I Don't Know If It's An Unpopular Take But I Cannot Stand Toph's Characterization In The ATLA Comics.

I don't know if it's an unpopular take but I cannot stand Toph's characterization in the ATLA comics. They stripped Toph of all her personality traits expect for sassy earthbender. She's downright rude in some instances. I won't even begin to talk about her erasure - one of the fandom's preferred characters and yet she is barely more than a side character (even in her designated comic she has to share it with Aang)

Where is the Toph that cried because she missed her mother and felt remorse for abandoning her during the war? Where is the Toph that comforted Zuko during the Ember Island Play intermission? Where is the Toph that canonically loves and protects her friends, thinks of them as a family and wants to carry out their friendship into another life?

Yes, Toph is confident, arrogant at times and sassy. But she never was rude to her loved ones; never disregarded differenf cultures nor did she ever lack spirituality. It's also hysterical that during The Rift - after Toph passes out from saving multiple people from being crushed by metal - not one of her friends remembers or seems to care about her. NOT ONE!

Most characters were done dirty in these comics. Katara and Zuko might be the biggest victims of being substantially OOC but I rarely see people talk about how they completely disregarded Toph's character arc or her personality.

One day I'll write a whole dissertation of Toph's portrayal in the comics (and how her relationship with Aang was handled)

You can have a badass female character without stripping her from her humility and vulnerability.

More Posts from Sarahkrolokfan and Others

5 months ago
I Found This Artist On Ig
I Found This Artist On Ig
I Found This Artist On Ig
I Found This Artist On Ig
I Found This Artist On Ig
I Found This Artist On Ig

I found this artist on ig

@becomeafish if You Danna check their art ❤️ is so beaitiful 😭❤️

1 year ago

I hate fanon-ization of Lily, James, Regulus and Barty (Evan, Dorcas, Marlene etc. are literally only mentioned in the books, there is nothing to mis-characterize)

Lily is side-lined for a non-existent, non-sensical ship (yeah, I hate jegulus), her Muggle origin is overlooked even though it played a MAJOR role in her life (heck the entire Marauders era takes place during the war against a wizard-supremacist, Muggle-hater and his racist followers). Her relationship with Snape and how his words and newly found ideologies affected is completely overlooked when he was her only magical friend during her entire childhood. Her relationship to her son? (yk, that one thing that set the entire series in motion...) - pfft, don't be silly, she is just a surrogate to James and Regulus.

James is portrayed as a ray of sunshine, good boy whose biggest sin was being a bit sarcastic. No, he WAS an arrogant asshole who mercilessly bullied another student simply for his own enjoyment. Yet he was also incredibly loyal man who didn't hesitate to share his home with his friend after he ran away from home and who grew out of his arrogant phase and changed himself for better because of a woman he loved (loved so much he died protecting her and their son later).

Regulus is portrayed as an edgy yet kind-hearted little aristocrat boy whose parents forced him into being a Death Eater - no, he wasn't pressured into becoming anything, Regulus for the longest part of his life WAS a Voldemort supporter. He collected newspaper articles about Voldemort, he talked to Kreacher about how great Voldemort is and how great his ideas were - yes, he realized later he was wrong but it doesn't suddenly mean he was pressured into anything.

Barty is portrayed as a silly little babygirl who has an IQ of goldfish. No, he was one of the smartest characters with multiple talents but was also a mentaly-unstable young man (Azkaban/Dementors have horrific influence on everyone but while other Death Eaters managed to last 10+ years there he was already on his death-bed in a year and started to scream for him mother the same day he was brought in) who went completely insane and evil by the end and craved for father figure so deeply he was ready to become a murderer/torturer to get one. His manipulativeness and sadism? Non-existent in fanon...

In the end... I truly dislike the overall state of "Marauders era" fandom - like, they are a generation impacted by war and ever-changing politics who essentially needed to choose a side while they were still children, some betraying their families and loved ones - and then you try seeing stuff in Marauders fandom and they are turned into edgy teens who all wear crop-tops and black nail polish, listen to Taylor, go to Starbucks and talk in a Tik-Tok slang....


Tags
1 year ago

Hange with 6packs and tons of muscle please

Hange With 6packs And Tons Of Muscle Please

🧎‍♀️🧎‍♀️🧎‍♀️

1 year ago

My issue with Korra isn’t that the characters were uninteresting tbh - it’s that they were the exact opposite of that. There was so much room for exploration. Avatar was such a good show (with flaws) because developed it’s characters fantastically (up until Aang’s S3 arc, which could have been handled a lot better imo) - they took the troupes it would’ve been easy to resort to - naggy mom friend, happy go lucky kid, badass girl, edgy guy - and showed the complexities behind them. Aang hides the loss of literally his entire life behind his cheerfulness, and it’s shown how he snaps, gets angry and runs away. Toph’s entire persona is carefully crafted to defy the helpless role she’s been cast in her whole life - she’s not just badass, but badass purposefully. Zuko has a desperation born of years of abuse behind his angst. Katara has survivor’s guilt and trauma, forced parentification, and rage behind her hot temper and mothering, and is allowed to explore those. Sokka is goofy, but he’s intelligent, cunning, and it’s shown how his goofy façade hides his insecurities over his own skills and masculinity.

Korra never gave it’s characters room to breathe. We never got the chance to see who they were past the love triangles, too-fast plots that were dropped after one season, and robots for some reason. Mako was introduced as the edgy love interest, and despite how interesting his backstory is and all the potential behind it (especially with his parallels to Katara - he has so many!!), that’s who he stayed. Bolin, same as the goofy comic relief. Asami, she just… has no real personality. She’s… strong willed. Sometimes she’s angry, I guess. There’s never anything even to hold onto with her - her feelings over her mother’s death are never really explored, nor are her relationships with really anyone sans her romantic bonds with Korra and Mako. Her scenes with her father in S4 showed hints to some potential, but it wasn’t enough to make me invested in a character I had spent three seasons up till now looking at as a blank slate - the Token Badass Nonbender, and that’s that. Jinora’s one of the more interesting characters on the show, but there was a lot more room to explore her insecurities surrounding if she can live up to her grandfather’s legacy, her spirit abilities, and Kai and their relationship especially.

Really, it’s just… Mako’s parents were killed in front of him when he was eight, and then he was forced to basically raise Bolin without a home. Bolin had no stability in his life for most of it, and his only real trusted figure was his two years older brother. Korra is an avatar who was never given a chance to develop any identity outside of that, seeing the world, one carved from the ashes of imperialism and genocide, for the first time. Asami has a father who manipulates her and works with terrorists, but unlike Ozai with Zuko and Azula, genuinely loves her. Even within just these four there are such interesting ways you could go. But Korra was really the only one allowed to develop at all, and even then, for some reason she has to be brutally tortured to… ‘humble’ her? Like, I did like that arc, but there’s also some… things going on there.

Maybe there could have been an episode like the Southern Raiders but for Mako, where he and idk Asami? anyone really, hunt down the firebender who killed his parents, and he’s forced to confront the source of his trauma that started it all. Maybe we could have a storyline about the Triple Threats, Mako and Bolin’s time with them, how bad their circumstances were and some of the things they were forced to do. Maybe something like The Beach but for Asami, letting her crack and break about her complex feelings towards her father. We could have seen more of Mako being an older brother to Kai, Kai’s development from selfish and flightly to kinder and more grounded with Jinora. Maybe we could have been shown more of Kai’s backstory - his parents? Idk.

Korra, of course, would still need to be the focus. Maybe something like Nightmares and Daydreams but darker, like, towards the end of every season to explore how the pressure and trauma from being the avatar is negatively affecting her. Idk.

Just… let the characters develop. Breathe. Be people and not just caricatures or placeholders, yk? This goes for Jinora, Ikki and Meelo, Kai, the Krew, the adults, everyone - Korra had four seasons. Maybe not time for everyone, but at least for more than they gave. At least time for the main four.


Tags
2 years ago
Flojean Week Day 3: Mystery/noir
Flojean Week Day 3: Mystery/noir

Flojean week day 3: mystery/noir

1 year ago
Wenn Ich Dein Spiegel Wär / Dann Würdest Du Dich In Mir Sehn / Dann Fiel's Dir Nicht So Schwer / Was

Wenn ich dein Spiegel wär / Dann würdest du dich in mir sehn / Dann fiel's dir nicht so schwer / Was ich nicht sage, zu verstehn / Bis du dich umdrehst / Weil du dich zu gut in mir erkennst

  • spaceflower07
    spaceflower07 liked this · 1 month ago
  • paleomario66
    paleomario66 liked this · 3 months ago
  • bluestarlightobject
    bluestarlightobject liked this · 5 months ago
  • oddearthbender
    oddearthbender liked this · 5 months ago
  • vermillion-reeds
    vermillion-reeds reblogged this · 6 months ago
  • minluce
    minluce liked this · 6 months ago
  • mauradersdaughter
    mauradersdaughter liked this · 6 months ago
  • bailique88
    bailique88 reblogged this · 7 months ago
  • bailique88
    bailique88 liked this · 7 months ago
  • theshinymetalassknight7xl9
    theshinymetalassknight7xl9 liked this · 7 months ago
  • lakin520purple
    lakin520purple reblogged this · 7 months ago
  • lakin520purple
    lakin520purple liked this · 7 months ago
  • thiccciminaj
    thiccciminaj liked this · 7 months ago
  • rightwheretheyleftme
    rightwheretheyleftme reblogged this · 7 months ago
  • rightwheretheyleftme
    rightwheretheyleftme liked this · 7 months ago
  • dragonfoxandfound
    dragonfoxandfound liked this · 7 months ago
  • goddessofliteratureandsarcasm
    goddessofliteratureandsarcasm liked this · 7 months ago
  • ai-manre
    ai-manre liked this · 7 months ago
  • bblackthing
    bblackthing liked this · 7 months ago
  • miamista13
    miamista13 liked this · 7 months ago
  • carmelves
    carmelves liked this · 7 months ago
  • muiltifandomnerd
    muiltifandomnerd reblogged this · 7 months ago
  • muiltifandomnerd
    muiltifandomnerd liked this · 7 months ago
  • queencantaloupe
    queencantaloupe liked this · 7 months ago
  • lyndexv
    lyndexv reblogged this · 7 months ago
  • lordmommy
    lordmommy liked this · 7 months ago
  • le-n-writes
    le-n-writes liked this · 7 months ago
  • lamarie-artsy
    lamarie-artsy reblogged this · 7 months ago
  • blackbeau73
    blackbeau73 liked this · 7 months ago
  • akherontraveler
    akherontraveler reblogged this · 7 months ago
  • cresentnaia
    cresentnaia reblogged this · 7 months ago
  • cresentnaia
    cresentnaia liked this · 7 months ago
  • dingdongthedemon
    dingdongthedemon reblogged this · 7 months ago
  • dingdongthedemon
    dingdongthedemon liked this · 7 months ago
  • draxofoy
    draxofoy liked this · 7 months ago
  • altemisia
    altemisia reblogged this · 7 months ago
  • linnoya-writes
    linnoya-writes liked this · 7 months ago
  • mahiiragi
    mahiiragi reblogged this · 7 months ago
  • a-maidens-fantasy
    a-maidens-fantasy liked this · 7 months ago
  • alwaystireds-world
    alwaystireds-world liked this · 7 months ago
  • azula-hates-men
    azula-hates-men liked this · 7 months ago
  • deepestnerdkid
    deepestnerdkid liked this · 7 months ago
  • haveumetbi
    haveumetbi liked this · 7 months ago
  • linnoya-writes
    linnoya-writes reblogged this · 7 months ago
  • pantheri-leo45
    pantheri-leo45 liked this · 7 months ago
  • burst-of-iridescent
    burst-of-iridescent liked this · 7 months ago
  • mitchie-is-on-ice
    mitchie-is-on-ice liked this · 7 months ago
  • strawberrymilkyumyum
    strawberrymilkyumyum reblogged this · 7 months ago
sarahkrolokfan - My Blog
My Blog

Marta, returned to this hellsite just for art, Croatian, woman, twitter: @gilliantemptI like musicals, AoT (Hange, Floch, Jean), HotD, bunch of movies, Sims and DE 20+

229 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags