It Wouldn’t Be Historically Accurate For My Story To Include BIPOC!

It wouldn’t be historically accurate for my story to include BIPOC!

This is an argument often made about European-style fantasy media like Game of Thrones, Lord of the Rings, and Disney’s Frozen. Audiences, often white, assume that due to the majority-white setting, adding any visible number of BIPOC to the story would be unrealistic.

What these critics fail to realize is that BIPOC do in fact live, and have lived, in these settings, and records of BIPOC presence in places assumed to be majority-white have been buried, written out, or not taught due to white supremacist and/or colonial bias in the field of history. There are historical European settings that were far more diverse than is often portrayed. Consider:

The Moorish Empire exerted an extensive influence over life and culture in Southern Europe from Spain from 711 to 1492

The Ottomans were heavily involved in European affairs up until the treaty of Karlowitz in 1699, but still considered a part of Europe even through the 19th century

The sheer size of the Roman Empire ensured the continued movement of people from various backgrounds within the Mediterranean well until the end of the Byzantine Empire.

“Historical accuracy” should not be used as an excuse for media to be exclusively white in its casting. While there are places which are or were predominantly white, there will always be factors like global trade and immigration that bring multiculturalism to their doors.

And even if the presence of a certain demographic is unrealistic for a certain setting? Consider that we’ve accepted far worse inaccuracies in historical fiction in the name of artistic license. Consider that our understanding of human history is, and will always be, incomplete.

Further Reading:

Historically Diverse London, “Historical Accuracy,” and Creator Accountability

Making a Black Pride and Prejudice Resonate

---

This Q&A is an excerpt from our General FAQ for Newcomers, which can be found in our new Masterpost of rules and FAQs. If you're new to Writing With Color and/or want more writing resources, check it out!

-Writing With Color

More Posts from Echo-oaks and Others

1 year ago

Arcade’s only sin is the sin of being born and I don’t think anyone can get it right when they write him.

Can you imagine the hatred? The disgust? Do you think that when he passes by mirrors and catches his own reflection he thinks “Innocent people died so I could be born” or “I am named after an idea of paradise that would cause the slaughter of thousands”? Does he feel guilt, this man who had to privilege of not having to go hungry, of being able to grow and tower over regular wastelanders? Does he consider the fact he was born of years of love and hate? That he was bred to be a fervent nationalist? Does he miss Navarro and then realize with disgust that had it not been destroyed he would’ve become the very thing he fights tooth and nail against?

And he simplifies it. He dumbs it down in his head and tries to save himself the sheer horror that the people he misses so dearly, his father, his mother, would’ve probably wanted him to mercilessly kill the very people he treats. He says to the courier “They did bad things. Kidnapped people, terrorized settlements.” But is that really it? No. But the thought that his parents named him, this tall man who used to be a child (that, had fate not changed, would’ve grown to be a soldier or a scientist hellbent on “purifying the wasteland”), after a paradise that would’ve brought about the destruction of thousands of good people must be a bone-chilling notion.

People don’t write him with the guilt of knowing what he was born to do. And they don’t write him with the pride of knowing that he defied it and works to better the wasteland all around him, to fix his nation’s mistakes.


Tags
1 year ago
My Boy😍 I Adore Him🫶🏻🫶🏻

My boy😍 I adore him🫶🏻🫶🏻


Tags
1 year ago
Why Doesn't Souda Say Anything?
Why Doesn't Souda Say Anything?
Why Doesn't Souda Say Anything?
Why Doesn't Souda Say Anything?

Why doesn't Souda say anything?

bc it's funny.


Tags
1 year ago

i know people give Leon a lot of flak for his murder bc he claims it was in "self-defense," but let's be real with ourselves. What the fuck else was he supposed to do? If he just left, what, he has to go next day and be like yeah we both tried to kill each other and i broke her wrist. Can you pass the salt? Also Sayaka 100% would've turned everyone against him bc like she's Sayaka. So yeah I kind of have more sympathy towards this guy. Like Sayaka was going to straight up murder him. For literally zero reason. Like, I kind of get why she wanted to murder someone but it is never explained what made her choose Leon specifically.


Tags
1 year ago

PIPER JUST POSTED THIS ON HER INSTA AND GUYS😭😭😭😭


Tags
1 year ago

https://gofund.me/8416e129

This is definitelyyy something I feel vulnerable by sharing because I feel really guilty for asking for help like this, but - this is extremely life-changing news for me, let alone *what it is*, which is my top surgery.

I wrote a very sappy very candid explanation in the link itself, where donations are open too.

If you donated a lot of money, that'd change my life. If you donated a penny, it'd change my life. if you reblogged this post, it'd change my life. you don't know how much it would mean to me if you helped me. so thank u<33


Tags
1 year ago

Friendly reminder that Scribe Haylen risks her life to save Danse.

She risks it by warning him. Telling him what the Brotherhood found out before anyone had a chance to come after him.

She risks it by storming into Quinlan’s office, accusing sole of turning their back on Danse and not giving a damn that she’s speaking to officers that outrank her.

She risks it by lying to sole, a ranking member of the Brotherhood, telling them she has information on her vertibird only to lead them into the bowels of the Prydwen to plead for Danse’s life.

She risks it if Danse is saved by returning to check up on him and bring him supplies. He who is a known synth, an accused traitor and is supposed to be dead.

And why does she do it? Because she’s in love with him? No, it’s clear that her feelings for Danse come from respect, admiration and friendship. Because it benefits her in some way? No, her actions, if ever found out could only hurt her. She does it because he’s a good man, because he deserves a chance, because it’s the right thing to do.

And that is one of the most badass things in this entire game imo.


Tags
1 year ago
Reup Of A Commission I Did Based On The Painting Stańczyk By Jan Matejko

reup of a commission i did based on the painting stańczyk by jan matejko


Tags
1 year ago

Thinking about how spawn Astarion seems into cradling his SO's cheek/head (in the graveyard scene, and in the new patch 6 kiss).

Maybe this is an affectionate instinct borne out of this being the first person he really cares for and he just wants to hold them like that, like they're something precious, something he wants so close. The same way someone's hand might twitch to hold their lover's, Astarion feels this itch in his fingertips to let their cheek rest in his palm, so, so gently.

And he hasn't really had that itch like that before. A performative instinct, sure, he could pull those sorts of moves in his sleep, he knows them so well. But this is different. This is what he wants. And this is one of the first real affectionate moves he tends to initiate as he eases into being able to explore that freely.

When he pulls away in the new patch 6 kiss, his hand lingers in front of him, like it's still holding onto something, still holding onto that touch/warmth like he doesn't really want to let it go, but he also seems sort of struck/tickled by the not-wanting-to-let-go of it all. How novel. How sweet.

But also, maybe it's a grounding thing for him, as well, to keep himself tethered to that sweet moment with the one he loves, and not awash in so many memories he'd rather forget.

Idk I love how much effort and thought went into all these interactions and how much it speaks to the characters 🥰😭🥹


Tags
Loading...
End of content
No more pages to load
  • hyrulecastles
    hyrulecastles liked this · 3 weeks ago
  • mo0nch1
    mo0nch1 liked this · 1 month ago
  • cityoftheangelllls
    cityoftheangelllls liked this · 1 month ago
  • el-aleph
    el-aleph liked this · 1 month ago
  • lacebows
    lacebows liked this · 1 month ago
  • intheskiesabove
    intheskiesabove liked this · 1 month ago
  • coldgreywater
    coldgreywater liked this · 2 months ago
  • sojiane
    sojiane liked this · 3 months ago
  • spinogreen0iq
    spinogreen0iq liked this · 3 months ago
  • shadow-king-club
    shadow-king-club liked this · 3 months ago
  • neptunefall
    neptunefall liked this · 3 months ago
  • sadieb798
    sadieb798 liked this · 3 months ago
  • loardymacbee
    loardymacbee reblogged this · 3 months ago
  • loardymacbee
    loardymacbee liked this · 3 months ago
  • fire-dawn
    fire-dawn reblogged this · 3 months ago
  • kane-log-and-findings
    kane-log-and-findings reblogged this · 3 months ago
  • stinkycheeso
    stinkycheeso liked this · 4 months ago
  • i-must-have-flowers
    i-must-have-flowers liked this · 4 months ago
  • gwenhwyfar-oftheundead
    gwenhwyfar-oftheundead liked this · 4 months ago
  • annabwriting
    annabwriting reblogged this · 4 months ago
  • minecraftcreepercat
    minecraftcreepercat liked this · 5 months ago
  • dustmotedance
    dustmotedance liked this · 5 months ago
  • lilcrawe
    lilcrawe reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • galestral
    galestral liked this · 5 months ago
  • yay-animals14
    yay-animals14 liked this · 5 months ago
  • chaotic-inkme
    chaotic-inkme reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • chaotic-inkme
    chaotic-inkme liked this · 5 months ago
  • macbow333
    macbow333 liked this · 5 months ago
  • cloudbatcave
    cloudbatcave reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • zcreatescreations-reblogs
    zcreatescreations-reblogs reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • parakeetlover3
    parakeetlover3 reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • parakeetlover3
    parakeetlover3 liked this · 5 months ago
  • soepwashere
    soepwashere liked this · 5 months ago
  • fluffle-system
    fluffle-system liked this · 5 months ago
  • bordonfreeman
    bordonfreeman reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • justmenoworries
    justmenoworries reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • rainbowut
    rainbowut reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • thatwolf-goatthing
    thatwolf-goatthing reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • thatwolf-goatthing
    thatwolf-goatthing liked this · 5 months ago
  • stainedglassthreads
    stainedglassthreads liked this · 5 months ago
  • lightmooncream
    lightmooncream liked this · 5 months ago
  • savedstuffformelater
    savedstuffformelater reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • violetthunderstorm
    violetthunderstorm reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • violetthunderstorm
    violetthunderstorm liked this · 5 months ago
  • bobanchikn-reblogs
    bobanchikn-reblogs reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • clevercatchphrase
    clevercatchphrase reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • madnessandentropy
    madnessandentropy reblogged this · 6 months ago
echo-oaks - Writing Everything
Writing Everything

i will write everything. original work, fan fictions, fan art, advice, whatever. | 22 | Sky/Oak/Echo | he/they | 18+ Only author of And It Starts Again

458 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags