Curate, connect, and discover
Do y'all think maybe Rose Cracked pink but didn't shatter her. That would account for people saying they witnessed Pinks "shattering" by Rose. Maybe Rose didn't even intend to shatter pink, but crack her just enough to be able to heal her later. Also, everyone has this fabtabulous story that Rose COULDN'T have shattered pink because Roses Sword can't shatter gems. But what if rose didn't use her sword? What if she did use the breaking point like Steven guessed in "The Trial" but she missed on purpose to damage instead of destroy.Or perhaps the only reason she used the breaking point is because it was guaranteed strong enough to shatter a diamond,at least bismuth seemed sure of this. Or perhaps it was just strong enough to crack a diamond and bring them to their knees. (Which might be another reason Rose wouldn't allow bismuth to go off on a suicide mission to shatter the Diamonds with a weapon they weren't even sure would finish the job.) Anywho, the BP suddenly reappearing would explain why Blue Diamond is so upset, because though the diamonds knew the breaking point existed, they'd recieved Intel that Rose was not using such a horrible weapon, at least, not until she did use it.On Pink. Maybe Pink is still alive but damaged and that's why when we see her in Stevens dream and she punches the mirror, instead of it cracking and it's pieces falling out its frame. It's just cracked but not shattered and falling apart.