Be Careful: Nostalgia Likes To Link Arms With Fascism.

Be careful: nostalgia likes to link arms with fascism.

I've seen a lot of talk about how millennials are especially prone to nostalgia. How technology's rapid evolution left our childhoods as a distinctly different world than our present. How we cling to our childhood hobbies and IPs as a way to heal our inner children, etc etc.

And there's nothing inherently wrong with nostalgia. I still play pokemon games and am in the middle of rewatching Yu Yu Hakusho. You're allowed to love the things you grew up with.

But we need to be careful.

Conservatives, nationalists, and fascists *love* to evoke a ☆mythic☆ idealized past- when men were men, when America was great, upon which to build a fixed and solid identity. Any progress away from this idealized conception of the past is thus decay- corruption and ruin. Nostalgia underpins a fascists worldview and allows them to justify any violence against the forces that would further degrade society away from its perfect past. Protecting the past comes to justify all sorts of things in the present.

We need to be very careful about what we allow our nostalgia to mean to us, what we allow it to excuse or justify.

This is not *just* about Hogwarts Legacy, but Hogwarts Legacy is a good example of it. When you can invoke your nostalgia- that golden beautiful past where you felt safe and special- what are you willing to ignore? What harm are you willing to allow? What will you turn a blind eye to if doing so makes you feel like you've recaptured some of the magic from the past?

Tread carefully, friends. This HP bullshit may have been a test that you passed, but it will not be the last time when our sense of nostalgia may conflict with progress and morals. Always remember that you can love something from the past without letting it dictate the future.

More Posts from Emilyh1983 and Others

2 years ago
I Beg To Every Bowuigi Fic Writers Out There To Add Luigi Crossdressing AND Laughing Like This. It's

I beg to every Bowuigi fic writers out there to add Luigi crossdressing AND laughing like this. It's simply iconic.

2 years ago

Everyone saying Sans could host Welcome To Night Vale, besides being wrong, are failing to imagine the infinitely funnier alternative of Cecil in Undertale.

2 months ago

Okay I want to talk about this moment between Morrible and Glinda for a sec because it adds such a wonderfully sinister layer to a scene that is otherwise a triumphant defining moment for Elphaba, and it sets up the dynamics for Part 2 so perfectly.

Okay I Want To Talk About This Moment Between Morrible And Glinda For A Sec Because It Adds Such A Wonderfully
Okay I Want To Talk About This Moment Between Morrible And Glinda For A Sec Because It Adds Such A Wonderfully
Okay I Want To Talk About This Moment Between Morrible And Glinda For A Sec Because It Adds Such A Wonderfully
Okay I Want To Talk About This Moment Between Morrible And Glinda For A Sec Because It Adds Such A Wonderfully

At this point, we are in the thick of “Defying Gravity.” Everyone’s attention is on Elphaba - and rightfully so, she’s up there declaring war on the Wizard, displaying incredible feats of magic, of course everyone’s attention is on her.

…Everyone, except Morrible.

Morrible has realized that Plan A was a bust, but rather than panicking, she’s already worked over Plans B through Z in her head and has realized that Glinda, not Elphaba, is actually the key figure here. Glinda is actually the best thing that could have happened to them.

Mind you, Morrible hates Glinda. She thinks Glinda is vapid and attention-seeking and completely without talent. It would be extremely easy for her to brand Glinda as an accomplice to Elphaba, have the guards drag her off, imprison her, never have to deal with her again, nice and neat.

Instead, while everyone else is focused on Elphaba, Morrible only has eyes for Glinda. She zeroes in on her, releases her, and comforts her, because she understands what no one else understands, which is that yes, that’s great that the Wizard now has an enemy to unify his people against, but they also need a symbol of hope, something that is the exact antithesis to Elphaba, something to keep everyone at extremes. 

The Wizard himself can’t really be a symbol of hope, because the key to his success is that he remains shrouded in mystery, and yes people think he’s wonderful, but there’s a level of uncertainty and intimidation to him. He is Oz the Great and Terrible, and everyone’s preeeeeetty sure he’s a good guy, but if you have someone like Elphaba out there - who Morrible knows from experience is very smart, very articulate, and has her own sort of magnetism - there’s a potential that she could turn at least enough people against the Wizard to make things very inconvenient.

So what they need, now that they have an enemy, is to have an equally magnetic figurehead representing the Wizard who embodies all these one-dimensional ideas of goodness, someone for the public to adore and fawn over so the association between Wizard and Goodness is crystal clear.

And by bringing Glinda along, Elphaba has unknowingly served that figurehead up on a platter.

Glinda is everything Elphaba isn’t, from personality, to appearance - Morrible has already set Elphaba up by calling her green skin an “outward manifestorium of her twisted nature,” which paves the way for Glinda, who is the perfect conventional beauty, to be an “outward manifestorium” of pure goodness. 

Morrible realizes they need these two lightning rods of Absolute Evil and Absolute Good in order to manipulate people - fear alone isn’t enough; the only way to effectively radicalize the populace is to make sure there is no gray area whatsoever, no room for question: you're either good, or you’re evil. And the Wizard alone isn’t a strong enough representation of “goodness” when by virtue of existing, he has to remain in the shadows. Glinda on the other hand? With her looks and her charm and her openness and her ability to expertly win over a crowd? Perfect for the role.

Now the tricky part for Morrible is taking into consideration that Glinda and Elphaba love each other. But we also know from earlier scenes that Morrible is a master at manipulating emotions. Right from the start when Elphaba is having trouble with her magic, Morrible casually brings up the “Animals should be seen and not heard” disturbance from class, spoon-feeding her just enough to get Elphaba upset, triggering her magic, after which Morrible makes sure to give her assurance and praise to keep Elphaba optimistic about her power.

Okay I Want To Talk About This Moment Between Morrible And Glinda For A Sec Because It Adds Such A Wonderfully
Okay I Want To Talk About This Moment Between Morrible And Glinda For A Sec Because It Adds Such A Wonderfully
Okay I Want To Talk About This Moment Between Morrible And Glinda For A Sec Because It Adds Such A Wonderfully
Okay I Want To Talk About This Moment Between Morrible And Glinda For A Sec Because It Adds Such A Wonderfully

She’s also aware that Glinda does have quite a bit of influence over Elphaba, because when Elphaba flees, Morrible immediately tasks her with winning her over, rather than simply relying on the guards or even going after Elphaba herself. She knows if anyone has a chance at roping Elphaba back in, it's Glinda.

Okay I Want To Talk About This Moment Between Morrible And Glinda For A Sec Because It Adds Such A Wonderfully

Obviously, Glinda isn’t successful in getting her back, but while this puts a dent in Morrible’s plans to get control of Elphaba, it does give her an extra weak spot to exploit in Glinda.

So now, at the height of “Defying Gravity” when Elphaba has officially taken her stand against them, Morrible sees Glinda, and Glinda is at her most vulnerable, her most emotionally fragile. Not only is she heartbroken and in shock, she’s also just witnessed in real time exactly how easy it is to turn an entire nation against someone. She’s scared, she’s powerless. She’s just lost the love of her life her only friend, she has no one to turn to - Morrible has definitely picked up on the fact that even though Glinda has countless people who fawn over her, none of them can be considered a true friend except for Elphaba, which means Glinda is completely isolated. Glinda also has a very limited understanding of the bigger picture of what the Wizard is trying to accomplish, and because she’s never been a victim of the system the way Elphaba has, she is still desperately clinging to the idea that everything will be okay as long as she plays by the rules of the people in power.

She has been perfectly primed for Morrible to begin manipulating, not through violence or intimidation, but by offering her comfort when no one else would - when not even Glinda’s only friend would - when no one else is even paying attention to Glinda, because they have the very real and present threat of Elphaba quite literally hanging over them. In this moment, Morrible chooses Glinda, which Glinda has been striving for since the beginning. Elphaba has chosen her principles, the Wizard has chosen his enemy, but Morrible has chosen Glinda, and in this moment of being so alone and so afraid and so betrayed, that makes all the difference.

We also get kind of a parallel shot too - Elphaba really sealed her fate the second her hand closed around the broom. But here, Glinda seals her fate when she gives in and reciprocates Morrible’s hold on her.

Okay I Want To Talk About This Moment Between Morrible And Glinda For A Sec Because It Adds Such A Wonderfully
Okay I Want To Talk About This Moment Between Morrible And Glinda For A Sec Because It Adds Such A Wonderfully

THIS is the moment that sets us up for Part 2, with Elphaba and Glinda as our lightning rods for Absolute Evil and Absolute Good, but more to the point, it makes it clear that they’ve BOTH been used, they’ve BOTH played right into these respective roles Morrible and the Wizard need in order to be successful - even if it wasn’t how Morrible originally planned for things to go.

I just love it, because “Defying Gravity” is Elphaba’s song - it’s triumphant, and it’s heartbreaking, and it’s everything a defining moment should be for a character. But by injecting this little moment between Morrible and Glinda into the scene, we also get an underlying current of dread because we know we’re about to see the consequences of Elphaba’s defiance versus Glinda’s compliance and how both serve to benefit the Wizard/Morrible’s propaganda.

TL;DR - when I said "I want to talk about this scene between Morrible and Glinda for a sec" I clearly meant "I'm gonna write a whole essay. Like a nerd."

2 years ago
Hello Islanders, Please Acquire Your Translating Device Immediately.
Hello Islanders, Please Acquire Your Translating Device Immediately.
Hello Islanders, Please Acquire Your Translating Device Immediately.

Hello Islanders, please acquire your translating device immediately.

3 months ago

fuck. can i just say something. travis kelce gets on stage at the eras tour and swifties cheer. when he shows up to her shows, he’s seen as a supportive boyfriend. but taylor swift is shown on screen at the super bowl for 5 seconds and the entire stadium boos. the president of the united states even posts about it. they say she’s “ruining football”. if you can’t see the double standard here, you are part of the problem.

2 years ago
HAPPY VALENTINES JONMARTIN
HAPPY VALENTINES JONMARTIN
HAPPY VALENTINES JONMARTIN

HAPPY VALENTINES JONMARTIN

2 years ago

Best Tumblr Ship Master List

——————————————————————————

- General Tags -

#BestTShip : everything related to the competition

#besttship competition : specifically the polls

#besttship art : art made by me and others relating to the tumblr best ship competition

#round 1 : all posts relating to round 1

#round 2 : all posts relating to round 2

#round 3 : all posts relating to round 3

#round 4 : all posts relating to round 4

#round 5 : all posts relating to round 5

#round 6 : all posts relating to round 6

#winners : posts announcing the winners of various rounds. Will be accompanied by art relating to the winners of the rounds.

——————————————————————————

Round 1 Bracket.

Achilles x Patroclus vs Nico Di Angelo x Will Solace

Tara x Darcy vs. Adrien x Darcy vs. Adrien x Marinette

Fred x Daphne vs. My Little Pony Polycule

Snufkin x Moomintroll vs. Will Graham x Hannibal Lecter

Vi x Caitlyn vs. Uhura x Chapel

Goncharov x Andrey vs. Venom x Eddie Brock

Deku x Uraraka vs. Klavier Gavin x Apollo Justice

Nick Nelson x Charlie Spring vs. Langa x Reki.

Firestar x Sandstorm vs. Reigen Arataka x Serizawa Katsuya

Princess Bubblegum x Marceline vs. Bowser x Luigi.

Spock x Kirk vs. Merlin x Arthur

Prince Sideon x Link vs. Aziraphel x Crowley

Todoroki x Deku vs. Steve x Bucky.

Tony the Tiger x The Grinch vs. Eda x Raine.

Edward Teach x Stede Bonnet vs. Ruby x Sapphire

Karkat x Dave vs. Catra x Adora.

Luz x Amity vs. Percy x Annabeth.

Miles Edgeworth x Phoenix Wright vs. Poison Ivy x Harley Quinn.

Rouis x Legoshi vs. Miles Morales x Gwen Stacy

Katya x Sophia vs. Viktor x Jayce.

Rey x Kylo Ren vs. The Onceler x The Onceler.

Susie x Noelle vs. Franziska Von Karma x Maya Fey.

Undyne x Alphys vs. Tao x Elle.

Dean x Castiel vs Hunter x Willow

Alex Fierro x Magnus Chase vs. Sans Undertale x Y/n.

Velma x Daphne vs. Ritsu x Shou.

Cecil x Carlos vs. Zagreus x Thanatos

Bakugo x Kirishima vs. Ava Silva x Sister Beatrice

Korra x Asami vs. Deku x Bakugo.

Viktor Nikiforov x Yuuri Katsuki vs. Mob x Teru.

Mabel Pines x Pacifica Northwest vs. Fred x Shaggy.

Sherlock Holmes x John Watson vs. Sans Undertale x Reigen Arataka

2 years ago
A monochrome drawing of Grian perched on Scar's shoulders over a red background with smoke. Scar is in his Double LIfe red skin holding TNT and Grian is holding out a pickaxe in front of him and a dripstone on his shoulder.

They are going to cause problems <3

  • mirrix
    mirrix reblogged this · 1 month ago
  • y2kwaves
    y2kwaves reblogged this · 6 months ago
  • liketwoswansinbalance
    liketwoswansinbalance liked this · 10 months ago
  • nutzo0001
    nutzo0001 liked this · 10 months ago
  • garebeary
    garebeary liked this · 11 months ago
  • fawn-moved
    fawn-moved liked this · 1 year ago
  • aliencomicinvasion
    aliencomicinvasion reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • maggot-withanf
    maggot-withanf reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • what-is-my-face
    what-is-my-face reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • catgirl9696
    catgirl9696 liked this · 1 year ago
  • catgirl9696
    catgirl9696 reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • cosimosis
    cosimosis liked this · 1 year ago
  • phantomroyalty
    phantomroyalty reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • rose-awsome26
    rose-awsome26 liked this · 1 year ago
  • phantomroyalty
    phantomroyalty liked this · 1 year ago
  • itscharliebabey
    itscharliebabey reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • fandom-and-other-stuff
    fandom-and-other-stuff reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • fandom-and-other-stuff
    fandom-and-other-stuff liked this · 1 year ago
  • maggot-withanf
    maggot-withanf reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • maggot-withanf
    maggot-withanf liked this · 1 year ago
  • goliath-de-senfina-sango
    goliath-de-senfina-sango liked this · 1 year ago
  • sockdooe
    sockdooe reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • sockdooe
    sockdooe liked this · 1 year ago
  • scarletsaphire
    scarletsaphire liked this · 1 year ago
  • well-only-mostly-dead
    well-only-mostly-dead liked this · 1 year ago
  • dysonbradleyreblogs
    dysonbradleyreblogs reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • lucky-dyse
    lucky-dyse liked this · 1 year ago
  • bubblegum-discoqueen
    bubblegum-discoqueen reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • puppetmaster55
    puppetmaster55 reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • thecountryofbritain
    thecountryofbritain liked this · 1 year ago
  • hauntedcreaatin
    hauntedcreaatin liked this · 1 year ago
  • jimikii
    jimikii liked this · 1 year ago
  • nerd-bastard
    nerd-bastard liked this · 1 year ago
  • reedthephcknmanual
    reedthephcknmanual reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • danelloevee
    danelloevee reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • fuj-ju
    fuj-ju liked this · 1 year ago
  • maruxee
    maruxee reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • maruxee
    maruxee liked this · 1 year ago
  • fluffharpy
    fluffharpy reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • laracroftess
    laracroftess liked this · 1 year ago
  • themazziah
    themazziah reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • themazziah
    themazziah liked this · 1 year ago
  • sol1056
    sol1056 reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • keiyoshi
    keiyoshi liked this · 1 year ago
  • afishtrap
    afishtrap reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • pampandinha
    pampandinha reblogged this · 1 year ago
emilyh1983 - Em’s Trash Bin
Em’s Trash Bin

423 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags