I Don't Know About Obsession, But If I May Ask...

I don't know about obsession, but if i may ask...

Do you like Moby Dick because it may be based in a true story or because it's written so well??

It's certainly inspired by the true story of the Essex, which was rammed by a sperm whale. Back in the old days it was considered kind of unseemly to write pure fiction. Novels needed to be a travelogue or a biography or a historical account or a religious morality tale - at least on the surface. Pure fiction was too much like a lie, and could get you a dark reputation.

So yes, most of Melville's books were "based" on real events, either others' accounts or stories from his own colourful youth and later travels. But once you read them, you see the narrative is just an excuse for explorations of social or philosophical themes and ideas. Though his first two books were more straightforward travelogues, he couldn't afterwards write anything straightforward to save his life. His readers at the time felt betrayed by this - they'd liked his funny, scary adventures in the South Seas! - but they didn't understand the rest and stopped buying his books. Melville eventually gave up his writing career, got a day job, and died in obscurity.

I mention all this because Herman Melville the man is a big reason why I like Herman Melville's writing. His life was fascinating, sad, and we know a lot about it. It's brilliant stuff to study. His writing, too, is fascinating and sad. I'll just stick to Moby-Dick here but I love all his work.

Moby-Dick was the first novel I ever read that felt like the author was speaking directly to me. I was in high school when I first came across it - I was going through a pirate phase and it was on my list - and it stopped me dead in my tracks. It's not just a novel; it's an anachronistic multimedia experiment. It mixes prose and script and poetry and quotes and dictionary entries with elegant language and salty sailor speak. It's eloquent and disgusting, elevated and deeply down in the dirt and foam. It is an explosion of contrast, a constant seesaw back and forth between the narrative reality of a captain obsessively hunting a whale, and a common sailor named Ishmael reflecting on what that hunt means, what whales mean, what the colour white means, what the sky means, what the universe means. In his ruminations, nothing is dismissed. He wasn't dusty Hawthorne obsessing over the Bible; instead he was a sailor with a wide but naive breadth of knowledge of "Eastern religions," Asian history, "South Seas cannibals," so you never know what he's going to bring up. His was the kind of eclectic thinking that you didn't often see expressed with such eloquence in the 1850s.

So yeah, I like it a lot because it's written really well :)

But also, it's very raw, and you feel the sloppy earnestness of Melville on every page. He's trying so hard to communicate with you and - knowing that so many of his contemporaries didn't understand him - it makes you feel kind of special and connected with him when you do understand what he's saying, and you agree. It's a novel that benefits in a very unique way from NOT murdering the author; from understanding who the author was, what he went through, how exuberant he was for so long and then how much the exigencies of publishing and finances beat him down.

We people who love Moby-Dick tend to really love Moby-Dick. I'm certain Melville himself is a big reason for this. We connect with his struggles. We celebrate the immortality of all artists by raising up his work and reaching back through the centuries to take his tarry hand.

More Posts from Rainwvalker and Others

2 years ago

USA Native Plant Resource Masterlist

Because Google is totally useless and won't help you with ANYTHING

iNaturalist: Take photos of living things you see, post them, and the community will identify them for you. Data from iNaturalist is used in scientific research.

Wildflower.org Plant Database: Enter search criteria and find some plants. Very useful if you're looking for plants with specific qualities or know what you have in mind.

Native Plant Finder: This website is still in beta and is a work in progress, but it will show you plants for your area ranked by the number of butterflies that use them for their caterpillars.

WildflowerSearch: AMAZING resource for identification and for learning about new plants. Shows you where plants are native/not native, TONS of search filters.

Native Plant Trust: A New England organization, but probably useful to anyone.

Northern Forest Atlas: Great images and identification resources for trees; has good pictures of bark, seeds, buds, leaves.

FloraFinder: Another plant database site that's being slowly built up by a passionate nerd.

MonarchWatch milkweed by USA ecoregion: Tells you what milkweed species you should plant for monarch butterflies.

Native Beeology: Not plants, but a closely related subject.

I will add more and post an updated list as I find more.


Tags
1 year ago

I have so many poems memorized for the right moment but what they don't tell you is that there's pretty much never occasions to recite poetry unprompted. or prompted for that matter


Tags
1 year ago
Lines From The Original Composition Of “A Letter To An Israeli Soldier,” Written By Muin Bseiso And

Lines from the original composition of “A letter to an Israeli soldier,” written by Muin Bseiso and Mahmoud Darwish as they sheltered during the Israeli siege of Beirut in 1982. Courtesy of the family of Muin Bseiso.

Moments of decolonization, in relation to the recalcitrant Palestinian case, have been occasions for jubilation. We may recall the scenes from southern Lebanon in May 2000, when the Israeli military finally withdrew from the region. Israel had been in Lebanon, with the help of its right-wing Lebanese adjuncts, since 1982, when it invaded to evict the Palestine Liberation Organization from their Beirut headquarters. That summer, the Israeli military laid siege to Beirut for more than two months, bombing the densely populated city and killing thousands. While many Lebanese died, Palestinians were the principal targets of the Israeli campaign.

Among those huddled beneath the bombs were Muin Bseiso and Mahmoud Darwish, two of Palestine’s most prominent poets. They would both later produce book-length accounts of the siege, but over the course of one evening that summer, they wrote a poem as one.

A letter to an Israeli soldier, is what they named their poem. In one stanza, the two poets address the “inhabitant of the tank.”

We write to you Before a shell ignites us or ignites you Here is a message of the last besieged to the last besieged We write from a fragment you sent … to carry you From the darkness of the “ghetto” to our bodies … We write to you

Bseiso and Darwish ask:

Can one piss in a tank? Can he read in the tank? Can a person fly pigeons in a tank? Can one fuck in a tank? Or plant trees in the tank? … How long have you been in the claws of the tank? How long have you been safe?

The poem enacts an incredible reversal: the poets, themselves confined to an apartment at the mercy of missiles and mortars, taunt the soldier besieging them. The Israeli soldier is confined by the steel that is meant to protect him. They write in their letter, “You are in a dungeon, behind bars.” Many of the poem’s stanza’s end simply with the refrain Hal anta fi aman?—meaning, Are you safe?

Meanwhile, the poets have their own refrain: our siege is long.

Our siege is long We shall bake the stone We shall knead the moon We shall finish our journey Upon this beautiful day Our siege is long

From "Our Siege is Long," article by Esmat Elhalaby (published 27 October 2023)


Tags
2 years ago
L Krl_photo

l krl_photo


Tags
3 years ago

How do you feel about evolved forms of contractions? It'd've, for example :3

I think you should use whatever tools communicate your intentions best!

I've seen eggheads complain about excessive contractions, and against trying to phonetically write out how characters speak. but lol i say. lmao.

Beautiful writing is rhythmic writing, and every syllable is a musical note. Why would you restrict what notes you can use? Preposterous. Ludicrous!


Tags
4 years ago

This is for you, Rainwalker! You asked for it, baby!

The road infrastructure in Sharteshane must be appalling, good thing Rilursa can always count on GEICO Roadside Pickup :)


Tags
6 years ago
I’m Sorry.

I’m sorry.

//rainwvalker…… you will pay for this//


Tags
4 years ago

Did you actively design Cresce and Alderode to be opposites of each other or did they sort of evolve that way as you were writing the comic?

They were designed to be foils. Can’t have a story without conflict! However I didn’t design one to be markedly or obviously “better” or more just than the other. They both have their problems. I’m not extraordinarily interested in the fight between them, because neither are ideologically pure. You can’t honestly cheer for either side. If you DO, that’s fine, but there is plenty of space and reason to dislike them both.

I’m more interested in the citizens of each place and how they deal with each other on an individual level, and how people in general are able to live in a world where no one is ideologically pure; where almost all institutions are self-serving and wicked. That’s a big theme in Unsounded. All group endeavours are rotten, or become rotten. Trust individuals, but never institutions.

This will all carry through to Alderode. There is no “right” caste. There is no “right” religion between the Ssaelit and Gefendur. There are good people, good intentions, and good days all carried along by a river of time and entropy. That’s life.


Tags
1 year ago
Odysseus And Athena
Odysseus And Athena

odysseus and athena

find me on instagram!


Tags
Loading...
End of content
No more pages to load
  • schniggles
    schniggles liked this · 7 months ago
  • rifuye
    rifuye liked this · 8 months ago
  • lowpolyleaf
    lowpolyleaf reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • libraryofandrasta
    libraryofandrasta reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • woozapooza
    woozapooza reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • babystarcandysposts
    babystarcandysposts liked this · 3 years ago
  • not-a-robot-technically
    not-a-robot-technically reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • not-a-robot-technically
    not-a-robot-technically liked this · 3 years ago
  • playthelion
    playthelion reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • nels4630
    nels4630 liked this · 3 years ago
  • moshpitwallflower
    moshpitwallflower liked this · 3 years ago
  • willow-of-stars
    willow-of-stars liked this · 3 years ago
  • smuggysnake
    smuggysnake liked this · 3 years ago
  • novemango
    novemango liked this · 3 years ago
  • frostmoths
    frostmoths liked this · 3 years ago
  • zeugmalitotes
    zeugmalitotes reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • zeugmalitotes
    zeugmalitotes liked this · 3 years ago
  • antialiasis
    antialiasis liked this · 3 years ago
  • flamesparks
    flamesparks liked this · 3 years ago
  • the-quasar-hero
    the-quasar-hero liked this · 3 years ago
  • murderthegods
    murderthegods liked this · 3 years ago
  • literaryartisan
    literaryartisan liked this · 3 years ago
  • almondextract
    almondextract liked this · 3 years ago
  • malinkeshar
    malinkeshar liked this · 3 years ago
  • awlwren
    awlwren liked this · 3 years ago
  • jasjabberwocky
    jasjabberwocky liked this · 3 years ago
  • madmanrambler
    madmanrambler reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • madmanrambler
    madmanrambler liked this · 3 years ago
  • lady-lich
    lady-lich liked this · 3 years ago
  • lazerbeehm
    lazerbeehm liked this · 3 years ago
  • duskmonk
    duskmonk liked this · 3 years ago
  • carnotaur
    carnotaur liked this · 3 years ago
  • suspected-spinozist
    suspected-spinozist liked this · 3 years ago
  • leukaraii
    leukaraii liked this · 3 years ago
  • khyrberos
    khyrberos reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • khyrberos
    khyrberos liked this · 3 years ago
  • eelwheels
    eelwheels liked this · 3 years ago
  • birbbells
    birbbells liked this · 3 years ago
rainwvalker - You Must be Truly Desperate to Come Here
You Must be Truly Desperate to Come Here

Hello! This is a tumblr blog. I do stuff. Actually I don't really do stuff, I just reblog things. Yup. That's about it. Banner art is by @painter-marx, icon is by @rifuye

157 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags