I Think A Lot Of Modern Sherlock Holmes Adaptations (as In, Holmes In The Modern Era) Miss Out By Having

I think a lot of modern Sherlock Holmes adaptations (as in, Holmes in the modern era) miss out by having Holmes work so closely with the police. A lot of people forget that Holmes was one of the original ACAB bitchies in fiction; he did not like the police. Yes, he worked alongside them sometimes, but he often talked about them with open distain. Sometimes he even worked directly against them (think of The Norwood Builder).

Granted this was mostly because the police lacked a lot of the skills they have today, such as forensics, something that Holmes was an advocate for, and tended to draw conclusions that did not fit the obvious facts. This has obviously changed - the police have a lot more resources at their disposal nowadays, but they are not a perfect institution - far, far from it, and if he were alive today, Holmes would have a lot to say about that.

I wish modern adaptations stayed true to the fact that in canon, Sherlock Holmes was the man you went to if you could not go to the police. If you had, perhaps, a criminal record, were homeless, were POC, were queer, were neurodivergent, an abuse victim, reliant on illegal substances, or even wrongfully accused, Sherlock Holmes would be the man you went to, and he would help you to the best of his ability.

Also, Holmes had his own unique sense of justice. Think of The Abbey Grange - a man murders the abusive husband of an old lover, and the wife is complicit. Holmes and Watson ultimately decide to let them go - Lady Brackenstall was being horribly abused, she was trapped in a loveless marriage with a violent husband. Captain Crocker murdered Sir Eustace, freeing Lady Brackenstall and perhaps saving her life. If the police had arrested Crocker, it would be very likely he would be hanged for murder, regardless of the circumstances.

Then there is James Ryder in the Blue Carbuncle. He, after Holmes pesters him, freely admits to stealing the jewel, but Holmes does not hand him over to the police and instead lets him walk free. It was Ryder's first offence, one he was manipulated into committing, and Holmes and Watson see him as a, quite frankly, pathetic little man. Holmes realises that if he were to turn Ryder in, it would destroy his life - he would be 'a jailbird for life'. Ryder committed a crime, but he is no criminal. Prison would turn him into one.

Holmes takes justice into his own hands, and in a way, it turns him into an anti-hero. But I think this a part of what makes him such a loveable, iconic character.

Holmes has created a 'safe space' within 221B Baker Street. I think this would be extremely intresting to explore through a modern lens.

More Posts from Skylee-spider-lillis and Others

The urge to adopt several pets and name them after the Batfamily pets (specifically the animals that are the same like the comics, creating the characters in real life) is so strong.

Unfortunately, I don't think I'll ever find a dragon bat to call him Goliath :(

I want Goliath so bad.

Also forget naming your human kids after characters, I plan to name my pets after fictional characters.


Tags
4 months ago

i am so fucking depressed this show was cancelled can we pls get it back before i lose it omg


Tags
8 months ago

WTF.

WTF WTF WTF.

THIS SHOW CANNOT BE CANCELLED.

IT HAS BECOME MY LIFE THIS LAST FEW MONTHS.

NETFLIX I SM GOING TO CHOP OFF SOME HEADS.

WTF WTF WTF WTF WTF?????????

BUT THE SIGNS.

THERE WERE SO MANY SIGNS.

WHAT???????


Tags
11 months ago

I know most of the DBDA fandom probably thinks at paineland at the trope of "x fell first, xx fell harder" is Edwin falling first and Charles now falling harder; because Edwin was obviously shown first to express his feelings.

But consider this-

Charles falling in love with Edwin slowly a little more every day, falling a bit deeper for him every day they spent side by side.

And at some point later- Edwin is crushing hard. Realizing "oh shit, I love him-" and falling hard in a chaotic storm of feeling he doesn't know how to deal with, he's a complete mess.

Idk, I personally prefer the second version more but both options can be great interpretations of their dynamic.


Tags
6 months ago

You can spam boop me!

reblog if you let people spam boop you


Tags
2 months ago

I do love to think about all three versions of the dbda meeting but one thing I find extra funny is the concept of them fighting, like physically

with Charles: comic Charles would not last three seconds I’m sorry, if he wasn’t dead he’d die, we didn’t see much of doom patrol Charles but he seems pretty proficient with weapons so I’m guessing he and Netflix Charles would be evenly matched

with Crystal: honestly depends on the day, doom patrol Crystal could wack them with a shovel, Netflix Crystal could beat them with her bare hands and one of comic Crystal first actions is to burn down her school with a Molotov cocktail and chase a demon with knives, id give it to any of them tbh

but Edwin??? I’m sorry it goes to the twelve year old without question, the others are getting bodied, not even accounting the lightning spell that scrappy little shit would rugby tackle them to the ground and start beating, Charles would have to pull him off, maybe even two Charles’


Tags

I have mentioned in my previous post how everyone related to the biological bat family is Jewish, but I need to talk a moment about Damian Wayne's aunts.

Because this boy has 5 Jewish aunts. And not just from Bruce's side.

Let's review them, alright?

1. One of the most famous out of them, Kate Kane aka Batwoman. The Jewish icon and Bruce's cousin. (Once removed or-something still counts!)

2. Beth Kane or Red Alice, Kate's twin. She's his aunt as well, the same as Kate.

3. Bette Kane, aka flamebird, another cousin of Bruce. Also shares the same Jewish blood.

Just wait, now is the more interesting part I've been waiting for:

4. Nyssa Raatco. (Very different from the Arrowverse version).

Talia's older sister. Daughter of Ra's Al Ghul and her Jewish mom. A badass Jewish Arab assassin, and one of my favorite Jewish aunts of Damian.

And the last one might be more controversial, because I know she's *technically* not family but still

Harey Quinn is the 5 Jewish aunt of Damian I'LL DIE DEFENDING IT.

My source?

I Have Mentioned In My Previous Post How Everyone Related To The Biological Bat Family Is Jewish, But

AUNTIE QUINN!?!!

DC fans don't get mad at me I know Harley is not batfamily I just think she's an aunt figure to Damian. She's not part of the whole batfam, she's his aunt exclusively. She's Damian's fifth Jewish aunt fight me.

Yap I'll see myself out šŸšŖā†šŸƒ


Tags

Can people stop making Damian homophobic just because he's the "brat" child?

His best friends are bi and ace his aunt is a lesbian and his adopted brother is also bi. Some of the people Damian loves the most are LGBTQIA.

Damian was such a good ally to Jon during DC pride 2022- he was ready to fight homophobes in the parade! Mostly because he wanted to fight in general but still he was ready to kick homophobic asses. Very ally of him if you ask me.

Stop with the homophobic Damian jokes, if anything Damian would dislike everyone equally and not because of who they are.

In my eyes this take on him is a very poor understanding of Damian's character.

Edit: It might be just me but I saw "jokes" that made Damian homophobic, especially towards Tim, and it just makes me irrationally mad.

Edit 2: sorry to the arrow fam fans for mentioning Connor, I know the 2021 is a poor interpretation of him and not very in character. It's still canon, and the pride issue was nice.


Tags
8 months ago

Wayyyy later than what I expected to finish, I'm finally finished with my Payneland fencing fic! Thank you so much to everybody that offered themselves as my beta, I really appreciate that!

archiveofourown.org
An Archive of Our Own, a project of the Organization for Transformative Works

Relationships: Edwin Payne/Charles Rowland, Edwin Payne & Charles Rowland (the fic focus on their friendship specifically, the romance is just an ending bonus).

Rating: gen

Trigger warnings: blades/ fencing, dysfunctional gays, Charles that's so fucking gay you cannot say that to your platonic best friend,

Other stuff: fencer Edwin Payne, touch starved Charles & touch starved Edwin if you squint, love confession, hurt/comfort, eventual cuddling, teens being teens, slight miscommunication the first half of the fic, okay they're really miscommunicating at the start but it gets better don't worry!

Link to the snippet

Edwin and Charles' friendship come first before anything else, before any romantic feelings ever even started. This is why when shortly after Port Townsend when Charles is starting to act off and Edwin feels it's because of his confession affecting them, although Charles is denying the accusation, he confronts Charles to talk with him again the way they do things: He makes him fence with him.

And Charles can never tell Edwin no, is he? Or: Charles tried to isolate himself away from Edwin, Edwin couldn't let that stand. The boys being teenagers and fooling around fencing.

Based on my fencing history so I actually come with knowledge about that! I kinda took advantage of that for creating this fic.

I hope you'll like it! I really enjoyed writing it. Charles is my favourite out of them but damn fencer Edwin is ruining my brain.


Tags
Loading...
End of content
No more pages to load
  • pathos-logical
    pathos-logical liked this · 1 week ago
  • alotistwowords
    alotistwowords reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • alotistwowords
    alotistwowords liked this · 1 week ago
  • thelazytealover
    thelazytealover liked this · 1 week ago
  • itspinkflowers
    itspinkflowers liked this · 1 week ago
  • doeinheadlightsss
    doeinheadlightsss liked this · 1 week ago
  • kasutera
    kasutera liked this · 1 week ago
  • pixoearte
    pixoearte liked this · 1 week ago
  • rabbit-with-a-grapefruit-spoon
    rabbit-with-a-grapefruit-spoon liked this · 1 week ago
  • ravensknowledge
    ravensknowledge reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • gwendolynflight
    gwendolynflight reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • aitogi
    aitogi reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • blueberrymango
    blueberrymango liked this · 1 week ago
  • detective-frog
    detective-frog reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • makomoriii
    makomoriii liked this · 1 week ago
  • tyrannosaurusnacks
    tyrannosaurusnacks reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • teddyichneumon
    teddyichneumon liked this · 1 week ago
  • gaytobymeres
    gaytobymeres liked this · 1 week ago
  • intothehandsoffate
    intothehandsoffate liked this · 1 week ago
  • matsuorka
    matsuorka reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • hrshl-hlms
    hrshl-hlms reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • furiousghoul
    furiousghoul liked this · 1 week ago
  • spocklesbian
    spocklesbian reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • lunarinterludez
    lunarinterludez liked this · 1 week ago
  • blackbeardsballs
    blackbeardsballs liked this · 1 week ago
  • iamnotgoodatnames
    iamnotgoodatnames liked this · 1 week ago
  • theroxiefalls
    theroxiefalls liked this · 1 week ago
  • ineffable-ink
    ineffable-ink liked this · 1 week ago
  • sadieb798
    sadieb798 liked this · 1 week ago
  • siopea
    siopea reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • siopea
    siopea liked this · 1 week ago
  • delicacyoftouch
    delicacyoftouch reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • granadalock
    granadalock reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • granadalock
    granadalock liked this · 1 week ago
  • star-phantoms
    star-phantoms liked this · 1 week ago
  • piratesamsam
    piratesamsam reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • loveforjeremybrett
    loveforjeremybrett liked this · 1 week ago
  • fastenyourseatbelts
    fastenyourseatbelts reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • habadabadooda
    habadabadooda reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • amypihcs
    amypihcs reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • novas-reblogs
    novas-reblogs reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • just-some-fagdyke
    just-some-fagdyke liked this · 1 week ago
  • hides-from-the-light
    hides-from-the-light liked this · 1 week ago
  • theforestswillechowithlaughter4
    theforestswillechowithlaughter4 reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • theforestswillechowithlaughter4
    theforestswillechowithlaughter4 liked this · 1 week ago
  • thricellamaaddicted
    thricellamaaddicted reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • bedheaded-league
    bedheaded-league reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • rikslyart
    rikslyart liked this · 2 weeks ago
  • sam-neather
    sam-neather liked this · 2 weeks ago
skylee-spider-lillis - Dead Ben DetectivešŸ’€šŸ”ā„¢ at your serviceāœŒļø
Dead Ben DetectivešŸ’€šŸ”ā„¢ at your serviceāœŒļø

Call me RubĆØn!! Or Ru / Ben if we're friends.āœ”ļøšŸŒˆ no pronouns/he/they/it.Used to be multi fandom, mostly Dead Boy Detectives right now. I swear this account had other subjects before.Usually mostly DC but I spit out a lot of random fandoms shit.

213 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags