular ministrations he applied to your clit kept you from doing anything other than nod dumbly. But that seemed to be acceptable to Eddie, whose lips twisted into a lopsided grin.
You moved your grasp from his hand to find purchase on his forearm instead. His half lidded eyes stayed focused on yours. âCanât believe youâre letting me do this,â he admitted.
You wanted to tell him you were getting a hell of a lot out of it too, but again, words failed you. Instead, you settled for a breathy âMhmâ and let yourself get lost in his touch.
Within a few minutes, Eddie got more spontaneous. He moved his attention back down to your hole, keeping the heel of his palm right where you wanted. You were surprised when he teased your entrance with his finger without being prompted, but enjoyed the attention nonetheless. When you answered his raised brow with a nod, the delightful stretching around his thick finger paired with the friction on your sensitive button was nothing short of relief. You greedily took what he gave you, rocking your hips steadily to set the pace you wanted from him, and he happily obliged. Swiftly gliding his finger in and out with calculated compression against your clit.
âYes,â you cooed with a heaving chest. âJus-just like that.â
âYouâre so fucking beautiful,â he groaned, hot breath fanning against your face. âFucking yourself on my fingers. Jesus Christ.â
He never took his eyes away from yours. You wanted so desperately to kiss him, but somehow this was far more intimate. Noses nudging against each other, lips barely brushing to breath in every whine he coaxed out of you. He was so gorgeous like this. Brown eyes dark and hazy, pouty lips open in a silent âOâ as his brow furrowed in concentration. He made pretty noises too, panting and groaning along with you like it felt just as good to him.
But it wasnât enough.
âEddie,â you whimpered, grip tightening on his forearm. âEddie, I need you.â
ââM right here.â
Shaking your head, you moved your grasp from his arm to his cock. âNeed you. Inside.â
All of his movements ceased. His eyes nearly bulged out of his head. âReally? Like now?â
âYes, now!â you whined.
âRight! Sorry! Just canât--really canât believe this is about to happen,â he babbled. He made quick work of getting rid of his boxers before adjusting himself properly. He was heavy, but in a way that brought you comfort as he draped his body over yours and caged your head between his forearms. Both breathing heavily from exhilaration, you took a second to revel in the moment.
âHoly shit!â he laughed.
Brushing the long waves behind his ear, you nodded and leaned up just enough to press a tender kiss to his plump lips.
Eddie couldnât contain his excitement. He moved from your lips, you kissing all over your face before settling for sloppy opened mouth kisses dotting a path from your collarbone up to that mind numbing spot at the juncture of your neck. As soon as his teeth scraped against it, you squeezed his hips with your knees, the craving for him only intensifying. The feel of his breath on your neck, hair tickling your chin and cheek, the weight of his chest pressing against yours was all too dizzying.
âNeed you,â you whimpered against his cheek. You dipped your hand between your bodies to grab his length and poise it at your entrance.
Eddie groaned at the desperation in your demand. Sliding the head of his cock between your drenched folds, the torture of him being so close was getting to be too much. Your body jolted with every bump of his cock against your swollen bud. You were getting impatient, and needed him to be inside already.
âEddie, please,â you begged.
Breathing raggedly, Eddie obliged. He pushed himself in with you guiding him, emitting a groan of satisfaction that rumbled from the depths of his chest. Yours was just as loud as you felt him slide into you, walls stretching with that delicious bite to consume him completely.
As soon as he reached his end, a simultaneous breath of relief flowed between both of you. It was almost intoxicating being so full of him. It didnât seem like you could feel anything else but him, both inside and out, and you were deliriously addicted to it. You tangled your fingers into the curls of hair at the nape of his neck and yanked him down to meet your lips and a hungry kiss. You wanted him to understand just how much you wanted him. Greedy, sloppy, and feverishâyou put all your unbridled desire into curling your tongue around his, roughly nipping his bottom lip.
Breathing heavily, Eddie pulled away. âItâs okay?â
You nodded vigorously, almost begging him with the look in your eye to please give you what you wanted. âYou can move.â
Inching back, the slow drag of his cock between your tight walls was enough to arch your back, already missing the feel of engulfing him completely. But when he snapped his hips forward in a powerful thrust, you couldnât help the wanton moan that escaped your lips.
âFuck,â he moaned. âFuck, you feel so fucking good.â
You hummed in response, unable to formulate more of a reply than that. Even if he didnât know what he was doing yet, being stuffed full of him was already a relief of its own.
He experimented with pace and tempo. It took some time for him to find a rhythm that was to your liking. You didnât want to be too bossy or demanding, so you kept your queues limited to directing his hips with your handsâsubtly maneuvering him until you found just the right motion that made your head flop back onto the pillows. It was his first time after all, and you didnât want him to lose confidence with constant redirection.
âThere!â you gasped once he found the spot you could never reach on your own. âRight there, baby.â
âYeah?â Eddie grunted back. His hips rutted into yours in a steady, fast paced rhythm that kept you bucking into him for more. It was too good to not keep chasing the sensation of him gliding into you with each forceful pump of his cock.
Whatever he was hitting seemed to also be the off switch to your brain. All thoughts were erased from your mind in an instant, only leaving behind an instinctual need for more.
âYeah,â you repeated, no longer in control of the words falling from your lips. âYes. Yes!â
He dropped his chest down further, sweat slicked skin sliding against yours as he devoured your breathy moans in a heated kiss. You practically shouted at the new pressure of his pelvis grinding against your clit. You wrapped your legs tightly around his waist and locked your ankles together to keep him right where you wanted.
âSo fucking perfect,â he said thrkigh gritted teeth. âLook so pretty taking my cock.â
Normally dirty talk would have been another eyeroll and possibly get rid of any sexual desire you had. But it was another thing Eddie would get away with. It could be because of how grateful he looked when he said it, or because he felt so good inside you that you couldnât care less what came out of his mouth so long as he kept his hips moving.
You couldnât get enough of himâwanting to feel every inch he had to offer. You held him close, letting your hands roam around the expanse of his back. Feeling every ripple his muscles that appeared with each contraction of his torso. The ridges of his ribs. The dent of the dimples on his lower back. The soft fat of his cute little ass that you pressed harder against you to get him as deep as you could.
And there it was. The perfect combination of pressure, speed, and depth.
âEddie,â you gasped against him. âEddie, donât stop,â you pleaded breathlessly. âGod, donât stop.â
He drove into you harder, rewarded with the deafening sound of the headboard clashing against the wall. It was all getting to be too much for Eddie. The squealing of the old mattress springs, your cries of pleasure and death grip your hot, slick walls had on his cock, the bounce of your tits slapping against his chest all were causing his abdomen to contract in a way that could only mean one thing.
âIâm close,â he warned loudly, hips faltering a little.
Instinctively, your legs clenched tighter around him. You didnât want to lose it. Not again. Not knowing it would just leave you frustrated and sore. âIâm almost there,â you announced. You werenât far off, but not quite there yet. âJust a little bit more, baby, please.â
Eddie gritted his teeth and willed himself to hold it, losing both the battle and his mind with each high pitched mewl that escaped the back of your throat, each plea to not stop as you hurdled toward your release.
The hair on your arms started to stand on edge as the tingling goosebumps erupted across your naked skin. As soon as the tight coil in the pit of your belly ruptured, sending shockwaves of pleasure through your body, you lost your vision. Did you black out? You couldnât say. The only thing you could hear was the roar of blood coursing through your ears. The only sensation you could identify as you convulsed around Eddie was the tingling that radiated through every nerve you possessed. The only word you could pronounce between wails and blissful sobs was âEddie!â
Finally. After weeks of dreaming, you had Eddie Munson. After a year or so of solo ventures, you had an orgasm that wasnât by your own hand. After years of bad to mediocre sex, you had the best climax of your life. At fucking last.
When your body went completely boneless and released Eddie from the vice grip your legs had on him, he abandoned his post and collapsed next to you in a breathless, wheezing heap.
You found Eddieâs sweaty hand and laid yours atop it. He flipped it over and interlaced his fingers with yours, clutching tightly. A nonverbal way to say âIâm still here.â
Minutes ticked by as you tried to float back into your body. Eddieâs popcorn ceiling was all you could focus on while your heart stopped pulsing so hard against your face to where you could physically see the rapid beating. And when your lungs stopped screaming for air, you turned your head to see Eddie still struggling to breathe.
âShit, I gotta quit smoking,â Eddie wheezed.
You giggled and watched as he placed sloppy kiss on the back of your hand. âGlad you think thatâs funny,â he jested.
âWant me to get you some water?â You offered, trying to supress your giggles at his red and sweaty face.
He shook his head. âIâll get us both some in a second.â
You pushed yourself up on your elbow, your hand still tangled with his, and placed your chin on his chest. âDid you cum?â
âOh hell yeah!â Eddie answered eagerly. âHard not to when thereâs a hot chick screaming my name.â
You hid your face by burying it in his chest, concerned about what you said and how you sounded.
As if he could hear your thoughts, Eddie tapped the top of your head until you reluctantly looked at him. âSo fucking hot. Wouldnât change a thing. Câmere.â
You obliged, crawling up Eddieâs chest and meeting him in a smooch. A quick peck turned into two. Into three. Into one long kiss that stole what little breath you regained.
A sudden sense of dread settled in your stomach when you watched the way Eddieâs eyes raked over you. You could clearly see adoration. Appreciation. Glee. And while the look on his face should have brought you comfort and ease, anxiety took hold. Steve looked at you the same way, and that was a ruse. What if this turned out to be the same? Eddie could easily kick you to the curb now that he got what he wanted. Itâs what all men did, isnât it?
Nervously, you began to fiddle with one of the rings on his fingers. âYou know, thereâs one part of my dreams that I hope comes true.â
Eddie raised his brow. âDo tell.â
âYou donât forget me in the morning.â
Eddie snorted. âSweetheart, Iâm never going to forget you. Even when Iâm old and in the corner of some nursing home, Iâll always remember this night.â
âThatâs not what I mean, Eddie,â you said sadly. âI donât want you to act like this never happened or ignore me.â
Eddieâs smile slid from his face, an expression of concern replacing it. âIâm not gonna do that. Iâd invite you to spend the nightâshit, the whole damn weekendâbut I didnât wanna scare you. Come off creepy or whatever.â
Your abdomen felt lighter. âYou mean it?â
He kissed your forehead with a wet, loud smack. âI should have told youâwhen I said you have me, I meant it. I am your ever faithful, humble servant.â
Those damn giggles returned. âThen I suppose Iâll keep you, so long as youâll have me.â
The rest of the night was better than you could have ever imagined. After a shower that left you covering in half a dozen hickies or more, You both talked about everything that came to mind, often getting sidetracked and falling down other rabbit holes of stories before looping back to the initial thought that started it all. Eddie let you see some of the most vulnerable parts of himself, and in turn, you showed him those parts of you. Before you knew it, the front door of the trailer slammed shut, announcing the arrival of the eldest Munson.
Eddie grabbed his alarm clock and showed you the angry red numbers.
You gasped at the time. âSix in the morning?! Eddie, weâve been up all night!â
He tossed the clock carelessly onto his nightstand, not at all looking concerned when it crashed to the floor. âStop being interesting for five minutes so we can go to sleep.â
You rolled your eyes at him, but snuggled closer into his chest. This is where you wanted to be. Warm, held, and adored.
Though he wasnât at all what you dreamt of, Eddie Munson was indeed a dream come true.
ââââââââââââââââââââ
Part 2 coming soon?
For more of my writing, I recommend my current series: Disjointed.
Tagging those who responded to the feelers post and those who have been putting up w me the entire writing process!
@eddiemunsonspantschain @pastel-pillows @stayonmars @lesservillain @2clones-1kamino @laura83stuff-blog-blog @katethetank @thruheavenandhighwater @hellfiredarling @mmunson86 @b-irock
paul dano art i made for his birthday C:
It's just for me, I'll put the stories I really loved. I post it to empty my drafts. Don't mind it.
Captain hook
MasterlistÂ
Eddie Munson x Reader (She/Her)
Warnings: Swearing
Tag list: @Mikinyi @justaproudslytherpuff @angelicjinwoo @k12baby @spiderman-berriesâ @ruhro7â @justanotherhappyidiot @dontcallmesavvy @kenzi-woycehoskiâ @gh0stm3gâ @lagataprrr @spencersbookbag @ygrworld @ambernicole90 @alwaysbeenfamous @angelsarecallin @voteforevilthoughts @iameddiemunsonshair @hellf1reclub DM me if you wanna be on the Eddie tag list!:)
Synopsis: When Y/N realises that Eddie was hiding in the girls locker room, she has the decision to out him or believe him that it was all just a big misunderstanding
Afficher davantage
i want him to fuck me until HE can't walk
Request: Edward comes home from work to find his goofy little Reader playing around and wearing his Riddler outfit. They're pretending to be him, acting out a "murder" scene where he kills a "corrupt official" (in reality, they're just hitting a teddy bear with the carpet tool).
Incredible embarrassment ensues when they hear Eddie giggling behind them.
a corrupted toy
pairing â dano!edward nashton/reader
warnings â teddy bear violence
a/n â all i could picture while writing this was eddieâs beautiful smile. had me blushinâ nâ gigglinnnnâ ・â˘Ěâżâ˘Ě・ hope you enjoy anon!! (next request will be posted tonight!)
â..And so I said, yknow, you canât say that to me andâand then..â
A small stuffed toy sat on the couch, positioned to look directly at the bright screen. Itâs beady eyes had a glare as it sat so very still. The animal was extremely focused on the reality show built on wealth and fame. It was loved by many.
But the TV was only background noise for what was to come.
â..Ohhh my goshh! That is so terrible..â
From behind the couch stood a figure in green. You had every piece of the Riddlerâs outfit onâall except his clear-framed glasses. Those were with Edward, who had gone on a small shopping trip for you. You handed him a short list and gave him a loving kiss on the cheek. He couldnât have left the apartment any quicker.
Itâd been sometime since. You had to go get dressedâproperly, cling wrap and triple layered. If you were going to experiment and get the perfect feel of what being the Riddler was like, you had to go all out. You found it more difficult than it seemed, which dwindled the time you had before Edward would return home.
But you couldnât think about all that now, not with the corrupt teddy bear sitting on your couch. The sight of it made you take a deep breath. It sat there, watching the most obnoxious and meaningless show to ever air. Who paid the bills? You and your Eddie.
Breathing getting heavier with each inhale, you went for the attack.
With a shriek, you grabbed the teddy bears head and flung it to the side. The toy landed snout first, arms and legs spread. As if itâd move and fight back, you quickly slid onto your knees and crawled over. A carpet tucker was in your palm, tightly held so it wouldnât ever leave your grasp.
ââŚHa-haaaa, I wouldâve done the same thing. NoâI swear!â
The teddy bear was struck with the tool, over and over and over. It was old and the thread was weak, so there wasnât much surprise when stuffing came flying out. A mess of poly-fil began to surround you.
All you could hear was the ripping and your own breathing. Moving was a hassle and tremendously sweaty. It fueled your anger as you tore the teddy bear to shreds.
â..Has anyone seen her? Weâve been waiting for sooo long, ohmygoshh..â
A snicker comes from afar before it developed into giggles. You could almost hear it over your grunts and the tucker hitting the floor..
Edwardâs sweet giggles.
You whip around, startled from the sudden noise. The carpet tucker drops with a clank.
Edward stands at the entrance of the hallway, back towards the end. He held a couple of plastic bags in one hand.
Despite his adoring smile, you were floored with embarrassment.
âWhat are you doing?â he continues to giggle, eyes fixed on the scene before him.
You were at a loss. You couldnât move, you refused to even glance away. Every part of you was clammy and warm. Suddenly the uncomfortableness of being in the Riddlerâs position hit you.
âI..â your mouth was dry. How could you answer him without sounding like a fool? Even with that thought, you said what immediately came to mind, â..I was tucking in the carpet.â
Edward snorts and takes a step forward. He reaches over to set the bags on the couch before cutting the distance between you. Before another thought could cross your mind, Edward was getting on his knees to meet your level. Your eyes were blown wide but he felt invisible under your gaze.
Carefully, Edward reached to take his mask. Your eyes followed his hands yet you didnât fight him off. Fingers hooked to the straps, Edward pulled off the green mask to reveal your overheated, damp face. You tilt your head down instantly, knowing you looked ridiculous.
Edward suppressed a lovesick grin at your shyness. He couldnât take his eyes off you, he was too bewitched.
âYouâre gorgeous,â he sighs tenderly, mask forgotten on the ground. Edward ducks, hopeful he can get a good look at you with the positions youâre both in. You saw a hint of a smile on him.
âYou make it all look so, so good..â
âOh, Eddie..â
âOh, angeleyes,â Edwardâs infectious giggle returns, making the corners of your mouth tug, â..what did he do?â
You take a glance up at Edward. A wave of confusion tickled you, until you remembered the mess underneath you.
âOh, uhâŚthe usual. Corruption, greed. Maybe with a side of pride.â
Edwardâs eyes flicker over to the TV, and you felt embarrassment crawl back into your core.
Your head turns towards the TV, â..He enjoyed The Kardashians a little too much.â
âWhat a menace.â
You canât help but weakly laugh at Edwardâs comment. He was charming, especially when he played the part with you.
Edward took your chin in one hand and leaned in for a kiss. He made a pleasant noise against your lips, making it transparent over how much he loved the contact. All you could do was melt.
When he pulled back, Edward extended his arm to get the cling wrap off of your head. He was gentle, not wanting to make the process uncomfortable in anyway. Once it was off, he set it to the side.
âDo you have the duct tape?â he asks in all seriousness. You nod, a little lost. You dig into his parka and pull out the roll of duct tape.
Edward hums as he picked at the tape and stretched out a long piece.
âWeâll start with the eyes.â
That's so cute I'm in love
Summary- An opportunity for some extra college credit lands you tutoring a few students from Hawkins High, and it seems like one of them has a little more trouble than the rest.
Genre- Fluff
Warnings- None :)
Tag List- @thatsthewaythechrissycrumbles @munsonology @esme-viridian @gvf23
(Tag list is always open, let me know if youâd like to be added đ¤)
Word Count- 2.9k
You sighed sitting at your usual table in the library, waiting for the next student. Ever since you graduated and started your classes at the community college, youâve found a little extra time to help out the other students at Hawkins High. It was always nice when you had the college tutors help you out with your classes and you figured it was best to keep up with the tradition. After all, with their help you were able to graduate.
You opened up one of your notebooks and started scribbling away, wanting to try and kill some time as you waited and waited. Usually you never had to wait this long for someone to show up. It was always maybe a 5, 10 minutes maximum wait, but there was only one student you knew always showed up late.
âHey! Sorry Iâm-â Eddie said to you as he approached your table, not before being cut off by the librarian shushing him to keep his voice down, âSorry iâm late.â He said quietly.
He pulled out the chair next to you and set a few notebooks and folders onto the table.
âItâs alright,â You gave him a smile, âwere you able to get that last test back?â
Eddie nodded quickly and opened up the folder in front of him, flipping through the various papers that were stuffed into it. You watched as his fingers moved through the scattered quizzes and exercise sheets, and you even noticed a few doodles on them, little dragons and demons and swords. For someone the same age as you, it really seemed like he never grew out of the same things you saw from the freshmen you helped tutor. Still scribbling little doodles on his papers, still getting sidetracked and distracted when you were trying to teach him, he was just a big kid. As cute as it was, you knew something had to change if he wanted to graduate on time.
âUm⌠Alright, here it is-â He finally found the test he had been searching for in his jam packed folder, â-and hereâs a quiz we took beforehand.â He placed the two pieces of paper onto the table and you moved them closer to you to compare his work.
âAlright, so you got a 73% on the quiz, which is a lot better than last time! But you only got a 70% on this test Eds, did you look over it and figure out some things you did wrong?â
âYeah,â He nodded and moved a bit closer to you, pulling the test towards him to show you his work, âI think for number 3 i just forgot to carry the 2? And for this one, number 7, i forgot which equation is used for this type of graph so i kind of just winged itâŚâ
âEddieâŚâ You said to him in the same disappointed voice youâd heard nearly a million times beforehand from your own parents, âwe spent the last few sessions studying for this test! I know youâre smarter than just a 70%. Did you ask if you can do anything to bring the grade up?â
âYes! Mr. Jackson said that if i came back tomorrow with a full corrections sheet on the problems i missed then heâll give me back half points for all of them.â
âThatâs great! See, even he knows youâre smarter than a 70%.â
Eddie smiled to you. He hasnât really gotten this kind of treatment from someone like you before. You were the same age and he didnât feel any differently towards you than he did the other people his age. But you were different. You were someone who encouraged him to do his best, even when his best isnât perfect. He had to admit he had a slight little schoolboy crush on you, but with you being so sweet to him how could he not?
You were smart, independent, someone who knew exactly what you wanted and thatâs what he strived for. He wanted to be able to live his life the way you lived yours. Carefree.
The two of you had plenty of conversations that didnât surround his classes, and from the few things he knew about you he knew you would be a pretty cool person. Hell, if you went to Hawkins with him he couldâve sworn heâd have done better just to be able to go off to college with you and not have to leave your friendship behind.
He liked you. And he was certain that if he knew a little more about you he may even love you.
âEddie?â You asked him with a giggle, pulling him out of his trance.
âHm? What?â
âI asked you to show me all the ones you got wrong so we can work on them.â You giggled again.
Situations like this werenât uncommon with Eddie. Every time he lost his train of thought or get sidetracked you always figured he just had a difficult time paying attention, which is what led to his grades being how they were. But every time you caught him losing track of whatever it was you were saying he had the littlest twinkle in his eye when he was looking at you.
He moved his chair closer to you and flipped through the packet of papers to show you each question he had missed, and thankfully it was only a few.
âAlright, so i know that weâve gone over a this stuff right before you took this test, i have a couple of things to look through from the other kids i tutor, do you think you can try to do your corrections without my help first?â
âI think iâll be able to.â
âI think you will too,â You said to him with a smile, âdo it yourself first, and when youâre finished iâll look over it with you to see if youâre still struggling.â
Eddie nodded with a smile and took his papers back, opening up his notebook and turning to a blank page to start on his corrections. You opened up one of your folders and took out a few papers to look over as Eddie started fixing his work. Every now and then youâd glance over at Eddie to check on how things were going and heâd quickly adjust himself in his chair, turning his eyes back onto his paper and working on whatever problem he was stuck on.
Youâd give him a little smile each time you looked up, and it was quite cute to see him get a bit flustered. For someone who looked like he did, it was a pleasant surprise for him to act this way.
When you first started tutoring him, you had to admit it was a little nerve wracking. He was older than any other high school student youâve known, and thought it felt a little strange to be tutoring someone your own age, those feelings soon faded once you really sat and got to know him.
He was kind, passionate, he was someone who had been a lot nicer to you than some of your own peers at school. And you could see from helping him through his classes that he was smart. He had an amazing imagination and he excelled when it came to story building, and it showed in a few of his DnD campaigns he had told you about.
It was just math that he really struggled with.
When you glanced back over at him after looking through and editing another essay from one of the other students, you could see him staring off at the paper in front of him, making little doodles in the corner. He always had the worst attention span. You focused in on the little doodles he was doing in the corners of his paper and it seemed like the strangest thing for him to be drawing.
Hearts. Hearts of all different shapes and sizes, a few with arrows in them, a few big hearts filled with little ones. All of them surrounding one bigger heart, with something scribbled right there in the middle, but before you could get a good look at whatever he has scribbled in the center you went right back into tutor mode,
âEddie.â You said to him in a stern tone, wii joy getting his attention as he looked over to you, his hand covering up his little doodles in the corner, âI thought you were doing your corrections?â
âI am! Iâm just⌠taking a break.â
You looked over to his notes and saw that he had already worked through three of the questions he missed,
âTell you what, you get five of those finished and weâll take a break, ok? Just please try and focus on your work.â
âI will! Iâm focusing, see,â He turned the page of his notebook and began working on another problem, âfocused.â
You chuckled and went back to your work, looking over the other students papers as Eddie did his best to finish up the last two problems before your break. However, just as you put away one paper to grab the next, you could hear the eraser of Eddieâs pencil tapping onto the paper of his notebook.
You glanced over to him and saw him gently bobbing his head, his lips mouthing out a few words as his curls bounced back and forth, following the rhythm of the eraser against the paper. He had only one more problem to do, but his attention span was really affecting his work.
âEddie.â You said to him again, stopping his motions as he looked to you once again, âWe really have to fix that attention span of yours.â You said with a giggle, reaching over to grab his notebook to check his work, but he quickly snatched it back.
âWait! Iâm not finished yet, one more to go right?â
âYeah, but if youâre gonna get distracted i can at least check what you have done so far. Iâm sure youâre doing fine! Just let me look-â
âNo.â He gripped it tightly in his hand.
âWhat do you mean no? Iâm sure you did fine, just let me see.â
You reached your hand out for him to give you the notebook and he reluctantly handed it off to you, crossing his arms over his chest and staring down at the desk as you flipped through the pages. You finally found the page with his corrections, the little hearts in the corner were a dead giveaway. It was when you saw what was scribbled in the middle of that big heart that you understood why Eddie was so reluctant to give you the notebook.
There, right in the middle of the heart in his notebook, were your initials. EM + (f/i)(l/i).
You looked over at him in his seat, not giving away any indication that you had spotted the initials, and saw the bright blush on his cheeks.
It was finally starting to click.
The way he had acted around you in the past, the way that he would hang on to every word you said as it left your lips. He had paid attention to every single thing you told him at every tutoring session, and even though he knew this stuff like the back of his hand, he was back every week. With you.
You smiled a bit and giggled to yourself, Eddie glanced over at you with a scared look in his eye. He was hoping it wasnât him you were laughing at,
âWhat?â
You slowly closed the notebook and placed it onto the table between you, looking over to him with a smile on your lips,
âYou never needed my help with your classes, did you?â
He got silent, his cheeks a bright red, knowing you had him all figured out. He gently shook his head as he looked back down at the table, too embarrassed to look up at you.
A little smile formed on your lips as you thought over all the past tutoring sessions youâd had with him. Each and every time youâd notice his little glances, the way he would pay such close attention to your voice and still have a hard time with his work, and no matter how long you had worked together to bring his grade up he always brought in something new he was struggling with. It all made so much sense, and you felt like an idiot for not being able to notice it before.
He had a crush on you.
He had a crush on his tutor.
You giggled, placing your hand over your lips to try and stifle it, not wanting to embarrass him any more than he already had been,
âIâm sorry, i donât mean to laugh, i justâŚâ Your mind kept wandering back to all the times you had heard Eddie humming and tapping along on his notebook, each and every time you had heard it, it was all the same melody. The same song. You knew exactly what it was, you just couldnât put your finger on it,
âWhatâs that Van Halen song?â
He finally looked up to you, the corners of his lips curling into a gentle smile,
âWhich one?â
âYou know the one. The one youâve been humming every time you come to see me?â
âOh, yeah,â You finally got a laugh out of him, âHot For Teacher?â
âYes! Thatâs it, thatâs the one!â
The librarian at the front desk looked over to the two of you and put her finger over her lips, signaling for you both to quiet down. You gave her a nod and a quick and quiet âSorryâ before going back to Eddie,
âYou must really like that song, hm?â
âWellâŚâ Now he was getting bashful, âItâs not a favorite, but i always think of it whenever i come to see you.â
You smiled with one another, though Eddie was still unsure of your feelings towards him. You knew he liked you, and though it felt very strange to have one of your students have a crush on you, you knew it was innocent. Hell, if he wasnât a student youâd go out with him in a heartbeat, but not now. Not like this.
âI think thatâs sweet. But you didnât have to have your grades suffer just to spend time with me, we couldâve always just hung out if you asked.â
He was taken back, eyes widening,
âReally? All i had to do was ask?â
You nod and giggle as he leans back in his chair,
âWell shit, if i knew that i wouldnât have fucked my algebra grade up this bad.â
âHow bad is it?â You asked him, though he gave you no answer, only looking back down at the table, âEddie.â You said more sternly.
ââŚ63% in the class.â
âEddie!â
The librarian looked over at you two once more, this time her eyebrows furrowed in frustration. She didnât even have to say a word for you to quiet down.
âEddie,â You whispered to him, âyouâre so close to graduating, why would you mess your grade up that bad?â
âI donât know, i just like being able to spend time with you.â
You sighed and smiled to him. Though it was always nice to be able to see him and spend time with him after school in the library, you knew he was so much smarter than this.
âIâll tell you what, because i know youâre smart enough to get at least an 80% by yourself wirh these corrections and the next few assignments, how about we make a deal?â
He looked to you strangely,
âWhat kind of a deal?â
You smiled and tore a little piece out of his notebook, grabbing your pen and scribbling down your phone number on it,
âWhen you graduate, if you get higher than an 80% in this class, iâll take you out on a date. Sound good?â
He perked up immediately, not expecting you to be so upfront. He nodded quickly, still not being able to say much. He was still a little embarrassed.
âGood. Here,â You handed him the little slip of paper, âif you actually need help with something, go ahead and call me. And make sure you let me know when you graduate ok?â You smiled to him as you saw the pink on his cheeks, he mouthed the number in his hand to himself as you stood up and started collecting your things.
âWait, are you going?â He asked you as you placed your few notebooks and folders into your bag.
âEddie, you and i both know youâre smart enough to get all those corrections done on your own.â You stood up from your chair and pushed it in as you slug your bag over your shoulder, âAnd remember, if you do need help, you have my number.â
He nodded again and straightened himself in his seat, opening up his notebook to the next blank page and starting his corrections once more. All he really needed was a push in the right direction, and he was glad you were the one to help him get there.
You gave each other a smile and a quiet wave as you made your walk out of the library, only to quickly turn back. You approached Eddie once more, pushing his bangs back and giving him a kiss onto his temple,
âYouâre gonna do great. This is your year, remember?â
He looked up to you and you could see just how much that meant to him.
After all this time, after everything youâve heard about him, after all the times youâve had to get him back on track after getting distracted or showing him the same problem solving methods nearly a hundred times, you still didnât give up on him. You made him want to work his hardest.
He wanted to finish this year, finally, all for you.
Ethan Landry x GN!Reader
Masterlist if you want to read my other things.
TW/CW: murder, breaking in, voyeurism, sexual activity(it don't go far), no p in v(they're not even naked).
it's good i guess. i feel like the end is weird though. (18/07/2023) (3614 words)
Ethan sighs deeply, already feeling the frustration tears drowning his eyes. Even though his vision was blurry, he could still see your shape, of course he could, you're the only thing he could ever see. His hand was closed thight on the handle of his knife. He couldn't believe you, and at the same, he couldn't blame you as you could never do harm, not to him.
He knew your relationship was hard to maintain, but did you really have to cheat on him ? Yes, you did not talk much together, ok you did not spend time on a date in a long time but it was hard, he was busy and you were always with your friends.
The last date you had only together was something like three month ago, it was a study date. You weren't in a good mood, either. You wanted to be in your friends group but they already formed duo and as the group is uneven, you ended up with him. You weren't too happy and he knew it, so he did what he could to help you. You spent the afternoon in the library. He was so happy that day, quite the opposite of right now.
He was biting the inside of his cheek to contain any insults to come out. As much as he liked seeing you like this, he hated the situation in itself.
Ethan was fucking pissed. Hidden in your closet, his dark eyes were watching each one of your movements. Usually, the smell of your fresh and clean clothes beside him would have calmed him to a state of sleepiness. But not today.
You brought someone over.
One of his friends by that. Well, not that much of a friend. Ethan doesn't really have any, his only goal is to avenge his brother after all. None of his relationship here are true.
Expect yours. The one you and him have. It's something indescribable. A link that goes upon everything, every law and physics. He understands you better than anyone else. You understand him better than everyone else.
Each breath you take is a benediction for Ethan who's the happiest man alive thanks to your existence. It was an addiction, really. Something so hard to forget, to ignore. Ethan was deeply in love. And he's sure you are, too.
You have these eyes that tell him everything he needs to know.
But well, you weren't ready for the officialisation and the whole relationship thing. And he understands that. He truly does. As even himself had trouble accepting his love. Your link is so strong, so powerful that you can be scared of it. Of the love you have for each other. He'd die for you, he'd kill for you.
He'd do anything.
Hence why he was hidden in your closet in his ghostface suit. Because he wanted to protect you. To make you feel safe. Each time he was hiding under your bed, he heard you confess to your friends about how you have trouble sleeping, that you feel watched. And Ethan hates the idea of someone bothering you. And in the blink of an eye, he was already armed and ready to protect you.
And he's sure you feel better ! That is if he doesn't mention the time you put a blanket on the said closet because you were feeling paranoid. Ethan was worried this day, he couldn't see you anymore through the slits.
Ethan watches as the man above you on the bed pull up your shirt to let you appear bare before him. He watches as you kiss him hungrily, your hands caressing every curve of his body and Ethan wants to fucking destroy everything.
Your one night stand's hands are flat on your chest, caressing it with a barely concealed horniness. You already want more, and he seems to think like you.
Your hands goes under his shirt, touching every inch of skin you could. Your nails grazing the area from time to time and he likes it, hard, by the smile he's giving you.
You were going to pull his clothe up above his head when his phone ring. He turns his head a brief moment before you grab his jaw with your hand to make him look at you again.
"Ignore it." you say between two heated breath.
And he did just that. After all, he was as horny as you. He'd never stop anything for a stupid phone call. His tongue lick at yours, his hands pass on your perked nipple. But the phone ring again. The song was louder than your breathy moans, you were starting to get out of the mood. And the phone ring again, again and again. Until your one night stand curse and get off you. He's as frustated as you.
"Fuck, who the hell is that? he says.
The man moves away, grabbing his phone to see who was the person who ruined the mood. You sigh, a little disappointed the moment had been cut short. Finding your room's temperature way too cold in comparison to his warm body.
You're left laying on the bed, staring at the ceiling and regaining your breath.
You don't have that much success with men. The times you fucked can by coumpted with one hand. So yeah, you were pissed to be bothered by a stupid phone call.
You were frustrated. You needed to fuck. This guy wasn't even your friend. He was nice enough and pretty so you went for it. But you didn't feel bad as he was probably thinking the same of you.
-So ? You ask impatiently.
-It's just Ethan. I'll put the phone in mute.
-Who's Ethan ?
-Landry ? One of my friends. He's in our math class ? Anyway, he's a friend."
By your face, he understands that you have no idea who this Ethan Landry may be. And that you don't care. This Ethan was just the fucker who disturbed you, he could go to hell for that matter. He shrugs, smiling when he can now get back to business. His hand roams your hips then go up to caress your tummy. Your hand goes on his shoulder and you pull him to you to kiss him.
The call was already forgotten. The temperature heated up.
His shirt is quickly out of the way, same for his pants and yours. His clothed erection rub against your genitals, you're burning from the inside. You thrust your hips against his and he smiles.
Your hand grab a handful of his hair and pull on it, the man smiles, his mouth leaving yours to start and suck on your neck. The boner in his underwear rub against your underwear. His last piece of clothes was hot and wet. At this point, it felt like he was naked. You could feel every veins and curve of it against you.
Finally, you thought, you're finally getting some dick. You just hope he's good.
Ethan saw fucking red. His hands were shaky. His whole body crumble with rage. His thoughts are full of one thing: fucking destroy him.
He had the audacity to take his lover from him, he had the audacity to fuck them before him, he had the audacity to fucking ignore him ?
No, no that's not possible. No, of course no. Ethan is a man of words. He swore he wouldn't let you slip between his fingers and he fucking won't. Tears fall from his eyes, from anger ? Sadness ? Frustration ? He doesn't know. But he starts laughing.
You both stop moving. The man turn around and stare at the closet before looking at you again, as if to make sure you heard that too.
Everything happened well too quickly for you to understand. You blinked and a man rushed out of the closet, knife in hand. Clothed in a Ghostface outfit. You screamed and tried to back off him, but with a wall behind you, you couldn't go really far.
Ghostface jumps on the bed, knife in the air, and suddenly, he plunges the blade in your fling's body. Blood splatter everywhere. Tears are running down your face and you can't control yourself.
You try to leave and fall off the bed before crawling on the ground to the door. You were still facing him as to be sure he wasn't coming to you. But it didn't seem he was interested by you.
It was as if he didn't even saw you.
Ghostface plunges his knife once, twice, and a lot more time in the already lifeless body with an uncontrollable rage. His hits were fast and angry, he was taking everything out on him. Hitting everywhere he could.
Crying, you try to get up, you fall the first time because of your shaking legs but you're standing seconds later. As silently as possible, you leave the room. You grab your phone and try to open the door but cry harder when it's locked. Your roomate locked it when they left.
Where is the key ? Where is the fucking key ? You don't want to die. You don't want to die ! In your panick, you drop your phone. But in a rush, you don't bother picking it up again.
By the time you found it, Ghostface was done with his prey. He was waiting for you before the door, head tilted. Blood was dripping from his knife and the white color of his mask was almost non existent.
You shake your head, crying your eyes out. The keys tightly held in your hands. You're dead. You're dead and you don't even know what you did to deserve that.
He stays before the door, no budging. He knows this door is your last hope and he's crushing it before your eyes. You try to think of another exit but there is none. You're at the fifth floor, if you jump, you're dead. But maybe it's better than to be killed because you know for sure: Ghostface is going to kill you.
"Please, you beg, I didn't do anything. you shake your head, body trembling like a leaf.
-I know." he says.
It wasn't even a real voice. You'll never know who is your killer. Your heart was probably going to explode at this rate. You couldn't breath, eyes boring into his hands, makig sure he wasn't moving. You were choking on your own saliva, crying each time his head moved a little.
When he takes a step, you squeal and back off, begging and crying, your words were slurred together, you couldn't even understand yourself what you were saying. You don't want to die, not like this. Your vision is blurry by your tears, all you see of him is a black spot with a white point. He's approaching.
"Don't cry, my love. I'm here." he says.
You frown and look at his mask in search of an answer. You couldn't see his facial expression and it was killing you. Who is this ? What do they want ? Why do they act as if they know you? You're scared, you're going to throw up.
"Please, let me live. you beg, one last time.
-I will, love. I will."
When he arrives before you, you close your eyes tightly. Praying this would be quick. But instead of slaughtering you like he did to the other, he puts his arms around you, holding you close to him. He shush you slowly, like you're a clid.
You're tensed, you stopped breathing and you're completly paralyzed. Every one of your muscle is put in pause. You don't dare look at his face, instead, you keep your eyes to the robe.
"Calm down, he says, you're okay. It's just me."
He was calm and you couldn't understand a thing. Who is 'me' ? Why doesn't he kill you when he already killed someone ? Why is he even hugging you ? What's happening ? You need to get out of here. Right, now.
"You're safe with me. Nothing will happen to you." you know his mask, his words, will haunt you until your death.
And when he lets you go, he gives you your phone back. He puts his hand on your head, touching your hair slowly before leaving by the front door.
Your eyes bore holes in the door, terrified at the idea of him coming back. You fall on the ground and vomit everything you could. Bawling your eyes out, you remember the dead man in your bed and call the cops with a shaky hands.
You don't remember much after that. Just that at some point, cops came and escorted you outside. You were alone on the parking building when you saw stretcher-bearer bring the dead body of the poor man in their car.
You stare at your hands, they're shaking and you want to throw up again just thinking about everything. The criminal fled, he killed him and he fled. You burst out in tears again, closing your eyes. A nurse comes talk to you but you can't hear anything. They're guiding you, you just follow.
You're empty. You can't think of aything else than the dead man. He's dead and you're not, why ? That's unfair. You're the one who invited him over. You should have died.
When you recognize a little more your surrondings, you're seated on the edge of the ambulance car with a coat on the shoulder, and now, you wear a pant. Hugging yourself. You don't even know how you got here, nor when. But you don't care. He's dead. He died. What the fuck. He got killed. Someone killed him. Someone was in your fucking closet in the first place. Was it even the first time ?
You know cops will ask you questions and you have no idea what you're supposed to tell them. That the man you were going to fuck had been killed by a ghostface hidden in your damn closet ? Yeah, you'll be put in jail before the end of your story. Your face is so dry, your body is numb. You can't feel anything other than guilt.
Ghostface disappeared, there is no proof of him having been there. From everyone's point of view, you two were alone and you killed him.
He's dead. The only man you ever talked to in months, dies after minutes in your flat. You're cursed. Did you really kill him ? No, no you didn't. You couldn't have known a killer was at home. It's not your fault. It's not your fault, it's not your fault.
Someone walks towards you. You know it's the cops. It's the end. It's the moment where you're wrongfully accused. Your eyes were glued to the ground and shoes enter your field of view. It do not look like cop's legs.
Well, if it is, he's not in service. Because that's a jean you're seeing right now. You follow the member further up to the face. You frown. That's definitely not a cop.
He smiles at you. He's young, maybe your age. He has curly hair and a boyish face. Who is that ?
"Hey, he says. You okay?
Your eyes are red and glossy. You're covered in blood and it's not even yours. You look like you saw a ghost and somehow, you did.
Do you look okay ? Is that really a fucking question ? Because you just witnessed a murder and you almost died yourself. So no, you're not fucking okay.
-Yeah, right. Sorry." He says.
He's not a nurse and he's not a cop. But he's not your friend or family either. Who is he ?
-My name's Ethan. I was a friend of... And it clicks. He's the one who called: Ethan Landry, from your math class.
-Yeah, I know."
Ethan sits next to you on the edge of the car. He smiles lightly. You ask yourself what is he doing here then decide to ignore it. He lost a friend. He raises his hand towards you, searching your eye for peermission to touch you and you shrug. He caresse gently your back to rassure you, to soothe you.
You don't know him but he's nice and you need someone. Everyone is running back and forth, ignoring you. You witnessed a damn murder and nobody bother to stay with you.
You two stayed like this a really long time. At least, in your mind it was long. Ethan tried to approach you more, moving his body. Then, he pulled your head to force you to lay it on his shoulder. But you didn't want to.
So you got up and moved away from him. When you faced him, his eyes were empty. You couldn't see any emotion. No sadness, no fear, no hapiness, no anger, just a void. It made a chill run down your spine.
Fortunaly, two cops arrived. One of them smiled at you, you didn't feel any compassion but he at least had the decency to try unlike the other who simply left without a word. The man tells you to sit down and you do, far from Ethan. Then, when you thought he'd talk to you, he turned to your new 'friend'.
"Ethan, right ? You told my colleague you were their boyfriend?
What ? You look at your said boyfriend and frown? Why would he say that ?
-Yes, I am. And I was a good friend of... He sighs but something in you tells you it's fake. I can't believe he's...
Something isn't right.
-Since the witness, your partner, is in shock and can't talk, we'd like you to share your contact details as we have to convoke you later for your deposition.
Why can't I talk ? Why is Ethan looking at me ? His eyes seems loving at first glance but when you really look into them, there is a sense of threat that reside. He's talking to you without words. He tells you to keep it shut.
-Of course, no problem. he stays silent while grabbing his phone, then lift his eyes and stare at the cops face. Just so you know, they didn't do anything.
-We'll see about that. Says the cop to conclude the interaction.
-Yeah, we'll see." Says 'Ethan' with a clenched jaw.
When the cops leave, you're left alone with him once again. Your hearing is muffled. In the background, a faint siren noise. Blurry stains of red and blue is all you see. The man puts his hand on your thight and you cringe. You try to get away from him, from this stranger.
Frustrated, hot tears start flowing down your face. You don't even cry strictly speaking as you stay silent. You can't feel anything, your body is just reacting to the situation alone. Ethan raises his hand to dry your tears and you back off to avoid him touching you.
Who the hell is this man ? And why is he here ? Telling everyone he's your partner ? Someone is dead for god's sake ! Does he really think it's the best time to joke ?
Other officers arrive towards you. You want to tell them you don't know who that damn man is. You want to scream at them so bad yet you can't. You don't know why but you can't move.
Ethan takes you in his arms. Tightening his hold around you. From the exterior, he looks like a caring boyfriend comforting his partner. But it's not. You don't know him.
Cops don't pay attention to you anymore, simply analyzing the area. You're left alone with him, this 'Ethan'. Is it really his name ? You don't find him as nice as before. Actually, you feel in danger with him. You try to push him but he hold you so thight it hurt.
He lifts you up without a care. You're scared. You don't know who he is nor what he wants, what he'll do. Just like Ghostface.
"Let me go." you cry, with weak and shaky voice as loud as a whisper.
He ignores it. He presses your chest flat against his, shushing you. And you know, you know it's him. You recognize him. You struggle, trying to leave. But he forces, hurting you. You beg, praying someone could come. But even if they did, they'd think you're crazy. Crazy after seeing such a horrible scene. Nobody will believe you.
Your body is shaking, you have trouble breathing and you can't articulate your thoughts. There is so much happening, outside and inside your head.
"Don't cry, my love. I'm here." he says, and you know, you know he said that.
Your tears are flowing freely. You close your eyes, trying to stop them but it's impossible. You're whining, pushing him away with all the sthrenght left in you, which isn't a lot. It's him, it's his fault. He killed him, he's Ghostface. You know it.
"Breath, it's okay.
No it's not. It's the killer, you're stuck with him. He won't ever let you go. He killed him with so much hatred, with so much rage. You're terrified of what he could do to you. He used such a violent manner to do it, too.
You can't even tell how many times this monster stabbed him. It was never ending. He never was satisfied, his fury keeping him from stopping.
You cry, and cry and cry but nobody cares. Maybe it is your fault. Maybe he really got killed because of you. Or maybe you could have helped.
-You're safe with me. Nothing will happen to you."
OMG you should do a gareth x reader and like you join the hellfire club and he has crush on you and he ends up telling you and you like him back!
Idk why it took me so long to write this. Characterizing Gareth should not have been as difficult as it was lmao. But y'know what it took to finish this? Sitting upside down. In a chair.
Like, y'know in big hero 6 when Tadashi holds Hiro upside down or whatever to get him to think and it worked? Yeah. That was me.
But I hope you enjoy this, it definitely got away from me lol. It wasn't supposed to be this long and the ending was definitely a little rushed. But whatever.
(Also, somewhere in an alternate universe, Gareth does turn out to be an axe murderer)
---
Word count: 5.8k
Pairing: Gareth Emerson x Reader
Warnings: underage drinking, swearing, mentioned drug use
Request Here
---
Eddie strutted down the hall with you at his side, excitement putting an extra bounce in his steps. He looked like a child, the pins on his jacket rattling.
You smiled faintly. A few weeks ago he asked you to play D&D with him. The two of you had gotten together to get high once or twice, you bought all your shit from him. And you mentioned how you used to play back in middle school.
That spurred the conversation of the Hellfire Club, which you'd heard a lot about. Mostly bad things if you were being honest, but hey. That was highschool.
It took him a while to convince you to join his club, and then bring you up to speed on all the rules and remind you how to play.
But now here you were, joining your first campaign with the Hellfire Club. You were pretty excited, you couldn't lie.
Not like you'd tell Eddie that. He'd be even more bouncy than he was right now.
Eddie kicked the door to their 'club room' with a loud crash, "hey nerds!" He called with an obnoxious grin.
You followed him into the room, which used to be the old theatre, but considering a new and bigger theater had just been built, this one was given to Eddie's club. It was really the only room they could spare.
Plus, it was pretty on brand; playing a fantasy game where drama had taken place.
They were backstage and all the lights seemed to be on. They were very colorful too, lighting the room up beautifully. There was also discarded sets and other junk pushed towards the walls and out of the way.
You went to look at the table where the other members sat, leaving the throne at the head of the table empty. You guessed that was Eddie's seat. His place at the table was already all set up, there were even candles lit on either side.
The rest of the table was occupied by the club members. A handful of them were underclassmen. You could tell by their baby faces. "Henderson! Drumroll!" He pointed to the table as he got closer.
A boy with brown curls obediently began to drum his fingers against the table, muttering, "why doesn't the drummer do the drumroll?"
"Shut it," Eddie said, pointing at him again. He got close enough to step right up onto the table. And then he bowed low, hand extended to where you stood with an amused smile.
"Please welcome the newest member of Hellfire! Y/N L/N!" He cheered as he rose back up, to which received several greetings ranging in enthusiasm.
Eddie grinned and hopped down from the table. He stepped forward and walked behind you, guiding you forward. "Curly is Dustin Henderson," he said, pointing him out once again. "His friends, Michael Wheeler, and Lucas Sinclair," he said, pointing to each of them.
You smiled and waved to the three younger boys. They looked like babies, they were so young. You wanted to squeeze their cheeks.
"That's Jeff. And finally, there's Gareth. He's a pain, ignore him more than you ignore the others," he instructed you very seriously.
Your eyes lingered on Gareth. He had the fluffiest hair you'd ever seen and you could imagine how soft it would feel beneath your fingers. He wore the same shirt as the others, white and black with the Hellfire logo. He also layered on a red and black flannel with the sleeves cut off.
Gareth fixed his annoyed look on Eddie. "And why should they ignore me?" He asked, his voice higher than you thought but beautiful to listen to.
"Because you're a pain," Eddie repeated with a 'duh' tone. But unfortunately for him, the only free spot they had was beside Gareth. He glared at Gareth like it was his fault once he realized.
You clapped Eddie on the shoulder with a laugh,"I deal with you everyday. I'm sure I can handle Gareth," you assured with a grin, going and sitting next to Gareth.
Eddie smiled before he understood, and when he did his expression grew annoyed. "Ha ha, very funny," he droned, sitting on his throne. "Now everybody shut up and let's get started!"
---
As soon as the session was over, Dustin cornered you while you waited for Eddie to pack up. He eagerly chatting your ear off about just about everything. You found it endearing how enthusiastic he was. His friend Mike, looked apologetic though as he awkwardly stood at his side.
"So how do you know Eddie?" Dustin asked, adjusting his cap. "Are you guys friends?"
"Oh, he's my deâŚuh, detention partner," you quickly altered your sentence. Maybe it wasn't the best idea to tell the kid Eddie was your dealer. Plus it wasn't like you were lying, Eddie had been your detention partner a couple of times.
"Really?" Dustin asked, ignoring Mike's urging warning that they were going to be late. "How long have you been playing D&D?"
"Since eighth grade," you answered honestly. "Gave me something to do after school."
"Why did you just now join Hellfire?" Mike finally gave in and asked a question. You knew he was curious too, after all you were a new face.
"Because I was too busy before," you shrugged, glancing to see if Eddie had packed up all his things yet. You looked back at the boys. "And I never had a ride."
"Do you need a ride?" Gareth asked, swinging his bag over his shoulder and stopping next to you. The way he looked you up and down wasn't as subtle as he thought it was.
"Nah, Eddieâ"
"Gareth, you take 'em home," Eddie cut you off. "I forgot, I have to take Henderson and Wheeler. Their ride is busy so of course, the burden falls to me," he said with a shake of his head.
Dustin swung his head around to stare at Eddie. "What!?" He yelped. "What happened to Steve? Why didn't you say anything sooner!" He shouted, storming over to Eddie.
Gareth tilted his head towards the door and you nodded, walking out of the theater with him. It was silent for a few moments before you broke it.
"So you're a drummer?" You asked.
Gareth looked over at you and nodded, "yeah, for our band. Eddie tell you?"
You shook your head. "You're in a band? Eddie's in a band and he didn't tell me? That ass," you scoffed.
"I'm surprised you've gone this long without knowing," Gareth replied earnestly. "He's your dealer, right? I think he's mentioned you a few times."
"Didn't want to say it in front of the kids," you nodded, "but yeah. That's how I originally met him."
"So you've been 'round his? I know you've seen his guitar," Gareth held the door open for you. "He uses it for gigs only. It's his prized possession."
You suddenly remembered the name of the band. Eddie invited you out one day but you'd been too busy to attend. Now you had a reason to attend one of their shows. "Corroded Coffin, right?" You asked with a proud grin at remembering.
Gareth smiled at you. And wow was his smile beautiful. He nodded. "So ya do know our band," he mused. "Yes, I'm our drummer."
"Well considering that Dustin kid was asked to drumroll and not you, I'm gonna assume you're notâ"
"Hey," Gareth said, affronted, turning to point a finger at you, "I'll let you walk home," he threatened.
"I didn't say it," you held your hands up in surrender. "I said nothing. What you use to fill in the blanks is entirely yourâ"
"Oh shut up," Gareth elbowed you in the side.
You jumped away from him with a scowl on your face, rubbing your injured side. "I'm not feelin' the love here, Gareth," you huffed. "I think I will walk home," you said, making a 90° turn and walking off.
"Hey!" Gareth shouted, grabbing your arm before you could get too far and pulled you back against his side. He casually tossed an arm around your side to prevent a repeat. "Eddie would murder me with my own sticks if I let you walk home."
"Maybe then youâll learn some manners,â came your snarky reply but you let him guide you. You tried to ignore how his touch made you feel.
âLook who's talking,â Gareth replied, unfortunately releasing you. He walked around to the driver's seat and unlocked the doors.
You grinned and got in the car. âSo, besides playing D&D and playing the drums, what do you do?â You asked, a pathetic attempt to keep the conversation going as you clicked your seatbelt on.
Gareth ignored his own seatbelt and put his arm behind your seat as he twisted to look behind him as he reversed out of his parking spot. âReally?â He asked, making eye contact briefly. âSmall talk?â
Warmth coursed through your body as you rolled your eyes, trying to pretend like the small action didn't fluster you. You were rapidly developing a crush on him. You were unable to decide if it was surface level attraction or if it'd maybe have a chance to develop into something real. âAre you really judging me, drummer boy?â You mocked.
âOh wonderful, I havenât ever been called that before,â he said flatly, turning and removing his hand from behind your seat. âAsk me something worthwhile.â
You took a moment to think about an âinterestingâ question. âOkay, whatâs the weirdest thing you have been called?â You asked.
Gareth paused to actually think about it. "Freak," he answered honestly. "That's what just about most of the school calls me. Us. Hellfire," he clarified.
You had to admit, you felt your heart squeeze at the sympathy you felt for him. You despised the words especially when it was used so maliciously. You pursed your lips, "that was supposed to be a light hearted question, sorry."
Gareth only laughed. "Hey, well, you asked," he replied, tapping the steering wheel. "Better get used to it. I did. Easier that way."
"No thanks," you shook your head for emphasis. "The second anyone calls me that, they're getting my fist."
"That's fair," Gareth conceded. "Hey, where am I going anyways?" He asked with a frown, slowing slightly to give you time to answer..
"Oh you missed the turn about a mile ago," you confessed, looking up at him. "But I figured it was too late to tell you."
Gareth was silent for a few seconds before he exploded. "What!?" He loudly demanded. "I am never driving you anywhere ever again!" He exclaimed. "Why didn't you say anything!"
"Sorry!" You shouted back. "I'm sorry! I justâŚI don't know, don't yell!"
"You're yelling too!" Gareth screeched, making a wild U-turn. You heard several things rattle and roll in his car.
"Heyâhey! Cool it with the crazy driving!" You continued to shout, holding onto what you dubbed the 'oh shit' handle on the roof. He was worse than Eddie, which was saying a lot.
"Just tell me where I'm going!" Gareth turned to look at you, a crazy grin on his face as he continued to shout.
You realized he wasn't upset, but rather having fun. You grinned. "Just drive!" You managed between laughter. "You don't have anywhere to be, do you?"
Gareth shook his head no and joined in your laughter. "I like you!" He shouted.
"Then why are you yelling!?"
Gareth's smile never died as he repeated, in a much more respectable volume, "I like you."
You grinned, "thank you," you responded. "You're not so bad, for a drummer," you added belatedly.
Gareth's eyes went wide and his mouth dropped open in very obvious, and deep offense. "What's that supposed to mean?"
"Exactly what I said."
Gareth scowled, "you got a problem with drummers?"
"Well, the last drummer I dated was crazy. I find the guitarist to be much more saneâ"
"Uh, in what world is the guitarist more sane than the drummer!?" Gareth wildly demanded. "No way is Eddie more sane than I am!"
"Hey I'm just telling you my past experiences!" You defended, "I didn't say I like Eddie more than youâwell, actuallyâ"
"I'm giving you a ride home." Gareth sounded deeply offended again as he turned to stare at you.
"Eddie gives me drugs."
"That you buy. I'm doing this for free and in my own time."
You paused. You didn't have a response for that because he did have a point. "Fine," you conceded. "Fine, fine. Sorry for insulting you, drummer boy."
Gareth's victorious grin twisted into a scowl. "Can't you come up with a different nickname?"
"No."
Gareth sighed as he took a right turn. "I need a nickname for you now. It's only fair," he stated.
"No," you turned down, you knew this could only end in an embarrassing or terrible nickname. You had a reputation to maintain, you couldn't let him give you a nickname that would likely stick and catch on.
"You're a nerd but that justâŚdoesn't fit," Gareth murmured to himself, staring out at the road.
You were concerned about the spaced out look on his face and thought maybe it wasn't a smart idea to let him drive you around.
"...I'll think of it," he finally shrugged. "But you need a new name other than drummer boy," he said, pointing a finger at you.
"Thumper," you replied.
"Will you be the Bunny to my Thumper?" Gareth wasted no time in asking.
You paused. "You've seen Bambi?" You asked in surprise. He didn't seem the type to sit through that kind of movie.
"I have a younger sister," Gareth offered in explanation, glancing over at you, "we've seen it a million times. Even my older sister's made me watch it."
You wanted to tease him, but you thought it was so sweet he watched it with her so many times. You smiled instead, "that's cute."
"Don't tease me," Gareth warned seriously.
"I'm not," you said quickly, "swear on my life. I'm not teasing you. I think it's cute that you watch movies with them."
Gareth tapped the steering wheel again to an imaginary beat and nodded, accepting that answer. "Do you need to be home soon?"
"I don't have a curfew," you answered, whichâŚwasn't completely honest but he didn't need to know that. You wanted to spend more time with him though, he was interesting. And cute.
"Good. I was gonna take a ride out to the drive-in. I hope you like horror," he looked over at you again.
"The drive-in is in the next city," you stated the obvious.
"Yep," Gareth agreed.
"Okay," you said. This would be fun. You hoped. You had just met him, but he didn't strike you as an axe murderer or something.
---
Gareth was in fact, not an axe murderer. The two of you went to the drive in together and saw a horror movie that you honestly lost the plot of, too distracted by him.
He was very engrossed by the movie. He laughed at parts he definitely shouldn't have, popcorn in hand. He made snide little comments about the actors or the movie in general.
His commentary made you crack up and you couldn't focus with him murmuring some smartass comment in your ear every few minutes.
You wouldn't have changed a thing about the night.
Well. You'd change one thing.
Gareth walked you up to your door with the excuse of, "you never know where a murderer might be lurking."
You doubted they'd lurk in the few feet from the street to your door, but you decided to humor him.
So you walked with him, arms brushing together with every step. Neither of you made an attempt to stop the contact. Neither of you attempted more contact
When you arrived at your door, he stopped you from opening it with a hand on your arm. "Hey," he began, shifting his weight and dropping his hand.
You turned to him, the faint light of your neighbor's porch light illuminated his face enough for you to see his shifting gaze. "Hi," you warmly replied, smiling at him.
"Hi," he laughed, looking away. He cleared his throat and tucked his hands into his jean pockets. He rocked forward on his toes as he spoke. "You should come to our show."
You were nodding before you even comprehended the suggestion. But once you did, you smiled. "You want me to come to your show?"
Gareth looked away again and shrugged, "yeah. Thought you'd like it. I'll prove I am a good drummer despite what some people think," he pointedly said.
Your smile grew. "I'll be there," you promised. You found yourself wishing for a kiss. Hell, even a brush of his lips against your cheek would sate you. But of course, nothing happened.
Gareth took a step back and nodded at you. "Night, bunny," he said, turning around and heading back to his car.
"Night, thumper," you murmured, your voice lost to the night. You stared at his back for a second longer before finally turning and heading inside.
---
You informed Eddie of your plans and Gareth's invitation and he would not leave you alone. You regretted telling him.
"Wait, wait. I explicitly told you to stay away from Gareth and you went on a date with him!?" He screeched, his voice disappearing into the forest surrounding you two. Thankfully, you decided to have this conversation outside of school.
"It wasn't a date," you denied, waving a hand. You sat up on the picnic table and stared down at where he was sitting on the bench. "It was just a movie."
"No, it was a movie at the drive-in," Eddie replied, putting more emphasis on the words like a weirdo. "You know what happens at drive-ins? Sex!" He shouted. Like a weirdo.
You grimaced, "what? No, stop. I didn't sleep with your best friend. Calm down," you huffed. "Jeez, Eddie. It was just a movie."
"Oh really? How do I know you didn't have sex in the backseat?" Eddie pressed.
You rolled your eyes. "You're disgusting," you stated.
"That's hateful," Eddie replied. "How come you never come to my shows when I invite you? Why is Gareth so special?" He complained.
He was right to complain. He invited you to his shows a couple of times, but you'd always declined. Either you were too busy or you weren't particularly interested.
That had been before you met the cute drummer.
"He's not special. I'm just not busy this week," you lied. "If you would have asked me, I would have said yes." You probably wouldn't have. No offense to Eddie.
"Mhm," Eddie hummed, eyes narrowed in suspicion. "Fine. I'll believe you," he said. "I'll give you a ride. I guess."
You grinned.
---
Eddie picked you up as promised. Once you were inside, he left you at the bar as he went to go set up.
Fuck did he undersell his band. There were already people gathering and more coming inside as time passed. You were impressed.
And by the time their set started, a crowd had gathered around the stage, dancing to the music and hyping up the band with their support.
You didn't join the crowd and instead stayed at the bar and watched. You had a good view of the whole band from where you were. And by that, you meant you had a good view of Gareth.
And sure, Eddie was absolutely killing it on stage, his voice was perfect for his songs and his playing was unparalleled. But your eyes were glued to Gareth, who was enthusiastically slamming his sticks against the drum kit. Head bopping to his own music with an infectious smile.
You got into the music quickly, but your eyes never strayed from Gareth for too long. He was too captivating to look away from.
But when the show ended and the band packed their things up, you finally turned away from the stage.
"How'd you like the show?"
You looked over and nearly fell out of your chair. "King Steve?" You couldnât stop the old title from tumbling from your lips, you were that surprised at seeing him. "Holy shit! What are youâthis doesn't seem like your type of scene." Granted, you didnât know much about Steve Harrington nowadays. You hadn't seen him in two years.
Steve awkwardly laughed, rubbing the back of his neck. "It's not," he agreed, "Eddie invited me." He shrugged and stuffed his hands in his pockets.
"Ah," you said slowly, nodding in understanding. "Eddie invited you."
Steve rolled his eyes, "it's not like that."
"Sure," you answered. "But it's fine if it is," you offered. "Gareth invited me."
"Steve," Gareth said, startling you as he materialized behind you. "Eddie didn't say he invited you." He gave him little more than a glance though before looking at you. "Hi."
You smiled, "hi," you responded. "You were amazing."
Gareth grinned, obviously pleased by the compliment. He ruffled the hair behind his ears, "thanks," he said. âSo? Iâm a good drummer, right?â
You playfully tilted your head as if pretending to think about it. He shoved you over and you shook with laughter, âyes, yes. Youâre a good drummer. Best Iâve heard, but donât let it go to your head,â you complimented with sincerity.
Gareth turned away with a bashful smile playing at his lips. âNo promises,â he murmured, âI wasnât uh, I wasnât sure if you were gonna show,â he continued, drumming his fingers against the bartop.
âOuch,â you deadpanned, holding your chest, âso little confidence, Emerson.â
âOh, itâs Emerson now?â Gareth scoffed, arching a brow. âAnd I was just about to offer you a ride home.â
"Oh no, whatever shall I do?" You dramatically asked, "thank god Eddie is my actual ride."
"Is that a no?" Gareth asked impatiently.
"Let me buy you a drink," you offered instead of answering. "You really were amazing tonight."
"I gotta drive," Gareth pointed out.
"You won't get drunk off one drink, will you?" You asked, before shrugging. "If you wantâŚ.you could come over. Have a drink orâor something. I dunno," you said, sounding way less confident than you would have preferred.
Gareth was silent, deliberating the idea as his eyes scanned the bar, eventually he nodded. "Okay," he agreed, "are you providing dinner as well or are you just trying to get me drunk?" He asked with a teasing smirk.
"Depends if you get us there in one piece," you replied, tucking your hands into your pockets and following him as he walked outside.
"All this slander on my driving from the person who can't drive," Gareth deadpanned, giving you an amused look. "Would you like to drive?"
"I would, actually," you answered, much to his surprise. "I can drive, y'know. I just don't have a car. Or a license," you shrugged, Eddie let you drive his van once or twice. In addition to stealing your parents cars, that's how you learned.
Gareth tossed his keys at you without saying anything and you barely caught them before they smacked into your face. You had half a mind to chuck them at his face.
You decided against it though, and followed him out to his car. You climbed into the driver's seat with a grin. "If I crash, it's not my fault," you stated, sticking the keys in the ignition.
"What happened to knowing how to drive?" Gareth asked, clicking his seatbelt on with a skeptical look.
"I never said I did it well," you cheekily answered as you pulled out of the parking lot and drove away.
You took a detour and got some food for the two of you (which Gareth was very happy about) before driving home.
You were proud to say you got both of you there in one piece. You didn't run any red lights or stop signs either, which you were very proud of.
Gareth didn't think it was so amusing.
"How is it an accomplishment, Y/N? That's the law," he pointed out, holding the food as he climbed out of his car.
You held the six pack you bought with your trusty fake ID, since you technically had promised him a drink. You tossed his keys over the hood of his car, "this is coming from someone who said, and I quote, speed limits are just suggestions," you snarked.
"Yeah, but I don't make a habit of running red lights," he sniped, catching the keys and pushing them into his pocket.
You pulled your own keys out as you walked up to your front door, correcting over your shoulder, "I don't make a habit of it, it's only happened once or twice. But in my defense, the light turned red right when I got to the intersection so I couldn't stop." You slid your keys in the lock and opened it, stepping to the side to let him in first.
"My parents are out of town, so don't worry," you said when you noticed his hesitation, stepping inside behind him and shutting the door.
"Starting to think you have ulterior motives," he called from where he set the food down on the coffee table. He sat himself down on the floor back against the couch.
"It's nothing like that," you promised. You took two beers out of the black and put the rest in the sink. You joined him on the ground, handing off a beer.
"You sure it's nothing like that?" He asked, eyes searching your face.
You nodded and turned away from his gaze before you could blush or say something stupid. You got up quickly to look for a movie to put on.
And with a smirk, you put Bambi on.
"Seriously?" Gareth deadpanned, staring at the screen as the opening played. "You're so funny, bunny."
"I try," you said with a mocking bow. You straightened up and joined him on the floor once again and began to eat.
Just like at the drive-in, he made snarky, sarcastics comments under his breath and kept a running commentary going. And just like at the drive-in, you didn't mind one bit. You discovered you loved hearing his voice.
"Thumper is so cute," you said with feeling, staring at the screen with a smile. The little bunny just melted your heart, he was adorable. You watched as he tried to get Bambi on the ice.
"Eddie can be Bambi," Gareth said thoughtfully. "He's as clueless as him. Besides Bambi looks almost high in some scenesâ"
"Don't say that!" You chided with a laugh, "he doesn't not. He's a baby deer. He's supposed to be clueless. And Eddie isn't as spacey as a baby deer."
"Oh please, I've known him for years," Garqeth dismissed. He pointed at the screen where Bambi was struggling on the ice. "That's exactly what he gets like on skates. Haven't managed to convince him to ice skate though," he said with a dejected sigh.
"I'll skate with you," you volunteered, just to watch him light up. You smiled at how happy it seemed to make him. God he was just precious. Just like Thumper.
Gareth didn't say anything as his eyes returned to the TV screen, but he did settle back into the couch. His arms crossed and he looked pleased.
You took a drink from your half empty bottle. But just as you tipped it back, swallowing a mouthful of the bitter liquid, Gareth decided to speak.
"I like you. A lot. Romantically," he said, turning to look at you.
You choked, immediately setting the glass down on the table, coughing harshly, trying to dispel the liquid you accidentally inhaled. "Jesus Christ," you croaked between coughs.
Gareth reached over to pat and rub your back. "Interesting reaction," he said, his shoulders shaking with ill-concealed amusement.
"Shut up," you scowled, wiping your mouth with the back of your hand. "You're an ass, Gareth Emerson. I could have died!"
"And that would've been a shame," Gareth said mournfully. "So?" He asked.
"I'm starting to rethink my feelings about you," you said sourly, rubbing your chest.
Gareth shoved you.
"WhaâGareth! Not helping your case right now," you exclaimed, sitting up from where you dramatically fell over. "You have a crush on me?"
Gareth nodded.
You grinned. "Okay, well, good. Because I have a massive crush on you too," you said happily. "Probably from when I first saw you. Y'know, I think the hair is what sold me. And then your personality. Is that shalloâ"
Gareth leaned over to claim your lips with his. You eagerly pressed forward, kissing him back without hesitation.
You groaned into the kiss as he licked into your mouth, lips parting with no resistance. You reached out to touch him, your hand buried in his hair, tugging gently.
Gareth pulled away soon after that, a lazy smile on his face, his cheeks red. "My new favorite hobby might be kissing you now," he breathlessly confessed.
"Yeah," you agreed, feeling drunk off his kiss alone. "Yeahâwe should, uh, we should definitely do that again."
Gareth grinned, "take me out to dinner first."
You gestured to the food between the two of you, "excuse me, what would you call this? Technically, if anything, this is our second date," you pointed out.
Gareth seemed to have no wiseass comment for that and he instead kissed you again.
---
Like all good things, the night eventually came to an end. Gareth drove home (you two decided it was fine since he only had a beer) and that was the end of the night.
You went to bed dreaming about him, because that's how hard you'd fallen for him. And now you had him. You were now dating Gareth Emerson and honestly? You could not have been happier.
The next morning, you were woken up by a blaring horn. You very nearly fell out of bed, half asleep as you got up.
You jumped when the horn honked again and you groaned, muttering swears under your breath at being so rudely awoken.
You got to the door and threw it open, still in your pajamas and glared at the car. You realized it was Gareth's. "What the fuck!?"
"Hey, bunny," he called out of his open window with a delighted cackle. "come on, come on. Let's go," he urged, "we have places to be!"
"Why are you so excited to go to school?" You asked, crossing your arms. "I'm not even dressed!"
"Who said anything about school?" Gareth smirked. "Hurry and get dressed. We have places to be," he repeated, enunciating his words with another obnoxious beep of his horn.
"Fine, fine! Stop honking, my neighbors already hate me!" You exclaimed, whirling around and heading back inside. But before you closed the door, Gareth loudly honked one last time.
You rolled your eyes and went to get dressed. A little embarrassed at being seen in your pajamas, but you got over it quickly.
You headed out of your house dressed for whatever it was Gareth was up to. You got in the car, and were greeted with a sweet kiss. And when he pulled away, he was smiling. "You look good," he said and stepped on the gas.
You lurched forward and scrambled to get your seatbelt on. "Where are we going?" You asked, staring at him expectantly.
"Surprise," he replied. After a few moments, he gave in. "We're going on a date. Double date. I told Eddie, sorry," he said, glancing over at you, tapping the steering wheel again.
"No, don't apologize," you said quickly, "it's fine. But uh, last I checked, Eddie was single. Painfully so," he said.
Gareth began to smile, "well it seems like we're not the only one who got serious last night," he said, "Eddie and Steve are a thing. But it's supposed to be a secret."
"How is it a secret if we're going on a date with them?" You couldn't help but ask.
"It's a secret date," he answered. "Eddie was looking for a new spot to deal after he almost got busted, and found a good place for a picnic," he explained.
You wondered just how long the two of them spent on the phone last night. It was an amusing thought to picture them gossiping over the phone.
"Okay," you said, satisfied with the answers you'd gotten and glad to know he hadn't spontaneously decided to murder you with an axe out in the woods.
The drive was mostly quiet, with metal music playing through the speakers.
Eddie and Steve were already there when the two of you arrived. You had to take a little hike through the woods to get to them though, which didn't really help your axe murderer theory.
But you eventually found Eddie and Steve in a small clearing. They were sitting on opposite tree stumps, a large one between them. That's where they had the food set up.
"You're late," Steve called when he laid eyes on you both.
You smirked when you seen him and sent a knowing look between him and Eddie. "What'd I say?" You asked.
"Y/N wasn't even awake when I went to get them," Gareth threw you under the bus, sitting right on the ground and reaching for the food.
"Traitor," you muttered, sitting opposite of him on the ground, internally grimacing about having to get the dirt out of your clothes later. "He was being obnoxious and kept honking!"
"I told you to stay away from him," Eddie said around a mouthful of food. "But does anyone listen? No," he said.
"Nothing new," Steve replied.
Eddie glared.
You reached for your own food with a smile. You could get used to this. This was so much better than being stuck in class all day.
And hey, you even got a very pretty looking rock from Gareth at the end of the date. He had disappeared for about half an hour and returned soaking wet, but with two rocks in his pockets that he waded through a creek for.
He gave you one, and kept the other.
You never got rid of the rock. It stayed with you always, even when others joined your collection. That first rock held so much more significance to you.
Even years later, that rock remained your most prized possession.