There Is A Difference Between Slytherin In Canon And Identifying As A Slytherin In Real Life!!! Slytherin

there is a difference between slytherin in canon and identifying as a slytherin in real life!!! slytherin house, in canon, is built on bigoted ideals and upholds bigoted standards and while there are non bigoted slytherins, you can’t pretend that the house is unfairly hated by many because it literally was built on the idea of blood supremacy…. like salazar slytherin was literally like “yeah i only want to teach those with pure-blood” and there’s no way that didn’t lead to systemic bigotry in the house….. obviously in real life slytherins feel that they are slytherin because they think they’re cunning or ambitious or they like the color green i don’t care but criticizing slytherin in canon has nothing to do with people who call themselves slytherins in real life

More Posts from Etoyra and Others

6 years ago
Progress

Progress

6 years ago

my least favorite aspect of the “slytherins are oppressed uwu” thing that keeps happening is when people try to say that J.K. Rowling has “anti-slytherin bias” because she shows the school-age slytherins as all being snobbish and 100% deserving of the reputation they have

like you guys know hogwarts is not a real place, right? there isn’t actually any such thing as slytherin. 

Jo Rowling is not a journalist who failed to report the story objectively because she has a personal vendetta against slytherin house borne of pervasive anti-slytherin prejudices in our society

She’s an author who made up slytherin and decided that the majority of them would be exactly as big of dicks as everyone thinks they are. Rowling literally can’t be anything but objective with regards to Harry Potter canon. She’s literally omniscient in the world she created, and if she wrote Slytherin house as being just full of dicks, even the 11-year-olds who are sorted into it (of their own free will, you can’t be officially sorted into a house you don’t want to be in, the first year slytherins wanted to be in slytherin and most of them, even muggleborns, know how much importance slytherin places on elitist snobbery in possible students)

If you think racist, classist, status-obsessed, snobbish slytherins are the exception rather than the rule, the problem isn’t that J.K. has an anti-slytherin bias, it’s that you have a pro-slytherin bias, and a bias in favor of the house that caters to both the privileged and supremacists by design is not a bias you should be proud of having

However, the thesis statement here is this is fake. You’re literally saying that a woman who pretended a whole planet of wizards for your entertainment is somehow wrong about how the world she made up operates. It’s like when the Supernatural writers said they spell Castiel’s nickname “Cass” and the fans said the writers were wrong. I agree that’s a dumb way to spell a shorter version of “Castiel.” Supernatural is a dumb show. However, if you find yourself saying that you, a fan, are more of an authority on canon than the literal writers who make up the canon for your consumption, you have overstepped your bounds as a member of the audience. 

Have headcanons about nice, non-racist slytherins if you insist. Say the books would have been better if Harry’s slytherin classmates had been more three-dimensional, or if the series had explored the idea of students going to slytherin because they expected it to be the “ambitious” house and being mortified to find out they’re actually stuck in the racist house. 

Please, though, put the “Rowling’s anti-slytherin bias” card back in the deck and leave it there forever, it doesn’t make sense and it shows me you think “the person who wrote the story told the series of events they made up inaccurately” makes more sense than “like the omniscient narrator and many of the characters said, there’s a problem is slytherin house.”

tl;dr: harry potter is a good book but it’s made up so why are you trying to spare the feelings of pretend racists

4 years ago

"real rednecks aren't racist! real punks can't be bigots! real (insert x social group) can't-"

"real Rednecks Aren't Racist! Real Punks Can't Be Bigots! Real (insert X Social Group) Can't-"
"real Rednecks Aren't Racist! Real Punks Can't Be Bigots! Real (insert X Social Group) Can't-"
4 years ago

GIVE TO THE BLACK BANJO RECLAMATION PROJECT

4 years ago

i haven’t seen any posts about this going around on tumblr yet, and i know theres a lot going on around the world but this is an issue that needs (and has always needed) more coverage tbqh.

Kylie Jenner has recently been under fire for her clothing line in collaboration with Kendall Jenner, Kendall + Kylie, refusing to pay Bangladeshi apparel workers making their products. the company is owned by Global Brands Group, which has decided not to pay the workers due to the lack of sales during the pandemic. people started speaking up about the payment issue on Kylie’s instagram, but instead of a proper response comments were being deleted and eventually limited.

however, the issue doesn’t begin and end with Kendall + Kylie, the treatment of factory workers in Bangladesh is a problem with a long overdue response. most of these people are women working in gruelling conditions, being paid in dust and recieving little to no benefits. their lives are seen as disposable. during the quarantine, factories continued production but laid off a quarter of the workforce while the rest still face the threat of wage cuts and lack of access to healthcare.

all the fast fashion we consume like Gap, Primark, Forever 21 and C&A comes at the cost of labour exploitation in developing countries like Bangladesh. this is the country where the main source of income is textiles, where the 2013 Rana Plaza incident killed 1,100 factory workers alone, where workers constantly protest for better salaries and safer conditions, and yet they recieve not even an ounce of dignity for their hard labour. change needs to happen, better sooner than later. will reblog with what you can do to help (since tumblr hates posts with links).

6 years ago

im still super fuckin salty that 2 of my instructors for my psych degree specifically mentioned not wearing makeup and feminine clothes as a sign of “deteriorating mental health.” specifically, that if a woman walks into your practice, and you’ve never seen her before, and she’s not wearing makeup or dressing up or shaving, then she’s going to be a “difficult case” and when she starts to do these things it’s a sign that therapy is progressing well.

especially since when i was at Rock Fucking Bottom ™ i was over-performing femininity as a) a way to dissociate from myself, my trauma, and the dysphoria i was experiencing and b) a last-ditch effort to get Approval, Validation, and Attention when i felt like i was unattractive and worthless. don’t let anyone tell you that “psychology used to have a misogyny problem and issues with pathologizing gender nonconformity, but it’s solved now because more women than men are earning psych degrees!!” because the problems are still very much there, they just change forms every couple of decades.

4 years ago
Saw This On Facebook, But I Have Greater Reach Hear

Saw this on Facebook, but I have greater reach hear

4 years ago
Hey, Not To Be The One Wielding The 'studio-led Sequel Culture Strips Out The Message Of The Original

hey, not to be the one wielding the 'studio-led sequel culture strips out the message of the original work' sword, but i feel like there's a parable out there about corporations ignoring scientific advice in the face of endangering the masses for profit, and i just can't remember what it is.

6 years ago
Huevember Day 8: T’Pol Uniform Redesign 

Huevember day 8: T’Pol uniform redesign 

4 years ago
Hannah Gadsy Roasting The Shit Out Of Men In Douglas (2020)
Hannah Gadsy Roasting The Shit Out Of Men In Douglas (2020)
Hannah Gadsy Roasting The Shit Out Of Men In Douglas (2020)
Hannah Gadsy Roasting The Shit Out Of Men In Douglas (2020)
Hannah Gadsy Roasting The Shit Out Of Men In Douglas (2020)
Hannah Gadsy Roasting The Shit Out Of Men In Douglas (2020)
Hannah Gadsy Roasting The Shit Out Of Men In Douglas (2020)
Hannah Gadsy Roasting The Shit Out Of Men In Douglas (2020)
Hannah Gadsy Roasting The Shit Out Of Men In Douglas (2020)
Hannah Gadsy Roasting The Shit Out Of Men In Douglas (2020)

hannah gadsy roasting the shit out of men in douglas (2020)

  • disorderedgem
    disorderedgem liked this · 3 years ago
  • while-the-night-falls
    while-the-night-falls liked this · 3 years ago
  • strangegalaxytraveler
    strangegalaxytraveler liked this · 4 years ago
  • iambapple
    iambapple liked this · 4 years ago
  • blenderbender1811
    blenderbender1811 reblogged this · 4 years ago
  • do-you-wanna-sugarcube
    do-you-wanna-sugarcube liked this · 4 years ago
  • lovclylupin
    lovclylupin reblogged this · 4 years ago
  • sam5701
    sam5701 liked this · 4 years ago
  • footballiskillingme
    footballiskillingme liked this · 4 years ago
  • ifyouknowme-stayaway
    ifyouknowme-stayaway liked this · 5 years ago
  • jespersgf
    jespersgf reblogged this · 5 years ago
  • jespersgf
    jespersgf liked this · 5 years ago
  • sarada-is-back
    sarada-is-back liked this · 5 years ago
  • a-lady-in-shining-armour
    a-lady-in-shining-armour liked this · 6 years ago
  • lesbiteez
    lesbiteez liked this · 6 years ago
  • sirikenobi
    sirikenobi liked this · 6 years ago
  • etoyra
    etoyra reblogged this · 6 years ago
  • bisexual-leandro
    bisexual-leandro liked this · 6 years ago
  • oforet
    oforet liked this · 6 years ago
  • etoyra
    etoyra liked this · 6 years ago
  • mage-chocolate
    mage-chocolate liked this · 6 years ago
  • whyhellotheregandalf
    whyhellotheregandalf liked this · 6 years ago
  • truthofthewell
    truthofthewell liked this · 6 years ago
  • intheradianceofthefuture
    intheradianceofthefuture liked this · 7 years ago
  • wizardysseus
    wizardysseus liked this · 7 years ago
  • sneaky-witch-thief
    sneaky-witch-thief liked this · 7 years ago
  • roonilbloodywazlib
    roonilbloodywazlib liked this · 7 years ago
  • corasombrelune
    corasombrelune liked this · 7 years ago
  • savemethewaltz
    savemethewaltz liked this · 7 years ago
  • cat-hair-and-cardigans
    cat-hair-and-cardigans liked this · 7 years ago
  • pj-halfblood
    pj-halfblood liked this · 7 years ago
  • safeandsolid
    safeandsolid reblogged this · 7 years ago
  • shame-bringer-blog
    shame-bringer-blog liked this · 7 years ago
  • jamesfleamont
    jamesfleamont liked this · 7 years ago
  • raywritesthings
    raywritesthings reblogged this · 7 years ago
  • gyugyu0428
    gyugyu0428 liked this · 8 years ago
  • deadstrides
    deadstrides liked this · 8 years ago
etoyra - Hi ??
Hi ??

Side blog for my socially anxious soul. No posts just likes. Edit : I'm a liar

99 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags