Changing The Plan (Chapter 4)

Changing the plan (Chapter 4)

(Fourth chapter of this longer form story. It pick up a few weeks after the events of the anniversary party. I wrote this chapter as a commission from a fan. If you’re interested in commissioning more or similar stories you can message me here, or my email TheBigBully1@outlook.com Enjoy.)

During the few weeks after James and Jessica’s anniversary party the couple decided to put the breaks on anything outside of the relationship. While the two of them admitted to each other that the entire experience was arousing, James was very concerned about Brad being the other man. Jessica told him that she understood and would hold off on any more fooling around behind his back until he was sure he was ready for it.

James checked his phone before driving home to his apartment. He had been lucky and was able to get out a bit early from his part time job thanks to his friend Kevin offering to cover for him. He had several messages from Jessica asking him how his day was going, asking him when he thought he was getting out, and asking when he thought he would get home. James felt like the two of them had been seeing less and less of each other since the party, so he agreed to let Jessica spend the day at his place to relax while he was stuck working.

The low battery warning chimed on his phone, showing James that there was only 5% remaining on his charge. He spent the next few minutes searching his car for the charger, but couldn’t remember if he had brought it inside or not. James decided to send a quick text to let Jess know he was heading home when he received a message from his little sister Alice. At that same moment however, James watched the screen switch to a logo as the powering down noise rang out and his phone turned off in his hands.

James shook his head and climbed into his car, getting it to start after a few attempts and began to drive home. He smiled as he thought about how much Jessica and him were able to click back together after it seemed their relationship had a dimmer few weeks. It did seem to him that Jessica was busy more than usual since their anniversary, but now it seemed like she was constantly asking him where he was and how long it was going to be before he arrived. It seemed to James that she really missed him even in the little bits of time they were apart.

With the weekend arriving however, James had someone else to divert his attention. That, of course, was his little sister Alice. She had been asking to come visit James for a long time and he had finally relented into agreeing. It wasn’t that they didn’t get along, but more that Alice was such a young and innocent girl in his mind that he really thought of himself as her protector. In James’ mind, Alice really was still that little girl she had been when they were growing up.

Pulling up to the apartment James quickly found a spot and walked back towards his front door a bit quicker than usual, excited to see Jessica. As he reached the pathway leading up to his front door however, James saw something that stopped him in his tracks. A pickup truck that looked so comically big that James would have instantly assumed the owner was compensating for something if he didn’t already know the owner. It was Brad’s pickup parked right in front of James’ apartment.

James took a deep breath. He thought that maybe Brad was visiting Tyler. They were friends after all, it wouldn’t be weird for Tyler to have Brad over for time to time surely. James tried not to think too hard and simply walked to the front door. He fumbled with his keys at the doorstep and ended up dropping them once before getting the correct one and putting it in the lock. He opened the door and stepped inside.

When James reached the kitchen he saw his girlfriend Jessica sitting at the small table with a drink in hand and wearing almost nothing. Nothing except an oversized T-shirt and one of the smallest little thongs he had seen her in. The T-shirt wasn’t really even long enough to cover her ass as it stuck out and attracted James’ full attention. His eyes lit up and a smile crept over his face as James ogled his girlfriend before she noticed him.

“Whoa!” Jessica shouted in surprise, putting one hand over her chest. “Oh my god babe you scared me. I…I had no idea you would be home so soon. I thought you were working later tonight.”

James just shrugged his shoulders as he opened the fridge to get himself a drink. “Yeah I was going to, but Kevin covered for me. I figured we would get to spend some more time together before Alice gets here. My phone died so I couldn’t let you know, my bad. Oh, Alice, I forgot, she sent me a message.”

James lifted his phone up to show Jessica, then quickly walked down the hall to find a charger. As he passed by Tyler’s bedroom door he saw it was closed and could hear the shower running. Just then he remembered Brad’s truck and breathed a sigh of relief, knowing that the two of them must be in Tyler’s room. Probably back from having gone to play basketball together or something. James entered his bedroom and plugged his phone into the charger by the nightstand.

Then he took a look around the room and shook his head. He knew Jessica wasn’t a clean freak or anything, but she really made a mess of his bedroom. He remembered seeing her get out of bed in the morning, but now the sheets were all pushed to the side, half hanging off the bed and the pillows tossed onto the floor. The clothes she had been wearing when he kissed her goodbye earlier were in a little a pile right at the foot of the bed as well. James did a bit of cleaning up before finding his bottle of lube hidden slightly under her clothes. He could only shake his head, happy that he would get to tease Jess about what she may have been up to while he was gone.

Back in the kitchen James sat with Jessica and talked about his day at work. He noticed her constantly looking over his shoulder and back down the hallway every so often, then she seemed to be doing it even more once the shower noises stopped. Just before James opened his mouth to ask his girlfriend why she was acting so seemingly paranoid Tyler’s door opened and shut and footsteps sounded down the hallway towards the kitchen.

James saw the look on Jessica’s face before he saw who it was. That panic in her eyes, the way she sat up straighter suddenly, as well as the way her breathing seemed to pause for a moment. There was also something else that James saw though. He watched his girlfriend bite her bottom lip, a look that always melted James’ heart and excited his entire body. James turned to look over his shoulder and instantly felt the anger rise up inside of him as he laid his eyes on Brad.

The meat headed giant walked into the kitchen laughing to himself as he approached the table where James and Jessica sat. James took care to bite his tongue to stop from calling Brad a flurry of names and insults. It was all he could do to stop himself from charging down to Tyler’s room and dragging him out to have him kick his friend from the apartment. The anger in James’ mind flowed together with all the things Jessica had told him that one night. Line after line about her submission to Brad.

“He made me beg him.”

“He made me beg him to let me suck his cock.”

“…while I licked his big round balls.”

“I begged for more and told him how much bigger he is than you.”

It was too much for James to take. He didn’t know how to stop the thoughts and emotions flowing through him when he was inexplicably saved. Saved by the sound of the doorbell. The doorbell rang out, then rang out again, then a soft knocking came not a second later. James pushed himself up as quickly as he could without knocking the table over and left Jessica and Brad behind him.

The sight of Alice standing at his front step was a shock to James. Both that she was several hours early and her appearance. It hadn’t really been that long since James had seen his little sister, but it seemed each time they spent time apart his memory went back to her being that little girl from their childhood.

Wordlessly James opened the door to let Alice in, watching her give him a questioning look as she stepped inside. She didn’t look like the little girl from his memory, but there was something still young and innocent about her. The soft pink skirt she wore, the pristine white shoes, Alice’s white top with hearts on it, and especially the way her soft blonde hair was put into pigtails.

All of that contrasted with the other things James noticed about his little sister. How incredibly short her skirt was, barely reaching the tops of her pale thighs, how tight her little shirt was and how it left her stomach exposed, the layers of makeup on her face he didn’t know the names of, and the way her lips shone with a glossy pink finish.

“Alice. What are you doing here? I wasn’t expecting you to get here for another couple of hours.” James asked confused.

“Well hello to you too big brother. Why didn’t you answer any of my texts? I sent you like 100 messages!” Alice rolled her eyes as she turned her phone towards James.

James wiped the look of confusion from his face and paced quickly down the hall, grabbed his phone, and returned as he scrolled through his text messages. The first few from Jessica, asking when he was coming home, asking him to make sure to let her know when he’s leaving work. Then a ton of unread messages from Alice. Messages detailing that her ride over had to be earlier, that she was on her way, that she was almost at his apartment and why wasn’t he responding.

James was quick to apologize, noting that his phone died and he hadn’t had a chance to even look at any messages or the several missed calls, since he got out of work. The siblings put the matter behind them as James smiled at his little sister and offered to show her around. While the place wasn’t as clean as he wanted to make it for Alice, James couldn’t help it since she had already arrived, so he started the tour.

When they entered the kitchen together James saw Jessica still dressed in just a T-shirt and thong. As well as the bully Brad having taken James’ seat and dragged right up next to Jessica. The sight made James’ heart leap into his throat, but he did his best to hide and anger and surprise he felt. 

“…then wait until he’s asleep-.” Brad was saying quietly to Jessica.

Looking up and noticing the two of them enter the room, Jess jumped up and ran over to hug Alice. The two girls didn’t seem to get along when James first introduced Jessica to his family, but over time they quickly became friends and had their own series of inside jokes he didn’t really understand.

Next, Brad stood up and in James’ mind, had a horribly nauseating look on his face as he looked Alice up and down. James thought about telling him to ‘fuck off’, but decided to try and keep things civil in front of his little sister. Besides, Brad knew a secret that James never wanted Alice to hear about.

“Well, well, well, who is this?” Brad asked, as he towered over Alice and she almost had to tilt her head back to look all the way up at Brad. “How boutcha turn around. Damn that ass looks fat even from the front.”

James stepped halfway between Alice and Brad. “THIS!” He said loudly, “Is Alice, my little sister. So back off.”

Brad just chuckled in that cocky way he always seemed to as he ignored any intimidation. “Well damn shrimpy, your little sister Alice looks like she’s got a dump truck on her.” 

Then he gave one more loud laugh and took a step back, still eyeing Alice up and down.

James turned to see his sister’s face growing bright red, barely able to even make eye contact with anything except the floor. Her hands fiddled with the bottom of her skirt as her hips gently wiggled from side to side with embarrassment.

After introductions James was happy to see that Brad went back to Tyler’s room and seemed to keep quiet and out of his life for the next several hours. Jessica hung around and gossiped with Alice about everything from fashion, to the boys at her school, to college life and beyond. Jess even mentioned a few times that she thought Alice should really try out something special with her, showing her pictures on her phone that Alice found very shocking. It seemed to James it was only ever brought up just as he was leaving the room, so he never heard what this special thing was.

By the time night rolled around and sleeping arrangements had to be made, James agreed to Jessica’s suggestion that he stay on the sofa out in the main living area while Jessica and Alice took his bed.

The day had been exhausting for James and he fell asleep almost right after his head hit the pillow. He didn’t sleep great though, awakening several times throughout the night. The first to several doors opening and closing and footsteps down the hallway. James didn’t have the mental energy to wonder what the ruckus was about so he closed his eyes right away and drifted off.

The second time James woke up it was a very different sound. The noise confirmed to him that Brad had gone home and Tyler must have brought a girl home. He wondered if it was Hannah, feeling like he hadn’t seen a ton of her since the anniversary party either, despite Tyler’s strong feelings for her. Although, the scene in Brad’s pickup made James guess that perhaps the two weren’t perfect for each other.

The sounds echoed down the hallway a bit and he wished that he had warned Tyler that Alice was staying over. He just hoped she didn’t wake up and have to listen to the sounds of moaning and bed springs bouncing through the night. It took James quite a bit more time to fall asleep again, hearing the sounds get more and more intense. It even sounded like some loud slapping joined in and a really high pitched moan. James couldn’t help himself, being so unable to sleep he slid a hand down his own pants and tugged a quick one out to the incredibly lewd and long lasting noises, as he told himself it was just to help him sleep.

The third time James woke up, the sound wasn’t subtle. He thought an intruder had just broken in from the front door slamming open and then closed. Loud footsteps, laughing, and someone falling over caused James to jump up from the couch. He reached over to turn on the light and saw Tyler pushing himself up to his hands and knees, before standing once more. Tyler had the goofiest smile on his face as he struggled to get his shoes off and put his keys away.

“J-Jamesy my friend…” he stuttered out looking a bit dizzy and a bit sick. James realized that Tyler was drunk, definitely too drunk to enter their apartment quietly, and maybe too drunk to even get back to his room. He just shook his head and despite offering help, Tyler declined and boasted that he was fine and just needed some sleep before stumbling and bumping his way down the hall to his own bedroom before slamming the door all too loud.

James laughed at his friend and roommate. He wondered how he had gone from such incredibly long lasting and loud sex sounds to stumbling through the front door to…the noises began again. In fact, the sound of bedsprings may have just been happening the entire time Tyler was crashing into their apartment, but James realized he was too distracted to hear them from all the way down the hall. All the way down, to the very last door, his bedroom.

James felt his own heart race, he felt that awful twist in his stomach, but he had to confirm it. He stepped down the hall, hearing the noises getting louder and louder. Eventually, just a few paces from his own bedroom door, he could hear muffled voices. Then, once he got all the way to the door, he could just about make out what they were saying.

“Just, so, big! C’mon, it’s so good.”

“I…I don’t know. I’ve never…you know. Plus that looks big, like, really really big.”

“I know you’re a little scared, but he’s seriously amazing. Trust me, the size just makes it so much better.”

“What about…”

 James slipped a bit backwards as he realized the voices belonged to his girlfriend and his little sister. He could barely bring himself to listen to anymore.

”…doesn’t have to find out about anything. He’s dead asleep. Besides he has no idea we’ve been together every day for weeks.”

“Are you sure? You guys were getting pretty loud and-”

“I’m sure! Seriously, James is great, but he’s really oblivious. I mean Brad fucked me all day on this bed and he was clueless when he got home!”

“O-Okay…you’ll help me though? Show me what to do?”

“Of course sweetie! Now come on, get on your knees right here. You’re going to need both hands.”

Suddenly a much deeper voice joined the girls, “Stop. First, show me that fat ass girl. Fuck, I knew you had a dump truck. Now on your knees bitch.”

“Hey, I’m not a bitch!”

“Whatever, crawl closer. Yeah, see, you already got handlebars for me bitch…”

James stumbled back down the hallway to the couch. His mind and heart were racing so fast he thought he was going to pass out. He sat on the couch and put his head in his hands, unsure if he was going to puke, or if the tent in his pants was going to explode. Instead, he leaned back and eventually he did pass out. 

As he opened his eyes to the sunlight James could smell breakfast in the kitchen. He stumbled in to find Jessica standing in front of the stove and Alice and Tyler sitting at the table. Tyler had a coffee in front of him and his head on the table, looking like he was somewhere between horribly drunk and horribly hungover. Alice on the other hand looked a bit tired, but was smiling.

The three of them talked like it was a totally norming morning after Tyler excused himself to spend the morning in bed, leaving his coffee for someone with even the slightest appetite. James couldn’t bring himself to say anything, despite running it through his head again and again.

Meanwhile, all through the meal Jessica kept looking at her phone and giggling before tapping  it a few times and rejoining the conversation. She even turned the phone to show Alice once or twice who simply blushed at whatever was on the screen.

After breakfast James complained about being tired and Jessica quickly offered to take Alice shopping so he could take a nap. Alice was about to object when Jessica whispered something to her that was inaudible to James.

“Really? Again?” Alice said surprised.

Jessica nodded with a smirk on her face that James hadn’t seen in quite some time. He felt too tired to complain though and went to fix his bed up for a nap. During the process of returning the covers to the bed he saw Alice’s heart covered top from the day before at the foot of the bed. 

Upon moving it, James discovered the same bottle of lube he had found the day before underneath it. When James picked up the bottle of lube, he was even more surprised to discover just how much lighter it felt. In fact, it was almost completely empty.

He decided to just put it to the back of his mind, having much more important things to talk about with Jessica first. He made his way to the kitchen finding it empty. Then noticed both Jessica and Alice already at the front door, ready to take off.

“…really doesn’t like it when I’m late. Oh, hi babe. Alice and I are going to leave now actually. You go take a nap, we won’t be gone all day I’m sure.”

James raised an eyebrow, feeling a bit of the knot in his stomach, but the anxious feelings made it difficult for him to form a question that asked what he really wanted to know.

“So, where are you guys going to go today?” James asked.

“We’re going to go see Br-ahhh!” Alice began, stopping midsentence as Jessica stepped onto her foot.

“Oops.” Jessica said unconvincingly.

Alice shot her an angry glance but then her eyebrows raised as though she just realized something important. 

“Bras! We’re going to see bras. Just girly shopping.” Alice finished with a satisfied smile. 

“Bye bye big bro.” Alice said before taking off out the front door with Jessica behind her, as she turned to blow a kiss to James who watched the two girls exit and close the door leaving him alone.