Listen, I Know It's Very Much A Thing That Utopian Leftists Think That Religions Will Simply Stop Existing

Listen, I know it's very much a thing that utopian leftists think that religions will simply stop existing once all of our material needs are met, but that is just not the case.

Human beings need ritual. If we are deprived of ritual, we make new ritual. It does not matter if you call it religion or state or whatever it is you call it, human beings will keep making up new rituals.

You cannot stop us, and saying 'this ritual which I like and doesn't hurt anyone else is fine, but that ritual which you like and doesn't hurt anyone else is bad' is just bigotry.

When I say 'you cannot stop us,' I literally mean you cannot stop human beings from making up rituals and religions. Leave a group of six year old girls alone near a mud pit for an hour and you will come back to a newly-minted faith. We make ritual. We make culture. That is what we do.

No, Judaism will not 'naturally cease to exist' when all of our material needs are met. What will happen then is that the Jews will get Jewier, because we will have all the time in the world to study Torah and write stories and make Jewish art. If you met all of my material needs tomorrow, two days from now there would be six more hamsas, a complete bound copy of all the volumes of the Talmud, and a shit-ton of giant Jewish art prints in my house.

You cannot stop people from making up culture and religion. It is, arguably, the thing which makes us human, one of the defining features of our collective humanity. We will always make up silly songs and new religions, and the idea that we'll just give all of that up for some vanilla yogurt and taupe jumpsuits utopian existence is absurd and beyond belief.

More Posts from Creaturebeeing and Others

2 years ago

See, while "gender is not inherently tied to sexuality" is true, I think it's a bit more complex than that. Often, you'll fond that society conflate gender and sexuality to the point that they influence each other, and that's important also to recognize.

My manhood isn't contradicted by my queerness, but I spent so many years feeling like I have failed as a man because societal manhood hinges on performing heterosexuality. It actually made me dysphoric to be queer because my manhood was already under scrutiny.

I've found that this is something cis queer guys and I have been able to bond over, though. Even though these guys are cis, their own manhood is just as criticized because of their queerness. They have been treated as lesser men or not even as men but gay men (derogatory). It's made me so much more aware of how fragile manhood can be if you base it on society rather than your own internal world.


Tags
2 years ago

i hate keyboards

I Hate Keyboards

Tags
2 years ago

not to Discourse but I’m a cis man and my partner is an afab enby and if you call us a “straight couple” I will personally come to your house tie you to a chair and make you listen to a podcast about gender identity on endless repeat


Tags
2 years ago

Hi! Gentile here, I've been reading your blog and find it very interesting + informative, thank you for being such a good source of information and explaining things so clearly and calmly despite all the nonsense you have to deal with.

I hope it's okay to ask this, since I understand it's a very solemn / sensitive subject. In a few of your posts that mention / discuss the Tetragrammaton, you mention that the knowledge of how to say or pronounce the name has been lost. As far as I understand, Hebrew has a phonemic orthography (ie each grapheme / letter corresponds to a phoneme / elementary sound unit). If that's the case, could one theoretically know how to pronounce the Tetragrammaton from combining the sounds those four letters make according to normal grammar / pronunciation rules, or is it the case that the knowledge of how to pronounce the Tetragrammaton exists independently of the knowledge of how to pronounce the constituent letters? Or is it something to do with how Hebrew orthography / phonology has changed over time, and modern Hebrew phonology wouldn't be accurate to the pronunciation as it would have existed before the fall of the second temple? Or is there a nuance in Hebrew orthography / phonology I'm missing?

I understand of course you wouldn't *want* to say it out loud anyway given how sacred and taboo it is, I suppose I'm just curious at the semantic properties of the knowledge of the pronunciation. (If this ask is inappropriate or offensive, I sincerely apologise and please do not feel obliged to post it / reply to it.)

Hi there, thanks so much for your kind words and happy Friday!

So there’s a few things at play here, because you are right, generally speaking, the Hebrew alphabet is a phonemic orthography which would generally lend itself to being pronounceable even in the absence of unbroken oral teaching (leaving aside theological and cultural boundaries on doing so, for the moment). But there are a few confounding factors:

1) Hebrew, both ancient and modern, doesn’t have vowels in its alphabet. To indicate vowels typically it uses nekudot, but that’s not done in texts meant to be read by fluent adult speakers/readers and Jewish holy texts don’t contain them. So we don’t have hard evidence of what vowels go with the Tetragrammaton’s consonants.

2) Some of the consonants in the Tetragrammaton can be used to indicate the presence of certain vowels, but they don’t always get used that way. So there’s no way to know of their presence specifically indicates those vowels or they’re being used purely as consonants and it’s coincidence.

3) Pronunciation of some vowels and consonants, although it does not seem to have been a substantial shift, has changed over time (and not in uniform ways, because of the diaspora).

So certainly scholars fluent in the various ancient forms of Hebrew can make educated hypotheses, but there are confounding factors. And, of course, because of the theological and cultural restrictions on the speaking/writing of the Tetragrammaton there is no unbroken tradition we can look at to confirm any of those educated guesses. And that’s before we even get to the limited number of Jewish scholars who are even willing to try to discern pronunciation of the Tetragrammaton for religious reasons.


Tags
2 years ago
Happy St. Patrick’s Day! As A Person Of Predominantly Irish American Heritage, I’ve Had Many An Argument
Happy St. Patrick’s Day! As A Person Of Predominantly Irish American Heritage, I’ve Had Many An Argument
Happy St. Patrick’s Day! As A Person Of Predominantly Irish American Heritage, I’ve Had Many An Argument
Happy St. Patrick’s Day! As A Person Of Predominantly Irish American Heritage, I’ve Had Many An Argument

Happy St. Patrick’s Day! As a person of predominantly Irish American heritage, I’ve had many an argument w/ my more racist family members about the wildly inaccurate story they tell themselves in an effort to be victims and invalidate Black Americans’ true experiences of racism and the legacy of slavery. So just spreading a dose of reality today!

Source from Instagram


Tags
1 year ago

Edit: someone reminded me I can just put a link, so here you go. I'm not deleting the how-to stuff, because I'm lazy, lmao.

Anyway, link is here

I have found a place where I (an American) can legally watch Doctor Who classic for free! Thought I'd share it!

I don't know if it has the missing episodes that have been redone, but it has all of the of her episodes as well as the movies.

Edit: It has an unaired pilot and bonus videos of different things. Will edit more as I find out more.

There's a website, Internet Archive, and I've found where the BBC has released them by season!

For those who need it, under the cut is just how to get to it!

You need an account on Internet Archive, but they're free.

Once you're logged in, you can get to all the seasons if you first search up "Doctor Who Classic Season 1," which should being up the first season,of course.. Then you click that.

Edit: Someone Reminded Me I Can Just Put A Link, So Here You Go. I'm Not Deleting The How-to Stuff, Because

Then scroll down a little and click the "British Broadcasting Corporation" hyperlink below the video.

Edit: Someone Reminded Me I Can Just Put A Link, So Here You Go. I'm Not Deleting The How-to Stuff, Because

Then you'll be brought to all the stuff they've put out.

Go to the left of the screen to the filters and go to the "media type" filter and click "movies" (which really means video).

Edit: Someone Reminded Me I Can Just Put A Link, So Here You Go. I'm Not Deleting The How-to Stuff, Because

It'll reload with that filter applied and once it's done that, go back to filters and filter by "subject" and click the "doctor who" filter.

Edit: Someone Reminded Me I Can Just Put A Link, So Here You Go. I'm Not Deleting The How-to Stuff, Because

And then you'll have them! The seasons are out of order, but they're all there.

I don't know if missing episodes that have been recreated are on there. But the rest definitely is.

So, it should look like this!

Edit: Someone Reminded Me I Can Just Put A Link, So Here You Go. I'm Not Deleting The How-to Stuff, Because

And then just find the season you want, pick the episode you want, and watch the show!

2 years ago

I think we're all really scared right now. If you live in a high risk area, and if you can, make sure you have all your important documents where you can easily access them, get a passport, etc. Make preparations if you potentially have to get out.


Tags
2 years ago

Help a disabled trans man live

Help A Disabled Trans Man Live

I have a couple of job interviews coming up in the near future but I still need to pay my rent and groceries, I also have a hefty medical bill hanging over me.

If you can't donate then please share!

cashapp: $vredia

venmo: @vredia

$40/600


Tags
2 years ago

i love being t4t I love gender nonconformity... i love girls who arent girls and women who are men and people with a million xenogenders and dykefags and femme trans men and butch trans girls. nothing is sexier than someone who spits in the face of the gender binary, and our very existence is not conforming to gender ideals


Tags
Loading...
End of content
No more pages to load
  • starburst-motif
    starburst-motif liked this · 3 weeks ago
  • thekeyring
    thekeyring liked this · 1 month ago
  • sunlitbones
    sunlitbones liked this · 1 month ago
  • talisman975
    talisman975 reblogged this · 2 months ago
  • welcome-home-official
    welcome-home-official reblogged this · 2 months ago
  • flaming-orca-lilly
    flaming-orca-lilly reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • flaming-orca-lilly
    flaming-orca-lilly liked this · 5 months ago
  • scoopstroopahoy
    scoopstroopahoy liked this · 5 months ago
  • dandelions-arent-weeds
    dandelions-arent-weeds liked this · 5 months ago
  • shittygaypornmagazine
    shittygaypornmagazine reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • shittygaypornmagazine
    shittygaypornmagazine liked this · 5 months ago
  • blue-ink-pearls
    blue-ink-pearls reblogged this · 6 months ago
  • yung-and-bludy
    yung-and-bludy reblogged this · 6 months ago
  • sionnachsskulk
    sionnachsskulk reblogged this · 6 months ago
  • thisbeathrowaway
    thisbeathrowaway liked this · 6 months ago
  • missingjadesnake687
    missingjadesnake687 liked this · 6 months ago
  • gwynthemoose
    gwynthemoose reblogged this · 6 months ago
  • gwynthemoose
    gwynthemoose liked this · 6 months ago
  • elinaviolets
    elinaviolets reblogged this · 6 months ago
  • elinaviolets
    elinaviolets liked this · 6 months ago
  • arinrowan
    arinrowan reblogged this · 6 months ago
  • itsben0
    itsben0 liked this · 7 months ago
  • yumeveggie
    yumeveggie reblogged this · 9 months ago
  • jeidai
    jeidai reblogged this · 9 months ago
  • aseariel
    aseariel reblogged this · 11 months ago
  • holyfuckthisfishcandrive
    holyfuckthisfishcandrive reblogged this · 11 months ago
  • pinkandgreenarepurpleandyellow
    pinkandgreenarepurpleandyellow reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • comp-lady
    comp-lady reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • blahh770
    blahh770 liked this · 1 year ago
  • panintegral002
    panintegral002 liked this · 1 year ago
  • bittylittlebat
    bittylittlebat reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • brightisthedawn
    brightisthedawn reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • scheherezhad
    scheherezhad reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • saekhwa
    saekhwa reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • redrarebit
    redrarebit reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • mac-n-cheese-flavored-arson
    mac-n-cheese-flavored-arson liked this · 1 year ago
  • weirdlumps
    weirdlumps liked this · 1 year ago
  • notactuallyatreefrog
    notactuallyatreefrog reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • theimaginatrix27
    theimaginatrix27 reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • predictament
    predictament reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • malevolent-pear
    malevolent-pear reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • malevolent-pear
    malevolent-pear liked this · 1 year ago
  • algirdasgiedraitis
    algirdasgiedraitis reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • algirdasgiedraitis
    algirdasgiedraitis liked this · 1 year ago
  • shiningroyalty
    shiningroyalty reblogged this · 1 year ago
creaturebeeing - i-might-bite
i-might-bite

237 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags